Core Ideas/Principles Flashcards
PRAGMATISM
How does Michael Oakeshott summarise this concept?
‘To be a Conservative is to prefer the tried to the untried’
PRAGMATISM
What is the official definition of ‘pragmatism’?
rejects ideology and theory in favour of decisions made on the basis of practical experience and ‘what works’
PRAGMATISM
Why do traditional conservatives feel that ideas such as ‘classless society’ and ‘human right’s are dangerous?
they can promote a radical reordering of society
lead to worse rather than better conditions
PRAGMATISM
What approach does it have to politics?
flexible
what is in the best interests of the people, what is acceptable to the public and what will maintain social stability and cohesion
PRAGMATISM
What strands of conservatism are associated with pragmatism?
traditional and one-nation
PRAGMATISM
Why do conservatives prefer pragmatism (reference their view of human nature)?
they think humans lack the intellectual ability and powers of reasoning to fully comprehend the complex realities of the world
PRAGMATISM
How to conservatives try to avoid sticking to? How do they prefer to act?
rigid ideological approach to issues
prefer to act in a pragmatic way that emphasises caution, moderation and sense of historical continuity
PRAGMATISM
How is Edmund Burke (and traditional conservatives) related to this concept?
he argued that it was an essential element in facilitating ‘natural’/inevitable change (‘change to conserve’ policy)
‘a state without the means of some change is without the means of its conservation’
PRAGMATISM
Why do traditional conservatives favour pragmatism over relvolution?
pragmatism brings about NECESSARY change peacefully and through evolution
the unbending pursuit of revolution or reaction leads to conflict and chaos.
PRAGMATISM
What to one nation conservatives think of pragmatism?
they hold similar attitudes to traditional conservatives
PRAGMATISM
Where haev one nation conservatives reently adopted a policy of prgamatism? Why?
pragmatic ‘middle way’ approach to the economy
combining market competition with government regulation
why - they argue that this moderate economic course promotes growth and social harmony. it promotes wealth creation through priavate enterprise.
PRAGMATISM
Why do traditional conservatives maintain their ‘change to conserve’ policy?
to safeguard the essential features of society
e.g. property, order, tradition, established institutions.
PRAGMATISM
What does ‘change to conserve’ necessarily mean?
established institutions (and other key features of society) can only be preserved through pragmatism when it takes changing circumstances into account
it msut recognise occasions when it is necessary to change
e.g. Brexit, gay marriage in chruches etc.
TRADITION
What does this concept refer to? Who is it associated with?
attachment to tradition - the institutions, customs and practices of a society that have developed over time
G.K. Chesterton
TRADITION
What is the original justification for tradition?
religious roots
they saw the world as created by divine being, and society’s institution and practices as ‘God-given’
humans who want to alter this are challenging the will of God
TRADITION
What are the 2 secular arguments for the value of tradition (following the Enlightenment which undermined the religious reasoning)?
- tradition constitutes the accumulated wisdom of the past
2. provides society and the individual with a strong sense of identity
TRADITION
How does tradition represent the ‘accumulated wisdom of the past’?
- future generation can benefit from it
- tradition establishes continuity and social stability (Monarchy)
- demonstrate they are ‘fit for purpose’ over time (marriage/nuclear family)
TRADITION
How does tradition provide a ‘sense of identity’?
historically based sense of belonging to a particular society
- fosters social cohesion and powerful ties between people
- radical changes will cut people off and lead to instability
HUMAN IMPERFECTION
What is the conservative view of human nature?
pessimistic
people are flawed
and people are incapable of reaching a state of perfection
HUMAN IMPERFECTION
Why does human nature have to be kept in check?
human nature is immutable (remains constant)
it has to be kept in check due to human capacity for evil
HUMAN IMPERFECTION
What are the political implications of this pessimistic view?
- tough stance on law
TO DETER CRIMINAL BEHAVIOUR - foreign policy based on national security rather than international cooperation and harmony
HUMAN NATURE CANNOT BE TRANSFORMED - political systems will recognise self-interest as more powerful motivator than altruism
HUMAN BEHAVIOUR IS COMPETITIVE
HUMAN IMPERFECTION
What are the 3 ways humans are flawed?
PSYCHOLOGICALLY:
e.g. limited and dependent
crave security and safety
want familiarity of place in society
MORALLY
e.g. naturally selfish and greedy
INTELLECTUALLY
e.g. intellect and reasoning of humans are limited
do not possess the mental faculties to make sense of complex modern world