Contracts Flashcards
Offer
Objective manifestation of a willingness to enter into an agreement that creates the power of acceptance in the offeree
Advertisements
Generally only an invitation to receive offers (but may qualify as an offer if sufficiently specific and limit who can accept or if associated with a stated reward)
Termination of offers
- Lapse of time (specific date or reasonable period of time if none stated)
- Death/mental incapacity of the offeror
- Destruction/illegality
- Revocation (even if it states it will be open for a specific amount of time)
- Revocation of general offers – only by notice given at least the same level of publicity as offer
- Rejection by offeree (including counteroffers)
Limitations on revocation
- Option K – offeree must generally given consideration for option to be enforceable
- Firm offer – offeror is merchant and assurances are made in an authenticated writing that offer will remain open
- Promissory estoppel – if offeree reasonably and detrimentally relies on offer
- Partial performance – for all Ks, offeree must have knowledge of offer when performance begins
a. Unilateral K – offeror cannot revoke once offeree has begun performance
b. Bilateral K – commencement of performance operates as promise to render complete performance
Acceptance
Objective manifestation by the offeree to be bound by the terms of the offer
- Shipment of goods – request invites acceptance by either seller’s promise to ship or by prompt shipment of goods
- Nonconforming goods shipped – both acceptance and a breach, unless seller notifies buyer that goods are an accommodation, which buyer may then accept or reject
Mailbox rule
Acceptance is effective when sent, unless offer provides otherwise
- Acceptance will control even if offeror receives rejection first (but if offeror detrimentally relies on rejection then offeree estopped from enforcing K)
- Rule does not apply if acceptance follows rejection
- Rule does not apply to an irrevocable offer
Notice of acceptance
Unilateral K – not required to give notice after completing performance unless offeror wouldn’t learn of performance or offeror requires it
Bilateral K – offeree must give notice of acceptance
Mirror-image rule (CL)
Acceptance must mirror the terms of the offer, so any change or addition to the terms acts as a rejection and a new counteroffer
UCC treatment of additional or different terms
One or both parties are not merchants – definite and seasonable expression of acceptance OK even if it contains new/different terms unless acceptance is conditioned upon assent to said terms
Both parties are merchants
- Battle of the forms – additional terms are automatically included in the K unless
- Term materially alters original K;
- Offer expressly limits acceptance to terms of offer; or
- Offeror objects to new terms within reasonable time after notice of new terms is received - Knock-out rule – different terms in offer/acceptance nullify each other and court uses Article 2 gap-filling provisions to fill holes in K
Consideration
Must be bargained-for legal detriment to the promisee
Pre-existing duty rule (CL)
Does not qualify as consideration unless promisor gives something in addition to what is owed or varies preexisting duty in some way
Modification
CL – must be supported by consideration
UCC – no consideration is necessary; only requires good faith
Accord and satisfaction
Generally, consideration is required for accord to be valid
Satisfaction – performance of accord agreement; discharges both original K and accord K
Illusory promise
Not legally binding because it is vague or promisor can choose whether or not to honor it
Promises binding without consideration
- Pay a debt barred by SOL
- Material benefit rule – when a party performs an unrequested service for another party, performing party can enforce promise of payment for material benefits received to the extent necessary to prevent injustice
- Promissory estoppel – promise is binding if
- Promisor should reasonably expect it to induce action on the part of the promisee,
- Promise does induce such action, and
- Injustice only avoided by enforcement of promise
Mistake
Mutual – both parties mistaken as to an essential element; K generally voidable by adversely affected party if:
- Mistake existed when K was formed,
- Mistake relates to basic assumption of K,
- Mistake has material impact on transaction, and
- Adversely affected party did not assume the risk
Unilateral – elements of mutual mistake +
- Mistake would made K unconscionable, or
- Non-mistaken party caused the mistaken, failed to disclose the mistake, or knew or should have known the other party was mistaken
Misunderstanding
Each party attaches different meanings to same terms; must show that
- Parties use material term that is open to two or more reasonable interpretations;
- Each side attaches different meaning to term; and
- Neither party knows, or should know, of the confusion
Misrepresentation
Statement at the time of the K that is not true
Fraudulent misrepresentation – requires proof that
- Misrepresentation is fraudulent,
- Misrepresentation induced assent to K, and
- Justifiable reliance on misrepresentation by adversely affected party
Non-fraudulent misrepresentation – same elements except that, instead of fraudulent, misrepresentation is material
If misrepresentation is cured, K will no longer be voidable
Duress
Improper threat that deprives a party from making a meaningful choice
- Economic duress: when a party makes threats to induce another party to K (or modify a K)
- Undue influence: when a party puts very intense sales pressure on another party who seems weak minded or susceptible to high-pressure tactics
Capacity to K
- Infancy – voidable by infant but not by adult
- Mental illness – K is void for one who is adjudicated mentally incompetent but only voidable if there has been no adjudication
- Intoxication – K is voidable by intoxicated party if she was unable to understand nature/consequences of K and other party knew of intoxication