Contracts Quicksheets Flashcards
What is the primary question to ask FIRST when analyzing a contract problem?
Governing Law: Is the contract governed by Common Law or the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)?
When does the UCC govern a contract?
The UCC governs ‘sales of goods.’
Sale: Transaction where seller transfers title of goods to buyer. Goods: Any movable item at the time of identification to the contract. Excludes intangibles (IP, goodwill), money, legal claims, services, real property.
How is the governing law determined for hybrid contracts (involving both goods and services)?
Apply the Predominant Purpose Test (Majority Rule):
* Contract Language: Was it described as a goods K?
* Nature of Supplier’s Business: Do they primarily sell goods? (e.g., Best Buy)
* Value: What is the relative value of the goods vs. services?
If a contract is governed by the UCC, does common law still have any relevance?
Yes. Common law principles still apply unless the UCC specifically contradicts them.
What are the two essential elements of a valid Offer?
- Outward Manifestation: An objective indication of present intent to contract (oral, written, or conduct).
- Power of Acceptance: Signals that acceptance by the offeree will conclude the deal.
Are commercial advertisements generally considered offers? What is the American Rule?
No. Generally, ads, catalogs, and price lists are considered invitations for offers.
American Rule: Treat ads as invitations.
What is the exception to the general rule that advertisements are not offers?
Ads can be offers if the language identifies who gets the limited supply, even with excess demand.
Examples: ‘First come, first served,’ ‘First 10 customers get the deal.’
Are Reward Offers considered offers?
Yes. They are offers because they promise compensation ($) in exchange for the performance of specific tasks.
How can the Power of Acceptance created by an offer be terminated? (List the 4 main ways)
- Lapse of time
- Death or Incapacity of either party (before acceptance)
- Revocation by the Offeror
- Rejection by the Offeree
How does Lapse terminate an offer?
The offer terminates:
* After the time explicitly stated in the offer; OR
* If no time is stated, after a reasonable time.
How does Revocation by the Offeror terminate an offer? What are the requirements?
The Offeror can revoke an offer at any time before acceptance.
Requirements:
* Revocation must occur before acceptance.
* Revocation must be communicated to the offeree (directly or indirectly).
What is Direct Revocation?
The offeror directly communicates to the offeree an intent to withdraw the offer.
What is Indirect Revocation? What are its two requirements?
Occurs when the offeree learns the offeror may no longer be willing or able to proceed.
Requirements:
* Offeror takes an action inconsistent with the intent to go through with the offer (e.g., sells the item to someone else).
* Offeree learns about this inconsistent action from a reliable source.
How can an offer be made irrevocable under Common Law? (2 ways)
- Option Contract: Requires (a) an Offer, (b) a separate Promise to keep it open, AND (c) Valid consideration for the promise to keep it open.
- Detrimental Reliance (Construction Bids): Offer held open if offeree (e.g., general contractor) detrimentally relied on it (e.g., using a subcontractor’s bid).
How can an offer be made irrevocable under the UCC? What is a Firm Offer?
UCC Firm Offer Rule (UCC 2-205): An offer by a merchant to buy or sell goods is irrevocable without consideration if:
* Offer made by a merchant;
* In a writing signed by the merchant; AND
* Expressly states it will be held open.
How long does a UCC Firm Offer remain irrevocable?
For the time stated in the offer, OR a reasonable time if no time is stated, BUT irrevocability cannot exceed 3 months, even if stated otherwise.
How can an Offeree’s Rejection terminate an offer? (3 ways)
- Outright Rejection: Offeree clearly communicates rejection.
- Rejection via Counteroffer: A counteroffer acts as both a rejection of the original offer and a new offer.
- Rejection via Non-Conforming Acceptance (Common Law): The Mirror Image Rule applies.
What is the difference between a counteroffer and a mere inquiry?
- Counteroffer: Rejects original offer and proposes new terms (‘I’ll pay $9k instead of $10k’).
- Mere Inquiry: Explores possibility of different terms without rejecting the original offer (‘Is $10k your best price? Would you consider lower?’).
What is the Mirror Image Rule (Common Law)?
Acceptance must exactly mirror the terms of the offer. Any variation, addition, or omission constitutes a counteroffer (which is a rejection of the original offer).
What is a Bilateral Contract? How is acceptance achieved?
An offer seeking acceptance via a promise. A promise is exchanged for a promise.
Acceptance: Offeree makes the requested promise.
What is a Unilateral Contract? How is acceptance achieved?
An offer seeking acceptance via performance. A promise is exchanged for an act. (e.g., reward offers).
Acceptance: Offeree completes the requested performance.
In a Unilateral Contract, when can the offeror revoke under (a) Common Law and (b) Modern/Majority Rule?
(a) Common Law: Offeror free to revoke any time until offeree has fully completed performance.
(b) Modern/Majority Rule: Once the offeree begins performance, an option contract is created, and the offeror cannot revoke.
What are the two general requirements for Acceptance under Common Law?
- Acceptance must mirror the terms of the offer (Mirror Image Rule).
- Acceptance must be communicated to the offeror.
If an offer is silent on the means of acceptance, how can the offeree accept?
The offeree can use any reasonable means of transmission to communicate acceptance.