Contracts Flashcards
UCC Contracts
Sale of Goods
Rules for merchants and non-merchants.
What is a merchant?
Merchants are parties who deal in goods of the kind; or
By their occupations hold themselves out as possessing knowledge or skill concerning the goods involved in the transaction.
Common Law Contracts
Real Property and Services.
Requirements for a Valid Contract
(1) One party must make a binding offer to the other; (2) the offer must be accepted by the other party; and (3) there must be consideration.
Offer
An indication of willingness to perform some obligation or refrain from doing something (enter into a bargain).
Terms must be sufficiently certain.
Inquiries or Invitations to Make an Offer
Are NOT an offer.
Advertisements
Generally, not offers, but rather, invitations to make offers.
For an advertisement to be an offer the advertisement should (1) target a specific or limited audience, (2) have definite terms, and (3) require the offeree to do something.
Offer Termination
When it has: (1) lapsed; (2) been revoked; (3) been rejected; (4) met with a counteroffer; or (5) by operation of law.
Lapses
No acceptance within a reasonable time.
What constitutes a reasonable time is a question of fact.
Use 30 days as a default rule.
Offers are Freely Revokable
Party making the offer can revoke any time prior to acceptance.
Revocation prior to acceptance precludes the formation of a contract.
Rejection and Counteroffer
Offeree that communicates rejection of an offer or responds with counteroffer terminates the original offer.
Rejection Meaning
A manifestation of intent not to accept an offer.
Operation of Law
Death of the offeror or even that makes contract impossible terminates an offer.
Firm Offer Rule
-Irrevocable Offers-
(1) Signed written offers (2) promising to be irrevocable and (3) made by a merchant are revocable for time stated but not more than 3 months.
Since the firm offer must be made by a merchant, this will only arise under the UCC where a sale of goods is involved.
Option Contract
-Irrevocable Offers-
Parties exchange consideration for the promise to keep an offer irrevocable for an agreed time – if not time stated than a reasonable time.
Unless terms recite otherwise, an option contract is not created until RECEIPT of the acceptance.
Can appear under the UCC or Common Law.
Part Performance
-Irrevocable Offers-
An offer that invites performance as a reasonable method of acceptance makes the offer irrevocable upon partial performance.
Mere preparation is not enough.
Detrimental Reliance
-Irrevocable Offers-
A detrimental reliance that the offer will remain open.
Counteroffer Meaning
If you propose a change to the terms of an original offer, you are making a new offer – a counteroffer; there can be no contract until the counteroffer is accepted.
An offer made by the offeree to the offeror that concerns the same subject matter as the original offer but differs in its terms.
Acceptance
Requires a meeting of the minds (mutual assent).
May arise by communication or performance.
May be express (by word of mouth or in writing) or inferred by conduct, e.g., if he receives goods and makes use of them.
Validity of Acceptance
(1) Must take place while the offer is still in force; (2) Under common law, must be on the same terms as the offer; (UCC has exceptions) (3) Must be unconditional; and (4) Must be communicated to the offeror.
Mirror Image Rule – Common Law
For an acceptance to form a contract the acceptance must be a “mirror image” of the offer.
Any deviation from the terms is a counteroffer. (an offer and acceptance with new or additional terms is an offer and a counter offer)
Mirror Image Rule – UCC
-One or None are Merchants-
Offer and Acceptance with New or Additional Terms
A contract is created according to the original terms of the offer.
Mirror Image Rule – UCC
-Both are Merchants-
Offer and Acceptance with New or Additional Terms
A contract is created that includes the new or additional terms.
Unless: (1) there is an objection; (2) the new or additional term is a material alteration; and (3) the original offer expressly says it can only be accepted as stated.
Acceptance by Performance
Creates a contract.
What happens if the performance deviates from the terms of the offer?
Non-conforming performance/ acceptance creates a contract and a simultaneous breach.
Non-conforming performance/ acceptance accompanied by written explanation creates a counteroffer.
Mailbox Rule
Acceptance of the offer is effective upon dispatch.
Revocation of offer is effective upon receipt.
Exceptions to Mailbox Rule
Does not apply where the offer states that acceptance will not be effective until received.
Does not apply where the acceptance is in response to an option contract; acceptance must be received to be effective.
Where rejection is sent before acceptance, whichever is received first controls.
Consideration
An exchange of promises to perform acts in the future.
May take the form of a commitment to pay, to perform or to surrender a right in exchange for another’s promise to act.
Promise for a promise is sufficient.
Inadequate Consideration
Past consideration is not sufficient legal consideration.
Pre-Existing Duty – if a party to a contract is under a pre-existing duty to perform, then no consideration is given for any modification of the contract and the modification is therefore voidable.
Consideration Principles
(1) A valuable consideration is required, i.e. the act, forbearance, or promise must have some economic value; (2) Consideration need not be adequate but it must be sufficient (as long as it has some economic value); (3) Consideration must move from the promisee. (4) Consideration must not be past.
Material Benefit Rule
-Past Consideration Exception-
(Some States)
A promise not supported by consideration may be enforceable if it is made in recognition of a benefit previously received by the promisor from the promise.
Does not apply (and the promise is not enforceable) if the promisee conferred the benefit as a gift, or to the extent that the value of the promise is disproportionate to the benefit conferred.
Terms
Must be sufficient such that an assent to the terms creates a contract.
Contract Modification
-Generally-
When parties change the terms of an existing contract the law regards the modification as a brand-new contract.
Contract Modification
-Common Law-
Modification requires new consideration!
Some states permit a writing to substitute for new consideration.
Some states permit modification without new consideration where the change is necessitated by unforeseen circumstances.
Contract Modification
-UCC-
Modification permitted without new consideration!
Requires good faith!