Contracts Flashcards
Past Consideration/Moral Obligation
Common Law: Not valid consideration, nor is it a substitute for consideration.
Exception: Expressly requested by promisor, and expectation of payment by promisee
Requirements Contracts
Don’t require a set quantity under the UCC.
Options
A promise to keep an offer open for a period of time.
Common Law: Must be supported by consideration
UCC: Merchant’s Firm Offer Rule - Offer by a merchant in a signed writing, which by its terms gives assurance that it will be held open, is irrevocable during the time stated. And if no time is stated, then the period of irrevocability cannot exceed 90 days.
Quasi-Contract
Only choose when:
1) No formal agreement between the parties
2) Evidence of unjust enrichment
Battle of the Forms
UCC, and only if both parties are merchants
1) If the offeree accepts the offer, and at the same time makes a material alteration, the terms of the offer controls. The alteration is out.
2) If the offeree accepts, and makes a NONmaterial change, that nonmaterial change is included in the contract, unless the offeror timely objects.
3) Material change = substantially affects money/liability/remedy
Perfect Tender Rule (UCC Only)
Seller has to deliver perfect tender to a buyer. Unless delivery includes notice of accommodation, treat it as a counter-offer that buyer must accept/reject, can’t sue.
If seller fails, buyer has 3 options:
1) Buyer can accept the goods, and pay the contract price
2) Buyer can timely reject the goods and sue for damages
3) Buyer can accept in-part and reject in-part
Statute of Frauds - Application
Requires objective proof (i.e., performance or writing)
Applies to:
1) Service contract not capable of being performed within one year from time of contract
- Does not include contracts for life
2) Sale of goods, $500 or more
- Oral contract btw merchants, subsequently followed by a writing, is okay. 10-day rule exception. Sender is bound immediately, recipient is bound if no response within 10 days
3) Suretyship
- Main purpose exception: if main purpose of guarantor is to benefit themselves, then no S/F issue
4) Transfers of interest in real estate (except leases less than 1 year)
Unilateral Mistake
General Rule: Will not prevent contract formation
Exception: If non-mistaken party knows (or should have known) of the other party’s mistake, and is trying to take advantage of it, they will not be permitted to enjoy the benefit of the bargain.
Mutual Mistake
If that mistake goes to the essence of the agreement, will be grounds for rescinding the contract.
Modifications
Common Law: Need new consideration
UCC: Must be entered into in good faith
Source of Terms - Parol Evidence Rule
Source of contract terms
Relates to earlier words of one or both parties
1) Changing/contradicting terms in the written deal –> cannot be considered
2) Mistake in integration (clerical error) –> YES
3) Defenses (getting out of a written deal) –> YES
4) Ambiguity (explaining terms) –> YES
5) Adding to the written deal –> Yes, unless complete integration
Third-Party Beneficiaries
Vesting of Rights
1) Learn of the contract, and they assent to it
2) Learn of the contract, and rely on it
3) Learn of the contract, and sue to enforce their rights
Effect of Vesting
- Prior to vesting, the contracting parties can cancel or modify the agreement
- After vesting, contracting parties cannot cancel or modify without the consent of that beneficiary
Promissory Estoppel
1) A promise
2) Expectation of reliance on that promise
3) Reliance
4) The interests of justice require enforcement of the promise
Shipping Terms (UCC Only)
F.O.B. is followed by one of three phrases:
1) Seller’s place of business - buyer bears the risk of loss once the goods leave (Shipment Contract)
2) Buyer’s place of business - seller bears the risk of loss until they reach (Destination Contract)
3) Point of destination - seller bears the risk of loss until they reach (Destination Contract)
Assignments and Delegation
All contracts are assignable and delegable, except long-term requirement contracts and unique personal service contracts.
Can be in writing or oral.
Can be for value or gratuitous. Gratuitous assignments are generally viewed as being revocable, unless there has been some reliance.
Accord and Satisfaction
Accord: A new agreement entered into by parties who are already under agreement with each other. Suspends performance of the old agreement, until accord is satisfied or unsatisfied.
If unsatisfied, the other party can sue under either the original agreement or the accord.
Don’t need new consideration. Just a new type of obligation.
Anticipatory Repudiation
Need a clear statement of an intent not to perform.
Gives rise to immediate claim for damages, unless claimant has already finished performance.
Repudiation: Okay as long as no material change in position by other party
Material vs. Nonmaterial breach
Material: Can cancel the entire agreement.
Nonmaterial: Can’t cancel the agreement. Just sue for damages
Impossibility
In a personal service contract, if you are too sick or too injured to perform, you are excused for that period of time, and you will not be liable for damages unless the contract provides otherwise.
Condition Precedent
An act or event that must occur first before a party is under a duty to perform.
Failure of a condition does not breach.
Liquidated Damages
Only allowed if two factors:
1) At the time of entering into the contract, damages are difficult to ascertain
2) The provision itself must be a reasonable forecast of compensatory damages.
Lost Profits Doctrine
Under the UCC
Must be dealing with a volume seller, with an unlimited supply of goods at their disposal.
If so, they can seek lost profits against the breaching buyer.
Applicable Law
If sale of goods, look for some special Article 2 rule
If mixed deal, usually all or nothing. Look for most important part, unless contract divides payment
Unilateral Contract Offer
Results from an offer that expressly requires performance as the only possible method of acceptance
Offer
Look for: manifestation of commitment by one party
Missing Content
- Price? No offer if sale of real estate
- Vague or material terms (e.g., appropriate, fair, reasonable)? No offer
- Quantity in a requirements/output contract? Okay under Article 2. Buyer can reasonably increase
Advertisement with price quotation is NOT an offer, unless:
1) If it is the nature in reward
2) If it specifies quantity and expressly indicates who can accept
3) If sent in response to an inquiry
Termination of Offer
1) Lapse of time
2) Death/incapacity of a party prior to acceptance
- Except for irrevocable offers
3) Word or conduct of offeror (i.e., revocation)
4) Words or conduct of offeree (i.e., rejection)
Revocation of Offer
How? Unambiguous statement or conduct by offeror to offeree of unwillingness or inability to contract
Irrevocable offers
1) Options
2) UCC Firm Offer Rule
3) Reliance (reasonably foreseeable reliance, and detrimental)
4) Unilateral Contract - Start of performance (not mere prep)
Rejection of Offer
1) Counteroffer
- Rejects and creates a new offer
- Does not include mere bargaining
2) Conditional Acceptance
- Common Law: rejects and becomes a counteroffer that can be accepted by conduct
- UCC: rejects
3) Mirror Image Rule (common law only)
- treats additional terms as a counteroffer
- If sale of goods –> battle of the forms
Methods of Acceptance
Offeror can control method of acceptance
Look for following fact patters where offer is silent on method:
1) Offeree starts to perform
- Start of performance is treated as an implied promise to perform
- Exception: unilateral contract offers
2) Distance and delay in communications
- All communications (other than acceptance) effective when received
- Acceptance is effective when mailed (mailbox rule)
- If rejection is mailed before acceptance, then neither is effective until received
- Cannot use mailbox rule to meet an option deadline
3) Seller sends wrong goods
- Generally this is acceptance and breach
- Accommodation: counteroffer and no breach
Accepting person
Generally only by person who knows of offer at time she accepts and person to whom it was made
Offers cannot be assigned
Options CAN be assigned