Corporate Formation & Structure Flashcards
What is a Corporation?
A corporation is a legal person or entity that has an existence that is separate from its owners (shareholders), and is formed by filing a written instrument (certificate of incorporation or articles of incorporation) in an appropriate state office (secretary of state).
What are the 5 characteristics of a Corporation?
1) Limited Liability-Shareholders only have limited liability for corporate obligations and are thus not personally liable for actions by corporate managers. Shareholders are not personally liable only if they (1) acted on behalf of the corporation and (2) the act was within their authority.
2) Free Transferability of Ownership Interests- In publicly held corporations’ shares of stock (ownership interests) are freely transferable without consent of other parties. (Transferee has rights of a shareholder, but only hold an economic interest)
3) Perpetual Existence- The legal existence of a corporation is eternal unless specified.
4) Centralized Management- In publicly held corporations the power to manage the business of the corporations is vested to the board of directors. Shareholders have no management rights only have the power to elect the board.
5) Entity Status- Corporations can exercise power and have rights in its own name. Recognizes as separate from its owners. (Can sue and be sued)(legal entity) A Corporation is a legal entity that can sue and be sued & own property.
Differences between choice of business entities
- Centralized or Decentralized Management
- Limited liability-partners have only limited liability and do not have full access to power and control. In a corporation, shareholders have no managerial rights (give up rights). A Corporation is managed by the Board of Directors.
- Transferability of Interest-Separates corporations from other business entities. If you take all rights of the share in a incorporated business it is assigned to the new owner.
- Taxation (1)Corporations are taxed twice on money that they make (Double Taxation) Taxed on its income, and its employees.
(2) There are no taxes on Partnerships, contribute the income of the company to the individual partners.
(3) An LLC that is unincorporated can choose whether to be taxed as a partnership or corporation.
(4) State (margin tax)-All of the business entities(except those comprised of real people) have to pay a franchise tax.
How are corporations formed under TBOC?
- Corporations are filing entities that only the state can create. 1.002(22)
i. Formed using a Certificate of Formation & complying with 3.001(a)
ii. Existence begins when a Certificate of Formation is filled under 3.001(b)
a. Organizers
b. Must have legal capacity
c. Sign CoF
d. and Mail to SoS with various fees
Types of Corporate Securites
- Corporate shares represent a pro-rata ownership of a corporation.
- There are two types of shares Common v Preferred (Shares w/ special rights created by certificate)
i. Preferred shares have special lives created by the CoF. Has to be specified by CoF. If not then the shares are common
i. Usually preferred can’t vote unless 1% owner
ii. Sometimes they can vote as a class, depends on the state law
iii. Same rights unless Certificate limits or grants (All shares are created equal to the extent certificate amends)
Under TBOC what must a COF contain? 3.005
- Type of filing entity (Must state that corporation or other business entity is being created)
- Name
i. Cant be identical or deceptive similar to another filing entity (5.053)
ii. Name must be distinguished; cannot be the name of another Corporation. Call SoS or look up online to determine if name is available.
iii. Can’t include the word lotto or lottery in the business name (5.061). Can’t be veteran related name. - Must contain “Company” “Corporation”, “Inc” or abbreviation
- Must state purpose (any “lawful” purpose)
i. What is the purpose? Why are we doing this? - General Prohibited Purposes
i. Unlawful activity
ii. Cant operate as a bank, trust co, or insurance co,
iii. For profit co: cannot be a co-op or labor union
iv. Cannot raise cattle and own land
v. Be in the business of stockyards & slaughtering
vi. Be in the business of oil producing and pipeline
vii. Business that requires a license that cannot be issued to a corporation.
VantagePoint Venture Partners v Examen Inc.
Dispute about voting rights of shareholders who held preferred stock and whether to use Del or Ca law. Court held that a corporation’s internal affairs are determined solely by the law of the state in which it was incorporated.
Internal Affairs Doctrine
a. Common Law principal-only the jurisdiction/state of incorporation has the authority to regulate a corporation’s internal affairs.
b. Applies to relationships b/w the corporation, it’s officers, directors, and shareholders.
c. TBOC 1.101: Texas law applies to corporations formed by filing in Texas
1. Formation
2. Internal affairs – 1.105
i. Rights, powers ,& duties governing authority, governing persons, officers owners and members
ii. Matters relating to membership of ownership interests
3. 1.104 liability of owners, etc. for obligations
4. In other words the state of incorporation regulates what happens within a corporation
Con Law v Choice of Law
I) Con Law v. Choice of Law
a. Choice of Law Only
1. Forum state choice of law (usually applies)
2. CA statute dictates choice of law
3. Forum shopping
4. Factors: certainty, predictability, uniformity of result, and ease of application of the law
b. Constitutional Principle
1. No Forum shopping
b. Constitutional Law
1. Due process 14th-gives directors and officers of a corporation a significant right to know what law will be applied to their actions.
2. Commerce Clause-a state has no interest regulating the internal affairs of foreign corporations, unless a rare situation.
3. Internal Affairs Rule is the rule
b. Why Internal Affairs Doctrine?
1. Consistency/Uniformity
2. Expectations-Delaware determines their rights and liabilities
i. Corporation
ii. S/Hs
iii. Directors (Ds)
iv. Officers (Os)
Why do Corporations choose Delaware?
- Choice for most publicly-held corporations
- Legislature keeps statute up-to-date
- Specialized courts
- Chancery: equitable
- Commercial Law Courts (new!)
- Expedited appeals to Del Supreme Ct.
- More cases
Delaware CoF requirements?
3.005
a. Type of filing entity (corporation)
b. Name
i. Must contain “Company” Corporation” “Incorporated” or abbreviation. 5.054
ii. Can’t be identical or deceptive similar to another filing entity. 5.053
iii. Can’t include: lotto or lottery (5.061) veteran-related (5.062)
c. Duration, if not to be perpetual
d. Name of registered agent and street address of that agent (registered office, no PO Boxes)
e. Name and address of each organizer
f. Names and address of managers(Name individually & give addresses)
i. Members of Board of Directors or
ii. Others if shareholder agreement requires
g. Must state purpose (can be “any lawful purpose”) 3.005(a)(3)
h. General prohibited purposes (all filing entities). 2.003 [On TEST]
1. Unlawful business or activity
2. Can’t lawfully be engaged in by that entity
3. Operate as bank, trust company, savings association, insurance company or cemetery organization
4. For-profit corps: Not co-op and not labor union 2.007(1)
5. Prohibited combinations 2.007(2)&(3)
i. Raising cattle and owning land to do so (except owning feedlots & feeding cattle)
ii. Stockyards and slaughtering, refrigerating, canning curing, packing meats
iii. Oil producing & oil pipeline (except thru subsidiaries)
6. 2.007(3): Business that require a license that cannot be issued to a corporation (practice law, doctors)
Filing a CoF in Delaware reqs:
a. 4.01: Organizers sign Certificate of Formation & deliver to SoS
b. 4.02: SoS
1. Determines if certificate conforms to the law, all fees paid, THEN
2. Files (accepts into filing system)
3. Delivers written acknowledgement of filing to entity or its representative
4. Won’t be effective until FILED or a later date if you choose so
5. Will notify you if effective, and give duplicates if asked
c. 4.051: effective on filing (except for delayed effectiveness, 4.052)
- 059 Organizational Meeting of BOD required after certification is filled
a. Have to give least 3 days notice to directors (others)
b. Adopt bylaws
c. Elect officers
d. Other business as necessary - Authorize issuance of shares, set price to be received(21.157-.162)
- Accept pre-formation subscriptions (21.165-.167)
- Banking resolutions (signature cards)
i. Bank is going to want signature card filled out that will be signed by CEO
ii. Need a place to put money earned from Corporation - Once money comes in for shares you will issue the shares
Pre-Formation Contracts Liability of a Corporation
Problem
Day-7-A signs Contract 1
Day 0-organized sign o/f & mail to SOS
Day 7-B signs Contract 2
Day 8-C/F returned unfilled name/consent
- Contract signed before corporation is legally formed
- Corp has no liability
- Unless the Corp agrees to be liable after it comes into being
- A would be liable
- Unless third party releases them
- A, B and C were working as Partners/General Partners or A was a sole proprietor
- Person who signed contract before formation is liable
- at execution
- at formation
- and after adoption
- Unless released by third party
Pre-Formation Contracts Liability of Corporation
- Contract is signed before corporation is legally formed and before Corporation exists as a legal entity
Liability of Corporation
- Not liable at time of contracting
- Not liable on formation
- Only after adoption of contract
- not ratification
- Express or implied by conduct
Pre-Formation Contracts liability of Agents
• An agent is a person who signed contract in name of corporation before corporation was formed
Personally liable for contract • at execution • after formation • and adoption • Unless released by Third Party
Pre-formation Contracts liability of Owners
- Business operating in fact pre-formation
- What is the “form” of that business?
- Liability of Owners?
- No limited liability at common law
- General Partnership
- Only non-filing entity
- Only common-law multi-owner form
- No corporation => owners => partners
- Partners liable for all “firm” obligations
Two equity alternatives to avoid personal liability of a Corporation.
- Defacto Corporation-treats Corporations as existing even though it does not exist at law
- Corporation by Estoppel-Look to context of Corporation; 3rd party claiming that Corp cannot enforce because it doesn’t exist.
Cts will likely rule that Corp is established by de facto. Use of defacto doctrine as a shield against liability.
Defacto Corporations
• Defacto Corporation(Valid in fact but not necessary valid at law)
o Defacto (in fact) vs. de jure (at law)
• T/P trying to avoid liability by arguing DFC
- - Contracts
- - Taxes by defective municipal corporations, unity districts
• Agents & S/hs try to avoid liability by claiming it was a DFC
- Distinguish contexts for applying de facto corporation doctrine
- Even though a corp can only exist at law it existed and it also doesn’t matter that the 3rd party didn’t know it wasn’t a corp
o Effect of defacto doctrine?
• If court adopts defecto argument
• Corporation exists “in fact” (as to T/P),
• Contracts are not pre-formation
• Agents are not liable if fully disclosed principal
• Owners not liable as general partners
• Corporation is liable
Defacto Test
• Statute for limited liability entity
• T/p must make colorable (Good Faith) attempt to comply
• Corporate agents must actually use the corporate franchise
- - Attempt Limited Liability
- - Sign in corporate name (Inc., Corp., Co.)
• T/P dealt with corporation & NOT individuals
- - Signed in corporate name
o Defacto Statute
• MBCA rejected:
• Easy argument for T/p to claim Corp was incorporated
• Vague what exactly are Corp acts
• “Too old its not 1890 anymore!!”(Not hard to communicate with other people)
• Language: “act as a corporation”
- - Anyone who “acts as a corporation” even though you have not filed in the state you are jointly liable for the acts of the business
• –passive owners not acting, not liable(Passive owner may not necessarily be liable under statute)
• RMCBA: only if “knowingly” acted, will you be liable for the acts of a corporation
o Courts still like it
o Statute protects would be limited liability partnerships
Some cts have still adopted Defacto in some context.
Corporation by Estoppel
When a party engages in misleading conduct; and causes another party to rely on that conduct, to which reasonably believe them; creating a detrimental change of position. The first party is estopped from asserting that matters aren’t as represented.
Estops Corp agent from arguing that no corporation existed.
o Misleading conduct by T/P?
• Don’t promoters (agents mislead as to existence of corporation?
• Don’t’ corp. wannabe’s mislead?
• Contracted for corp & not personal liability(individuals) Look to corporation and not to individuals
- - T/P knowledge corp status?
• Reasonable belief by “Promoters”?
• Had the Corp taken GF steps to incorporate?
• How hard is it to for them to find out they can check the Sec. of State online
Defacto v Estoppel. Who should bear risk?
• Best leave-cost avoider? (Incorporators)
• If you are going to sign a k with a Corporation you should check with Sec of State to get notice to make sure Corporation is existing
• Defacto = estoppel? Estoppel essentially the same argument as defacto…
– Statute rejects defacto, so Estoppel is most logical argument for T/p.
Texas Consequences of defective incorporation
- Texas Tax Code 171.255 says:
a. Corp. forfeits right to do business because not filing reports/paying taxes
b. Ds & Os who keep doing business as a corporation despite forfeiture :
i. Personally liable (a) as partners
(b) for debts created/incurred
ii. After forfeiture and before revival
iii. Remain liable after revival
Defenses to Texas 171.255
a. Not liable if D/O can show debt created or incurred
i. Over D/O’s objection or
ii. Without D/O’s knowledge, but only if can show
iii. reasonable diligence re corp’s affairs
iv. would not have revealed intent to create debt