Contract/Sales Flashcards
When to use UCC art. 2
for sale of goods! (moveable, personal house)
if contract is mixed goods/services look to the primary purpose (what they wanted when made contract)
When to use UCC art. 2A
ONLY in Texas
applies to lease of goods (not real property, but ex: lease of a car)
What is a Contract and 2 Ways to Create one
legally enforceable agreement
- express contract: created by parties (oral or written)
- Implied in fact: created by conduct
Restitution/Quasi-Contract
protects from unjust enrichment (last resort)
recover value of benefit conferred, not the contract price
Bilateral Contract
where offer can be accepted in any reasonable way (flexible)
Unilateral Contract
where offer can be accepted only by performing (not formed until total act of performing complete)
when:
- ‘offer only accepted by performing’
- reward, contest, prize
Steps to Analyzing Contract
1: was there an offer
2. was offer terminated
3. was offer accepted
What is an offer?
manifestation of intent to be bound
Is an advertisement an offer?
generally no b/c no quantity term so unlimited ppl could accept (not fair)
Except: if ad specifies a quantity
Open Price Term in Offer
Court will infer reasonable price at the time of delivery if price isn’t included
EXCEPT: price must be included for real estate contract
Requirement Contracts (UCC Art. 2)
ex: ‘i will buy all requirement of beans from seller’
when quantity is measured by buyers needs/requirements a specific number is not required
But buyer can’t take seller by surprise if amount goes up (even in good faith)–can’t be out of line with prior requirements
Offers Terminating by Lapse
offer lapses after stated term or reasonable time has passed (doesn’t stay open forever)
Offers Terminated by Revocation
offer terminates when offeror revokes offer
Direct Revocation of Offer
offerer indicates directly to offeree he changed his mind about the deal (no particular words are necessary)
Indirect Revocation of Offer
offeror’s conduct indicates a changed mind and offeree was aware of this conduct
Option Contract
makes offer irrevocable
a promise to keep offer open, that is paid for
no time limit
Firm Offer (art. 2)
Makes offer irrevocable
if merchant promises in signed writing to keep offer open
Signed: loose interpretation (fax, letterhead, initials)
3 month time limit no matter what!
Starting to Perform Under Unilateral Contract
makes offer irrevocable
w/unilateral offer, once offeree starts to do the job, the offeror can’t revoke
mere preparation doesn’t count
When is Revocation Effective?
revocation is effective when it is received (NOT when sent)
Rejection of Offer (3 main ways)
offer terminates when offeree rejects it by giving inappropriate response:
- Counter Offer (not mere questioning)
- Conditional Acceptance (rejection/counter)
- Acceptance Varying Offer only at common law
Acceptance Varying Offer: Common v. UCC
Common: must be mirror image so addition/changing terms operates as rejection
UCC: additional/different terms included if:
- both parties merchants and
- not material change (cause hardship/surprise, not customary to industry) and if
- other party didn’t object to it in reasonable time
Death of a Party Before Acceptance
terminates a revocable offer but not an irrevocable offer
Starting Performance for Bilateral v. Unilateral Contracts
bilateral: means acceptance and implied promise to finish
unilateral: merely starting isn’t enough, must complete (starting makes it irrevocable)
Improper Performance
simultaneous acceptance and breach of contract
Accommodation Exception to Improper Performance
if seller says he is sending non conforming goods as accommodation it’s not acceptance/breach
buyer can send back goods at sellers expense
Timing of Acceptance (Mailbox Rule)
acceptance effective when mailed
(remember, revocation effective when received)
burden of lost letter: on offeror (all that matters is that it was mailed correctly)
Exceptions to the Mailbox Rule (3)
- Offer states otherwise (can contract around it)
- Irrevocable Offer: acceptance effective when received, not when sent b/c they will expire when option is up
- Rejection sent first: it is a race, and whatever reaches offeror first will be effective
Lack of Capacity to Contract
who (3) and what it means to the contract
- minors
- intoxicated
- retarded
incapacitated person has right to disaffirm (doesn’t have to)
Incapacitated but then gets Capacity
retaining benefit after capacity obtained means it becomes a valid, enforceable contract b/c person has implied he wants to be bound
Exception for Necessaries w/ Minors
incapacitated party is liable for necessaries (food, shelter, clothing, medical) but only reasonable value, not contract price
Ambiguity/Misunderstanding in Contract
parties on completely different wavelengths (saying same thing but meaning different things)
ship example
no contract will be made
EXCEPT: if one party knew/reason of the misunderstanding then contract interpreted for innocent party
Mutual Mistake
about material/significant facts
- -mistake about value is NOT significant
ex: item destroyed and neither party knew
will destroy contract
Unilateral Mistake
one party’s mistake is not a fatal flaw
EXCEPT: if other party knew/reason about the other’s mistaken belief that lead them to contract
What is Consideration, and What can Constitute Consideration (3)
bargained for legal benefit or detriment
- promise
- performance
- forbearance/peace of mind
adequacy of consideration is irrelevant
must be over something legal to do
Past Consideration
NOT consideration b/c the work has already been performed
can’t bargain about things already done
Does Contract Modification Require Consideration?
UCC v. Common
Common: new consideration is req to modify contract
-performing pre-existing duty is not enough
UCC: consideration is not req to modify contract for sale of goods, if modification done in good faith
Partial Payment of Debt
due/undisputed v. not due/disputed
Partial Payment if Due/Undisputed:
-ex: X owes Visa 5K, but they orally agree visa take 2K. Visa then demands other 3K. X must pay b/c there was no consideration for the agreement
Partial Payment if Not Due/Disputed
-agreeing to pay some amount early or to end good faith dispute would be consideration and it would be ok for partial payment to forgive the debt
Time Barred Debts
written promise to pay a debt that can’t be collected on b/c of the stat of limitations is enforceable even w/o consideration
Promissory Estoppel as Substitue for Consideration
foreseeable reliance may make a promise enforceable even w/o consideration (like for promises)
SoF: When a Writing is Required (5)
- Interest in real property (sale, lease, easement, by owner or agent)
- Performance of Contract Can’t be Completed w/in A Year (look at what is theoretically possible v. impossible on calendar)
- Sale of Goods for 500 or more
- Suretyship
- Contract Modification, if contract as modified comes w/in SoF (over 500, longer than a year) or if contract forbids oral modifications (art. 2 only-common law doesn’t let ppl add to SoF)
What is a Satisfactory Writing?
UCC v. Common and 2 requirements each
Art 2:
- have quantity and
- signed by party to be charged (so can be one way street depending on who signed)
Common
- all material terms (who, what)
- signed by person its being enforced against
Real Property Exception to SoF (2)
- lease of 1 yr or less
- Part Performance
- requires 2 of the three: - some payment
- possession
- improvements on property
Work Contracts Exception to SoF
work contract for year or more must be in SoF but if it wasn’t and they worked full time on oral contract they can still get paid.
if didn’t work full year, can’t recover on contract (use restitution)
Sale of Goods Exception to SoF
sale of goods of 500 or more in SoF
Exception: goods accepted and paid for (but only those goods actually accepted/paid for, not whole contract–so works only if goods are easily divisible. Shipments of bats v. downpayment on boat)
Custom Made Goods as Exception to SoF
only if there has been a substantial beginning and they are not suitable for resale
Judicial Admission as Exception to SoF
in judicial proceeding someone says contract happened
Merchants Confirmatory Memo as Exception to SoF (3 elements)
one party can use it’s own signed writing to satisfy SoF against the other party if:
- both are merchants
- writing claims agreement and has quantity and
- no written objection w/in 10 days
Main Purpose of Suretyship Exception to SoF
when the promise to pay actually benefits the surety and not the primary payer
When Does the Parole Evidence Rule Come into Play and What does it Do?
comes into play only if there is a written contract
keeps out PRIOR or CONTEMPORANEOUS agreements (oral or written) that contradicts the later writing b/c you assume the last writing is complete
doesn’t keep out evidence of formation defects
Exceptions to Parole Evidence
(5)
(the evidence can get in)
- Typo
- defense against formation (ex: misrep)
- interpret vague/ambiguous term
- Add partially integrated writing (not all terms are included. the ballroom/sleeping ex)
- All Later events