Contracts Flashcards
K formation requirements
A binding K requires manifestation of mutual assent (offer and acceptance), consideration, and a lack of defenses to K formation
Offer
Offer is an objective manifestation of the offeror’s willingness to enter into an agreement that creates the power of acceptance in the offeree.
Advertisements
Ads are generally invitations to deal or receive offers unless the ad is very specific and leaves nothing open to negotiation.
Required terms under CL
Under the CL, all essential terms must be included in the offer (parties, subject, price, quantity).
Required terms under UCC
Under the UCC, the only essential term that must be included in the offer is quantity.
Ways that an offer may terminate
express revocation, constructive revocation, offeree rejects, offeree makes a counteroffer, offeror dies, or reasonable lapse of time
UCC firm offer
Under the UCC firm offer rule, an offer is irrevocable (up to 3 months max even if stated otherwise) if the Offeror is a merchant and the offer is in writing signed by the Offeror with an explicit promise not to revoke.
Who is a merchant for UCC purposes
A merchant is someone who regularly deals in the type of good at issue.
Option K
Offers kept open based on option Ks (separate valid consideration is needed to keep the option open) are irrevocable.
Acceptance
Acceptance is an objective manifestation by Offeree to be bound by the terms of the K. Unless the Offeror specifies, an Offeree can accept in any reasonable manner.
Mailbox rule
Under the CL mailbox rule, an acceptance sent by mail is effective when sent not received. A revocation is effective upon receipt.
Silent acceptance
Silence is usually not an acceptance unless the Offeree has a reason to believe silence could be an acceptance under the circumstances or previous dealings between the parties suggest silence can constitute an acceptance.
How does a UCC shipment of goods invite acceptance
Under the UCC, a buyer’s request that goods be shipped invites acceptance either by the seller’s return promise to ship or by prompt shipment of the goods.
Treatment of nonconforming goods
Under the UCC, a seller’s shipment of nonconforming goods operates as both an acceptance and a breach. However, if seller notifies the buyer that the goods are an accommodation (which constitutes a counteroffer), the buyer may then accept or reject the nonconforming goods.
Implied in fact K
Acceptance may be communicated based on a party’s conduct, in which a K exists based on implied in fact.
CL Mirror image rule
Under the CL mirror image rule, terms in the acceptance must exactly match the terms of the offer, otherwise it’s a counteroffer.
UCC 2-207, at least one party is a non-merchant
Under the UCC, an acceptance containing additional or different terms is generally treated as a valid acceptance depending on whether the parties are merchants or not. If at least one of the parties is not a merchant, then acceptance that states new terms is valid unless acceptance is expressly made conditional upon assent to the new terms.
UCC 2-207, both parties are merchants
If both parties are merchants, then under the battle of forms rule the new terms are included in the K so long as the new terms don’t materially alter the deal and the original offer was not limited to its own terms.
UCC 2-207 knockout rule
If the new terms between the offer and acceptance contradict each other, neither will govern under the UCC knockout rule and the UCC will fill in the gaps.
UCC 2-207 acceptance based on conduct
If the new terms differ too much to create a K but parties perform anyway, then only the terms that both writings agree on become part of the K, everything else is supplemented by the UCC.
Consideration
Consideration means that the parties to the K promise to incur a legal detriment or benefit.
Modification under CL
Under the CL preexisting duty rule, a promise to do something that one is already legally obligated to do is not valid consideration. There must be either a 1) change in performance, 2) 3rd party promising to pay, OR 3) unforeseen difficulties that would excuse performance
Modification under UCC
Under the UCC, a modification is binding w/o new consideration so long as the modification was made in good faith.
What are the two consideration substitutes
Promissory estoppel
Quasi-K
Promissory estoppel
A promisor is estopped if 1) their promise is reasonably expected to induce reliance, 2) promisee takes detrimental action in reliance on the promise, AND 3) injustice can only be avoided through enforcement of the promise.
Charity exception to promissory estoppel
A promise to a charity is enforceable so long as the promise is reasonably expected to induce reliance.
Quasi-K
A quasi-K exists where 1) P confers a measurable benefit on D, 2) P reasonably expected to be compensated, AND 3) it would be unfair to let D keep the benefit w/o compensation.
Defense to K formation means that…
Valid K never existed b/c there was no meeting of the minds.
Misunderstanding
There is a misunderstanding if 1) the parties use a term that can be interpreted in 2+ ways, 2) each side attaches a different meaning to the term, AND 3) neither party knew or should’ve known of the confusion.
Incapacity
A K can be voided by the incapacitated party, which includes minors, mentally ill, or very intoxicated persons.
Mutual mistake
A mutual mistake exists if 1) there was a mistake of fact existing at the time of the deal, 2) which materially impacts the K, AND 3) the impacted party didn’t bear the risk of mistake.
Unilateral mistake
A unilateral mistake exists if all elements of mutual mistake are met and either 1) the mistake would make the K unconscionable, or 2) the non-mistaken party knew of the mistake or caused it.
Fraud
Fraud occurs when D made a 1) misrepresentation of fact (not opinion), 2) that is material or fraudulent, AND 3) circumstances justify reliance on the misrepresentation.
Nondisclosure
There is normally no duty to disclose all material facts unless a fiduciary relationship exists between the contracting parties.
Duress
Duress involves an improper threat that deprives one from making a meaningful choice to contract.
Undue influence
Undue influence is when a party puts intense pressure on the other party who may be weak-minded or susceptible to pressure.
Defenses to K enforcement
Valid K may have existed but its provisions are unenforceable.
Illegality
Illegal Ks are unenforceable.
Unconscionability
A K is unconscionable when it is so unfair to one party that no reasonable party would have agreed to it.
Procedural unconscionability
Procedural unconscionability is when there is a defect in the bargaining process
Substantive unconscionability
Substantive unconscionability is when the K terms are a rip-off.
Ks against public policy
Ks against significant public policy are unenforceable.
Statute of Frauds applies to
Marriage
Suretyship
One year
UCC sale of goods $500+
Real property