Corporations Flashcards
Does Corporation by Estoppel work for creditors?
No. Corporation by Estoppel applies to the specific transaction or the contract at hand. Used for contractual transaction only. (Fl4)
Corporation by Estoppel + 3rd Party
Prevents a 3rd party who has dealt with the corporation from avoiding a contract or trying to hold officers and S-H liable by alleging deficient formation. (Fl4)
Will a failure to have the Articles of Incorporation by SOS qualify as Substantial Performance?
No. A failure to have the Articles of Incorporation accepted by the SOS will generally Not qualify for Substantial Compliance. (Fl3)
Corporation by Estoppel (Is a defense) - Defined
A defect in incorporation can be serious enough to deny an entity De Jure and De Facto. Nevertheless, a person who dealt with the entity as though it was a corporation, may be estopped from denying the corporate validity. (Fl4)
What is the difference between De Jure and De Facto?
De Jure = Full or Substantial Compliance
De Facto = Colorable Compliance
F-A-C-P-A-U-F-E-D
FORMATION / ARTICLES OF INCORPORATION / CORPORATION BY ESTOPPEL / PIERCING THE CORPORATE VEIL / ALTER EGO / UNDERCAPITALIZATION / FRAUD / ESTOPPEL / DEEP ROCK DOCTRINE
De Jure Incorporation Defined
Full compliance or substantial compliance with mandatory conditions. (Fl3)
Creditors + Issues with Formation -
They are testing you on 3 Doctrines***
- De Jure
- De Facto
- Corporation by Estoppel
Bylaws
Govern how the corporation will operate (covers officer duties, voting, and procedure). (Fl3)
Registration - Private Placements
If an issuer wants to raise money without registering, then that issuer must have a exception from registration.
If a transaction is exempt, the process of raising money for the corporation conducting the exempt transaction is often referred to as “Private Placement”
TESTABLE ISSUE!
When a Corporation becomes Insolvent and Creditors
Creditors may attempt to hold S-Hs, officers, and directors liable if it can be found that there was a defect in incorporation due to a failure to comply literally with statutory procedures. (Fl3)
Colorable Compliance
A failure to have the Articles of Incorporation accepted by the SOS, but a good faith attempt may be held to constitute Colorable Compliance.
(issue with signature notarized or atty failes to file…) (Fl3)
De Facto Incorporation
(Colorable Compliance = defense)
Arises where there has been a good faith compliance with all mandatory conditions precedent to incorporation (Fl3)
Howey Test
Is it an Investment Contract?
- Contract, transaction or scheme a person invests money.
- Made into a common enterprise
- Expectation of profits
- With profits to come solely from the efforts of others.
What is Not a Security?
An investment in a general partnership (because by definition it is Not the efforts of others)
…but a limited partner in a Limited Partnership might be a security since limited partners do not participate in management.
Characteristics of typical securities
- Right to receive dividends upon an apportion of profits.
- Negotiability
- Ability to be pledged or hypothecated
- Voting rights that accompany an instrument and correspond to the # of shares
- Ability to appreciate in value.
Shareholder Liability v. Personal Liability…
Shareholders are not ‘personally’ liable for the actions of the corporation. (Bk35)
What are Shareholder Suits?
Sometimes to enforce a right or to protect an investment, a shareholder resorts to a lawsuit. (Whit595)
What are the 2 Categories of Shareholder Suits?
- Direct suits by shareholders on their own behalf;
- Derivative suits on behalf of the corporation. (Whit595)
Name some types of Shareholder Suits (on their own behalf)
- to enforce the right to vote
- to sue for breach o a shareholder agreement
- to enforce the right to inspect corporate books and records
- to compel the payment of lawfully declared dividends
- to protect preemptive rights
- to compel corporate dissolution. (Whit595)
What are some examples of Derivative Suits?
- to recover damages resulting from an ultra vires act
- to bar corporate officials from breaching their fiduciary duty to the corporation
- to recover improperly paid dividends
- to bar outsiders from wrongdoing the corporation or to recover from such a wrong. (Whit595)
What is the role of the Board of Directors?
Board of Directors is the supreme power in the management of the corporation. (Whit595)
The Duty of Care is related to what other Rule?
Business Judgment Rule.
Duty of Care elements for a Board member?
a. An officer or director shall discharge his/her duties…
…in good faith…
…with the care an ordinary prudent person in a like position would exercise…
…in a manner he/she reasonably believes to be in the best interests of the corporation. (Whit599)
Can a shareholder give away a stock in death?
A Shareholder may give corporate stock to another after death just as he or she could have given that stock away while alive. (Whit547)
Meritocratic
Chosen by virtue of ability. (Whit547)
Corporation by Estoppel
Prevents a party who has dealt with the corporation from avoiding the contract or holding officers or shareholders liable by alleging deficient formation.
Consequence of Defective Formation
Common law treated the corporation as a Partnership and applied joint & several liability.
-Modernly liability imposed on shareholder who participated and liable for it. * Breach of Implied Warranty of Authority.
TESTABLE - What happens if the attorney negligently fails to file the Articles of Incorporation on time?
We have the Defense of a De Facto (Colorable) formation. This is an equity defense. (Do note that the state itself can seek action). (Fl)
Decision of the Board of Directors
-Typically, courts will not interfere with the decisions of a corporation’s Board of Directors.
-The Board of Directors will have the protection of the BJR.
-In order to prevail in an action, plaintiff will need to show that the BJR does not apply by showing: fraud, illegality, conflict of interest, bad faith, waste, egregious or irrational decision-making, no decision-making or uniformed decision.
HOW TO WRITE: There is no indication of fraud or other malfeasance
“In this instance, there is no indication of fraud, bad faith,….A conflict of interest involves; financial/familial conflict….
-In addition there ‘was’ an actual decision.
HOW TO WRITE - claim on a decision of the Board of Directors
“This leaves only a few elements on which the plaintiff might make his case. Plaintiff might attempt to argue….. that the decision to…. is irrational, egregious and/or waste….However, the Board of Directors had a business justification for their action. They though (action) would be good…….”