Contracts & Sales Flashcards
What is a contract?
A legally enforceable agreement
What is an express contract?
What is an implied contract?
Express contract
- Contract that results from words
Implied contract
- Contract that results from conduct which a reasonable person would infer a promise to pay
What is a quasi-contract?
It is not a contract. It is the remedy granted when the following elements exist:
- P has conferred a benefit on D
- P reasonably expected to be paid
- D would realize unjust enrichment if P is not compensated
What is the measure of recovery under quasi-contract?
It may, as justice requires, be measured by either:
- Reasonable value of the services rendered (i.e., quantum meruit)
- Extent to which other party’s property increased in value or his other interests were advanced
Note: the contract price is not the measure of recovery, but it may be a ceiling
What is a bilateral contract?
Contract formed from an offer that is open as to the method of acceptance (i.e., can return a promise or just perform)
What is a unilateral contract?
Contract formed from an offer that requires performance as the method of acceptance
Two examples on bar exam:
- Offer that expressly requires performance
- Offer of a reward
When does Article 2 of the UCC apply?
Sale of goods
Definitions
- Sale
- Passing title from seller to buyer for a price
- Goods
- Personal property
How do you determine whether the UCC applies in a hybrid contract (i.e., involves goods and services)?
Majority (including Virginia)
-
Predominant purpose test
- If the contract primarily involves goods, the UCC applies to the entire contract
- Factors:
- Price of goods v. services
- Amount of labor involved
- Sophistication of labor
- Does contract contains typical sales language?
A contract is more than an agreement. What does that mean?
It must be legally enforceable
What is an offer?
Manifestation of the intent to be bound by contract
Objective test:
- Would a reasonable person believe that his or her assent created a contract?
- Do not focus on the person’s subjective intention
Generally, what are the essential elements of an offer?
- Identity of the offeree
- Subject matter
- Price to be paid
- Time of payment, delivery, or performance
- Quantity involved
- Nature of work involved
The more that terms are left open, the more likely it is that courts will view the communication as mere preliminary negotiations
When can price be left out of a contract?
When is it required?
Real estate contract
- Required
- Because real estate is unique
UCC sale of goods
- Not required
- Because goods are fungible
Can a court fill in vague or material terms in a contract?
No. Both common law and the UCC this makes the contract insufficiently definite and clear
When will the courts imply the quantity for a contract?
Requirements contract
- Buyer agrees to buy all of its good faith requirements
Output contract
- Buyer agrees to buy all of the seller’s good faith output
Limitations
- Must be reasonably proportionate to either:
- Stated estimate
- Normal or comparable prior requirements/output
Is an advertisement an offer?
Generally, no.
Exceptions:
- An advertisement is an offer if it:
- Is specific to quantity
- Indicates who can accept
- __An advertisement is an offer it it:
- Is in the nature of a reward
Is a price quotation an offer?
Only if it is sent in response to an inquiry
E.g., catalog sent after purchaser says, “I need ten of these, how much will you sell them for?”
What is the offer in an auction?
What is the effect of a reserve price?
The bid, not the auctioneer asking for bids
An auction is with reserve unless the terms state otherwise
Auction without reserve
- Auctioneer obligated to accept highest bid
How does an offer terminate?
- Lapse of time
- Revocation
- Rejection
- Death
If no time is expressed for acceptance of an offer, after how long will the offer terminate?
After a reasonable time under the circumstances
- 2 years - yes
- 2 weeks - probably
- 2 days - no
How does a party revoke an offer?
-
Statement to the offeree
- Indicating an unwillingness to contract
-
Conduct of the offeror
- That is inconsistent with an intention to contract
- And the offeror is aware of the conduct
- Must be reliable
How do you revoke a public offer?
Give notice of termination with equal publicity to that given by the offer
When does revocation become effective?
When the revocation is received (i.e., mailbox rule does not apply)
When can a party revoke?
Anytime before acceptance, unless:
- Option contract
- Promise to keep offer open
- Supported by consideration
- UCC firm offer
- Contract for the sale of goods
- Written promise to keep offer open
- Made by a merchant
- Reliance
- Must be reasonably foreseeable
- Performance
- Must be on a unilateral contract only
- Must be more than mere preparation
Who is a merchant?
A person who either:
- Deals in good of the kind
- Holds himself out as having knowledge/skill particular to the goods
For how long does the UCC firm offer rule keep an offer open?
What if the promise doesn’t state a time period?
No more than 3 months, in the absence of additional consideration
If the promise doesn’t state a time period, it is a reasonable time less than or equal to 3 months
How does a party reject an offer?
- Expressly
- Counteroffer (but not mere bargaining)
- Conditional acceptance
- Acceptance with additional terms (but not under UCC)
- Acceptance with conflicting terms (but not under UCC)
Under the UCC, when do additional terms become part of the contracts?
When:
- Both parties are merchants
- Additional terms do not materially alter the contract
- Offeror does not object within reasonable time
Otherwise:
- Agreed terms become part of the contract
- Disagreed terms are left out
Does adding an arbitration clause materially alter a contract?
Majority
- YES
Minority
- Depending on industry standard, maybe not
Under the UCC, what happens when conflicting terms are added to a contract?
-
Knock out rule
- The conflicting terms cancel eachother out, and the UCC filles in the gaps
When does the death of a party not terminate the offer?
- Option contract
- Part performance of unilateral contract
Who can accept an offer?
Only the person to whom the offer was made, and they must be aware of it
So, the power to accept cannot be assigned
But, an option can be assigned unless it says otherwise
How can you accept an offer?
- Performance
- Unilateral contract - performance must be complete
- Bilateral contract - performance must begin
- Promise to perform
When can acceptance be done by mail?
When is it effective?
Acceptance by mail is reasonable if:
- Offer is by mail
- Customary in similar transactions at time and place
Mailbox rule
- Acceptance by mail is effective when posted (i.e., dropped in mailbox)
What is the difference in terms of the effectiveness of acceptance and revocation?
Revocation - effective when received
Acceptance - effective when posted
What are the exceptions to the mailbox rule?
- Rejection mailed first, rejection received first
- Acceptance is a counteroffer
- Acceptance mailed first, rejection received first
- If offeror relied on rejection, estoppel may apply
- Option deadline
- Acceptance must be received by deadline (i.e., mailbox rule does not apply)
If a party sends the wrong goods in response to an offer, do they accept?
Generally, yes
- Noncomforming goods is an acceptance and a breach
Exception:
- Accomodation
- If shipper makes it clear that the noncomforming goods are an accomodation, that is a counteroffer
Can silence be acceptance?
Generally, no.
Exception:
- When reasonable to interpret silence as acceptance based on prior course of conduct/past dealings
What are the elements of consideration?
- Promisee must suffer legal detriment
- Detriment must induce promise
- Promise must induce detriment
What are the different forms of legal detriment?
- Performance
- Doing something not legally obligated to do
- Forbearance
- Not doing something legally obligated to do
- Promise to perform
- Promise to forbear
What is a conditional gift?
Does it constitute consideration?
When promisor intends to make a gift that is conditioned on promisee doing something that doesn’t benefit promisor
It does not satisfy consideration because it is not a bargained-for-exchange
What is the rule regarding past consideration?
This is not valid consideration
It results in an unenforceable gratuitious promise
What is the rule regarding moral obligations and consideration?
- A moral obligation is not a substitute for consideration
When is consideration adequate?
Courts generally do not inquire to th eadequacy of consideration
If the consideration is grossly inadequate, there may be some flaw in the bargaining process, such as:
- Fraud
- Duress
- Incapacity
What is the rule regarding pre-existing duties and consideration?
Common law
- Performing a pre-existing duty is not consideration for a new promise unless:
- Duty owed to a third person (not promisor)
- Unforeseen difficulty renders performance vitally different than was was originally agreed upon
UCC Article 2
-
Additional consideration not required for modification if:
- The party modifying acts in good faith
When can partial payment be consideration for a promise to forgive the balance of debt?
Only when the debt is either:
- Not yet due
- Disputed
E.g., the release of the remaining balance is enforceable if the promisor pays any amount that is either disputed or not due
When can the promise to pay for a settlement be enforceable?
As long as the party giving up the claim in good faith believes it is a valid claim
Is a promise to pay debt barred by the statute of limitations enforceable?
Only if it is written, and only to the extent of the new promise, and not the original balance due
What is an illusory promise?
Does it constitute consideration in exchange for another promise?
It is a promise in form, but not in substance
It is not consideration for the other promise
E.g., I will buy your house if I decide I want it
Who lacks capacity to contract?
-
Infants (minors)
- Persons under 18 years old
-
Mental incompetents
- Person who is either:
- Unable to understand in a reasonable manner nature and consequences of transaction
- Unable to act in a reasonable manner in relation to the transaction
- Person who is either:
-
Intoxicated persons
- __Other party has reason to know that:
- By reason of intoxication
- The person is unable to either:
- Understand in a reasonable manner nature and consequences of transaction
- Act in a reasonable manner in relation to the transaction
- __Other party has reason to know that:
What are the consequences of incapacity?
The contract is voidable - i.e., incapacitated party can disaffirm
Can a contract ever be enforced against a minor?
Yes, under the quasi-contract theory if the contract is for necessaries - i.e., items that the minor needs in order to live
Whether soemthing is a necessary is a question of fact
What contracts fall within the statue of frauds?
“MY LEGS”
- Contract in consideration of marriage
- Contract that cannot be performed within one year
- Promise creating interest in land
- Promise by executor or administrator to pay own funds
- Contract for the sale of goods $500 or more
- Promise to act as a surety for the debt of another
What makes a marriage contract subject to the statute of frauds?
Must be a promise in consideration of marriage (not just a promise to marry)
What makes an executor promise subject to the statute of frauds?
Must be a promise by executor to pay his own funds for an obligation of the estate
What makes a surety contract subject to the statute of frauds?
Must be a promise to the creditor
Not a promise to the debtor
Not a novation - i.e., a promise to immediately pay the full debt
What is the main purpose rule with respect to the statute of frauds?
If a promise to pay the debt of another is for the main purpose of the promisor, it is not within the statute of frauds
E.g., main shareholder promises to act as a surety on the debt of the corporation
Is a contract within the statute of frauds if it is for multi-year employment, but can be terminated anytime?
Majority - yes
Minority - no
Is a contract to employ someone for life within the statute of frauds?
No. The person could possibly die within the year
Is a contract to grant an easement within the statute of frauds?
Only if the easement will last longer than a year
Is a lease contract within the statute of frauds?
Only if the lease is for more than a year
What is the equal dignity rule with respect to the statute of frauds?
If a contract is subject to the statute of frauds, and therefore must be in writing, you must have a writing in order to authorize someone else to sign it for you
When does the modification of a contract fall within the statute of frauds?
When both:
- Contract, as modified, falls within the statute of frauds
- Modified terms are essential to the contract
If a contract provides that all modifications have to be in writing, does a modification have to be in writing to satisfy the statute of frauds even if he contract would not fall within the statute of frauds as modified?
Common law
- Provision requiring written modification is ignored
UCC
- Provision requiring written modification is valid, unless waived
How is the statute of frauds satisfied for contracts other than for the sale of goods?
-
Writing that contains:
- Identity of parties
- Description of subject matter
- All essential terms
- Signature by party to be charged
- Part performance of oral real estate agreement
- Statute of frauds satisfied if 2/3 of the following:
- Full or part payment
- Possession
- Improvements
- Statute of frauds satisfied if 2/3 of the following:
-
Estoppel to plead statute of frauds
- D is estopped from raising statute of frauds if:
- D told P he would draft agreement
- P acted in reliance on this
- D is estopped from raising statute of frauds if:
-
Promissory estoppel
- Virginia
- NO PROMISSORY ESTOPPEL
- Virginia
How is the statute of frauds satisfied for contracts for the sale of goods?
-
Writing that contains:
- Quantity (or output/requirements)
- Indication that contract for sale was made
- Signature by party to be charged
- Writing signed by party seeking enforcement
- Under UCC 2-201(2), statute of frauds waived if:
- Both parties are merchants
- Writing claims there is a contract
- Writing is signed
- Writing included quantity
- Other party fails to object in 10 days of receipt
- Under UCC 2-201(2), statute of frauds waived if:
-
Part performance of contract for sale of goods
- Satisfied statute of frauds:
- To the extent of part performance
- Satisfied statute of frauds:
-
__Specially manufactured goods
- Statute of frauds waived if:
- Seller made substantial beginning of manufacture
- Statute of frauds waived if:
-
Judicial admission
- Statute of frauds waived if:
- Party admits there was a contract under oath
- Statute of frauds waived if:
What happens if a contract fails to satisfy the statute of frauds?
What happens if a party loses the statute of frauds defense?
Contract fails to satisfy statute
- Contract is unenforceable (but not illegal)
Party loses defense
- Statute of frauds defense won’t work
- May still argue that contract doesn’t exist
When does an ambiguity make a contract invalid?
When:
- Parties use a material term open to at least two reasonable interpretations
- Each party attaches a different meaning
- Neither party knows or has reason to know of the other’s meaning
E.g., Peerless example
When does a mutual mistake of fact make a contract invalid?
What if the mistake is just as to value?
When:
- Both parties are mistaken
- Regarding a basic assumption of fact
- That materially affects the agreement
- And is not a risk their either party bears
No relief if mistkae is just as to value