Contracts Flashcards
Contract (R2d 17)
Parties are committed to their duties and to each other, and the promises are worthy of legal consequences
Purpose of contract law
To protect parties’ expectations
Mutual assent
Parties agree to something and the same thing, determined objectively; consensual commitment
Objective view for mutual assent
The promisee takes the manifestations of the promisor at face value for what they reasonably appear to mean UNLESS they knew or should have known otherwise (jokes, drinks, known liars)
Duty to read
Parties have a duty to read their agreement (Ray v. Eurice Bros)
Offer and acceptance (R2d 18)
Each party intends for their promise to have legal consequences and makes a promise or begins/renders performance
Offer (R2d 24)
Manifestation of a willingness to enter into a bargain, so made as to justify another person in understanding that assent is invited and will conclude the bargain
Advertisements as offers
Advertisements are only offers if they are clear, definite, reasonable, and invite assent to conclude the bargain (Izadi v. Machado (Gus) Ford)
Offers are revoked upon:
Death/incapacity, revocation, information from a reliable source that offeror took action inconsistent with the contract (Normile v. Miller), counteroffer, lapse of time
Definiteness rule (R2d 33)
Terms must be reasonably certain to determine breach or craft a remedy
Option contract (R2d 87)
Option contract must (1) be in writing, (2) be signed by the offeror, (3) recite purported consideration, and (4) be proposed on fair terms
Option contracts (common law)
Recited consideration is not enough; actual consideration is required (Berryman v. Kmoch)
Firm offer (UCC 2-205)
A firm offer is an offer (1) by a merchant (2) to buy or sell goods (3) in a signed writing (4) with assurances it will be held open (5) not to exceed 3 months
Acceptance (R2d 50)
Manifestation of assent to the terms of the offer in a manner invited or required by the offer
Mirror image rule
Acceptance must be a mirror image of the offer
Mailbox rule (R2d 63)
The time and date of acceptance is determined by dispatch (exception: option contract acceptance determined on receipt)
Bilateral contract (R2d 56 and 32)
Formed when promises are exchanged; it’s assumed that an offer is bilateral and can be accepted either by return promise or performance
Unilateral contract
Formed and accepted upon completion of performance
Revocability for unilateral offers
R2d 45: Offeree’s beginning/tendering performance renders the offer irrevocable
Common law: Substantial performance renders the offer irrevocable (Cook v. Coldwell Banker)
Old Brooklyn Bridge rule: Offer revocable any time prior to full performance
UCC: Firm offers by merchants made in writing are irrevocable
Browsewrap
Actual or constructive notice of terms and conditions must exist for them to be accepted (Hines v. Overstock.com)
Clickwrap
Assent requires notice, an opportunity to review the terms, and action by the buyer (Feldman v. Google)
Shrinkwrap
Majority view: Seller makes the offer by shipping and buyer accepts by keeping the goods (DeFontes v. Dell; ProCD v. Zeidenberg)
Additional/different terms under common law
Normally, additional/different terms are a counter-offer; if parties start performing, the last form on the table at the time of performance governs (last shot rule) (Princess Cruises v. General Electric)
Preliminary negotiations (R2d 26)
Preliminary negotiations are not offers (Lonergan v. Scolnick)
Agreement to agree
One or more terms left open to be decided later; look to whether the agreement is too indefinite to enforce or whether court can imply missing terms; court can’t imply missing terms if they are essential (Walker v. Keith)
Formal contract contemplated
Not obligated before parties agree to be bound (except when necessary to prevent injustice - reliance on option contract)
Letters of intent
Some cases find that letters of intent give rise to mutual obligations to continue negotiations in good faith (Quake Construct. v. American Airlines)
Consideration (R2d 71, 76)
Bargained-for exchange; reciprocal inducement
Mixed motives (R2d 81)
Consideration exists as long as one of the motives is bargained-for
Enforcement of bad bargains
Inadequate consideration is consideration, but grossly inadequate consideration might mean no bargain at all or a lack of mutual assent
Past consideration
Past consideration is never consideration (Plowman v. Indian Refining Co.)