Contracts Flashcards
What law applies
The common law of Contract applies to all contracts, other than the sale of goods, to which the UCC applies.
Goods
Items movable at the time of identification to contract
Dominant Purpose
To determine which law applies when a contract involves both goods and services, consider the price and nature of the contract.
Merchant
Buyer or seller in goods of the kind
Checklist
- Formation
- Defenses to Formation
- Defenses to Enforcement
- Third Party Beneficiaries and Assignees
- Construction
- Conditions
- Breach and Remedies
Bilateral Contract
A promise for a promise
Unilateral Contracts
Requires acceptance ONLY by performance (offer for a reward)
Offer
- Promise, undertaking, or commitment to enter into a contract;
- with the essential terms certain and definite; and
- communication of the promise and the terms to the offeree
Essential Terms
- Identity of the offeree
- work to be performed
- definite subject matter)
- price/quantity/time of payment or performance
a. land conveyance - definite land and price terms
b. sale of goods - definite quantity
c. employment - duration/nature of work
UCC: Reasonable price and time will be supplied
Revocation
Terminates power to accept if it is communicated to the offeree before she accepts.
Can be revoked if communicated directly or indirectly if offeree receives correct information from a reliable source of acts that would indicate to a reasonable person that the offer is terminated
Mailbox Rule
Revocation only effective when it is received
Acceptance effective when dispatched unless offer stipulates otherwise.
If rejection then acceptance - whichever received first.
Limits to Power of Revocation
- Option contract - offeree gives consideration for offeror’s promise not to revoke for time stated or if no time stated, for a reasonable time (acceptance requires receipt); or
- Merchant’s Firm Offer - merchant under UCC executes offer in writing giving assurances that offer will be held open for a reasonable time, up to three months (no consideration necessary)
Acceptance Common Law
Mirror image rule (unqualified assent to the terms of the offer).
Assent must be communicated to offeror.
Offer may be accepted by any medium reasonable under the circumstances
Termination of Offer
- Rejection
- Revocation
- Lapse of Time
- By law
a. illegality
b. incapacity - death/insanity
c. destruction of subject matter
Battle of the Forms Analysis
- Are the parties both MERCHANTS?
- Different terms or additional terms?
- If DIFFERENT, apply Knockout Rule.
- Apply ADDITIONAL terms analysis (for Merchants)
Acceptance UCC
Battle of the Forms
Different terms contradict each other and are knocked-out and replaced with UCC Gap Fillers or course of performance
Additional terms are merely proposals are are not effective unless Seller does something to accept the proposal
As between merchants, some courts view different terms as proposals for additions UNLESS:
a. offer expressly limits acceptance to the terms of the offer;
b. they materially alter the offer; or
c. notification of objection to the additional or different terms is given within a reasonable time after notice is received.
Consideration
Bargained for exchange that causes a legal detriment to the promisor and a benefit to the promisee.
Promissory Estoppel
- Promisor should reasonably expect to induce definite or substantial action or forbearance
- and such action or forbearance is in fact induced
**Consider when there is a lack of consideration or contract fails for some other reason.
If met, promise, not contract, will be enforced. Thus, no contract damage but only reliance damages.
Modification
Common law - requires mutual acceptance and additional consideration. “No oral modification” clauses invalid.
UCC - consideration not needed for good faith written modification of a contract and for firm offers in writing by merchants. “No oral modification” clauses valid.
Defenses to Enforcement
- Statute of Frauds
2. Unconscionability
Statute of Frauds Elements
- Party to be charged (party against whom contract is enforced)
- executes a writing
- referencing the terms
- and signed by party against whom it is to be enforced.
**Always discuss when an agreement is VERBAL
Issues subject to the Statute of Frauds
- Promise to pay debt of another;
- creation or conveyance of ANY interests in land;
- contract that cannot possibly be performed within one year
- sale of goods of $500 or more
Statute of Fraud Exceptions
- Admissions (evidentiary or judicial);
- Full performance if the contract is for the sale of goods or is for a service;
- Contract involves conveyance of real property and (any two of):
a. Performance by payment in whole or part;
b. possession; or
c. valuable improvements made
Detrimental Reliance
Where promisor would reasonably expect promisee to rely on the promise and promisee does so rely
Unconscionable Contract
Pre-printed contract, one-sided at the time contract is formed; unequal bargaining power
Substantive Unconsionability
Procedural Unconscionability
Third Party Beneficiaries
Promisor - party promising to perform in favord of the third party beneficiary;
Promisee - party who the contract extracts the promise from the promisor to perform in favor of the third party beneficiary;
Third party beneficiary - party who receives payment from the promisor or an obligation of the promisor
Intended Beneficiary Factors
- Expressly designated or identifiable at the time of performance;
- Performance is to be made directly to them;
- They have rights under the contract;
- The relationship between third party and promisee suggests promise wishes the beneficiary to be benefited
Intended Beneficiary
Can enforce contract if their rights are vested. Cf. Incidental beneficiaries who cannot enforce the contract
Creditor Beneficiary
Promisee’s intent was to discharge an obligation to the third party
Donee Beneficiary
Promisee’s intent was to bestow a gift on the third party