Contracts Flashcards
What does the UCC apply to?
Sale of goods
What does the common law apply to?
All other contracts (land, services, etc)
What are “goods?”
Movable, tangible property
What is a merchant?
Deals in goods of the kind, or holds himself out as having special skills/knowledge of goods
If a contract involves both goods and services, how do courts decide whether to apply UCC or common law?
Predominance Test - look to see whether goods or services is the predominant purpose (argue both on test)
Elements of contract
Offer, acceptance, consideration
Under the UCC does an offer need to be in any kind of form?
No, any manner or medium will suffice
If an acceptance varies from the offer’s terms, what happens at common law?
Mirror image rule: Acceptance must be mirror image of offer, otherwise it is a REJECTION and COUNTEROFFER.
If acceptance varies from offer under the UCC, what happens?
Any expression of acceptance will constitute acceptance even if terms are different or additional.
What is consideration?
Bargained-for exchange of legal detriment (promise to act or not to act)
What is an offer at common law and what are the requirements?
Manifestation of willingness to enter bargain.
1. Intent
2. Definite Terms (QTIPS) A.Quantity B.Time (can be missing) C.Identity D. Price E. Subject Matter
- Communicated to Offeree.
Under the UCC, what happens with ADDITIONAL terms?
“Battle of the forms” 2-207
- If party is NOT a merchant - any additional term is a PROPOSAL and will not become part of K unless other party agrees.
- If BOTH parties are merchants: additional term becomes part of K UNLESS:
A. Offer expressly limits acceptance to terms
B. Material alteration
C. If offeror objects in reasonable time
Under the UCC, what happens if acceptance includes DIFFERENT terms?
Majority v. Minority (x2) v. Common law
Majority (“Knock out”) - conflicting terms knock each other out, and court will gap-fill.
Minority (additional terms) - conflicting terms will be treated as additional terms
Minority 2 (fall out) - Offeror’s terms control
Common law - K is only agreed-upon terms, court can supply terms
What are the UCC gap-fillers?
Price - reasonable price at time of delivery
Place of Delivery - Buyer picks up from seller
Time for shipment - reasonable time
Time for payment - payment due upon receipt of goods
Under UCC, can acceptance be made by shipping goods? Conforming v. Non-conforming
Yes.
1. Shipping conforming = acceptance
2. Shipping non-conforming:
A. W/o acknowledgement: acceptance AND breach
B. W acknowledgement: rejection AND counteroffer
What is a contract without consideration called?
An illusory promise (not enforceable)
What are requirements and output contracts?
Can appear illusory but are not because of implied obligation of good faith to supply goods.
Requirements: Seller is exclusive source of ALL buyer’s requirements for certain goods for certain time.
Output: Buyer agrees to buy all of sellers output for certain good for certain time.
Do gifts have sufficient consideration?
No.
Can a contract be based on PAST consideration?
Generally no, except:
A. New promise to pay debt where statute of limitations has run
B. New promise to pay for benefits previously received
Will a preexisting legal obligation provide adequate consideration?
No.
What is promissory estoppel?
If a promise foreseeably induces reliance and is actually relied upon, it can be enforceable WITHOUT consideration:
- serves as substitute for consideration
- recovery limited to RELIANCE damages (i.e., no expectation damages)
What are the defenses to contract FORMATION?
- Statute of Frauds
- Misrepresentation
- Fraud
- Unconscionability
- Mistake
What type of contracts fall under Statute of Frauds?
- Marriage (prenups)
- Land
- Promise to pay another person’s debt
- One year (impossible to perform in one year)
- Sale of goods over $500
What are the exceptions to contracts falling under Statute of Frauds?
- Marriage itself
- Land - if conveyance is made or performed in part, it will be enforceable
- Debt of another - if main purpose is for promisor’s own economic benefit
- One year - if full performance has occurred
- Goods over $500 - goods accepted/paid for, admission of K, or specially-manufactured good
What does the Statute of Frauds require?
A writing with essential terms and signed by party to be charged.
Exceptions:
- Merchants - a memo between merchants, with sign confirmation and no objection within 10 days will suffice
- Judicial admission
- promissory estoppel
What is misrepresentation?
Misrepresentation of material fact that was justifiably relied upon (no need to be intentional). MUST SUFFER $ DAMAGES.
What is fraud?
Intentional misrepresentation that is justifiably relied upon. MUST HAVE $ DAMAGES.
What is unconscionability?
If terms are so one-sided that no reasonable person would agree, court can refuse to enforce all or part of it.
NOTE: Assessed at time of FORMATION.
What is mistake?
- Mutual - K is voidable
A. Basic assumption
B. Material effect on K
C. Did not assume risk - Unilateral - Party must show factors above AND that other party knew or should have known.
What types of conditions are there?
- Express - in writing, strict compliance required
2. Constructive - supplied by court out of fairness, substantial compliance required
How can a party waive conditions?
- Keeping benefit
2. Failing to insist on compliance
What is the Parol Evidence Rule?
Limits evidence of writings/discussion made prior to, or contemporaneous with, written agreement.
What is the Parol Evidence Rule dependent on?
Whether contract is PARTIAL or TOTAL integration.
What is partial integration and how does PER apply?
Intended to be final expression of agreement, but NOT intended to include ALL terms.
Contradictory terms: Extrinsic evidence NOT allowed.
Supplemental terms: Extrinsic evidence allowed.
What is total integration and how does PER apply?
Total integration is intended to be final expression of agreement AND include ALL terms.
Extrinsic evidence NOT allowed to supplement OR contradict.
What are the exceptions to the PER (i.e., when is extrinsic evidence allowed)?
- to show K formation defects
- evidence of conditions precedent to K’s effectiveness
- Ambiguous terms (course of performance -> course of dealing -> trade usage)
Is oral modification permitted?
Generally yes, unless it falls under Statute of Frauds.
What are the modification requirements under the UCC vs common law?
Common law: NEW CONSIDERATION is required. Oral mods are permitted even if the K says otherwise.
UCC: GOOD FAITH required, but NOT consideration.
What two types of beneficiaries are there?
- Intended - can sue to enforce (creditor, donee)
2. Incidental - cannot sue
What happens if K is assigned even if K prohibits it?
Assignment is usually enforceable, but party who assigned will still be in breach.
If a party to a K appoints someone else to perform duties, what is it called? Is this permitted? Any exceptions?
Delegation
Most duties can be delegated
Exception: No delegation of special skills/judgment
What is a novation?
When party expressly agrees to accept performance of delegates and releases delegator from liability.
What is the general rule with assignment?
All rights are assignable, unless it would cause material change in duties/risk
What is it called if a party UNEQUIVOCALLY expresses before performance is due that they will not perform?
Anticipatory repudiation
What responses are there for anticipatory repudiation?
- SUE for breach (unless for PAYMENT)
- SUSPEND performance
- Treat K as discharged and the repudiation as an offer to RESCIND
- Urge perfomance
If the expression or conduct of a party indicates they won’t perform but it is NOT UNEQUIVOCAL, but causes reasonable grounds for uncertainty, what can other party do?
Demand ADEQUATE ASSURANCES in writing.
If no response in 30 days, it will be considered REPUDIATION.
(Note: party can suspend performance during this time)
What is considered a material breach at common law?
If no SUBSTANTIAL PERFORMANCE
Note: timeliness will not be factor unless time is of the essence
What is considered to be a material breach under the UCC?
- “Perfect Tender” Rule: if goods fail to conform in any respect.
Buyer can: reject all, accept all and sue, accept any “unit” and reject rest. - “Substantial conformity” for INSTALLMENT Ks.
If a buyer rejects goods under UCC, can seller do anything?
He has a RIGHT TO CURE at any time BEFORE performance is due. Notice must be given.
NOTE: can cure after performance is due if reasonably believes buyer will accept.
Is performance still due after minor breach?
Yes.
What types of warranties are there?
- Express
- Implied warranty of merchantability
- Warranty of fitness for particular purpose
- Implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing (in every K)
Accord and Satisfaction, what is it?
Accord - parties agree to substitute performance in discharge of existing duty
Satisfaction - performance of accord, both duties discharged.
Does an accord require new consideration? If an accord is breached, what can other party do?
Yes.
Sue on original K or on the accord.
What are the defenses to K enforcement?
- Defenses to K formation (no mutual assent, lack of consideration, SoF, misrepresentation/fraud, unconscionability, capacity, illegality, condition precedent)
- Impossibility
- Impracticability
- Frustration of Purpose: party’s purpose is destroyed by intervening events, frustration must be unforeseeable and total.
What considerations are there when calculating damages (i.e., what will the breaching party argue)?
- Foreseeability
- Duty to mitigate
- Certainty - no speculative damages (if too speculative, reliance damages)
- Causation - damages must be caused by breach
What are the requirements for specific performance?
- Valid K
- P Completed performance
- Inadequate legal remedy
- Mutuality of performance
- Feasibility of enforcement
- No applicable defenses