Contract Law AMP - Performance And Breach Flashcards
Under Article 2, unless the contract provides otherwise, a buyer has a right to inspect the goods __________.
A at the expense of the seller before the buyer pays for the goods
B at the expense of the seller after the buyer pays for the goods
C at the buyer’s own expense before she pays for the goods
D at the buyer’s own expense after she pays for the goods
C
Unless the contract provides otherwise, the buyer has a right to inspect the goods at the buyer’s own expense before she pays. Under Article 2, expenses of inspection must be borne by the buyer but may be recovered from the seller if the goods do not conform and are rejected. QUESTION ID: K0076 Additional Learning
When should the nonbreaching party treat an otherwise minor breach as a material breach?
A When the breach causes the nonbreaching party damages
B When the breach relates to the timing of performance
C When the breach is part of a divisible contract
D When the breach is coupled with an anticipatory repudiation
D
If a minor breach is coupled with an anticipatory repudiation, the nonbreaching party may treat it as a material breach. Thus, the nonbreaching party may sue immediately for total damages and is permanently discharged from any duty of further performance. The courts hold that the nonbreaching party must not continue on with the contract, because to do so would be a failure to mitigate damages. There is no reason that a minor breach that is part of a divisible contract should be treated as a material breach. In fact, in a divisible contract, recovery is available for substantial performance of a divisible part even if there has been a material breach of the entire contract. Even a minor breach can cause the nonbreaching party damages. The effect of a minor breach is to provide a remedy for the immaterial breach to the aggrieved party. The aggrieved party is not relieved of her duty of performance under the contract by a minor breach, unlike in the case of a material breach. Unless the nature of the contract is such as to make performance on the exact day agreed upon of vital importance, or the contract by its terms provides that time is of the essence, a failure by a promisor to perform at the stated time will not be material. Thus, a minor breach that relates to the timing of performance generally should not be treated as a material breach. QUESTION ID: K0100C Additional Learning
In a noncarrier case, for proper tender of delivery, the seller must:
A Put and hold the goods at the buyer’s disposition for a time sufficient for the buyer to take possession and give the buyer reasonable notice to enable the buyer to take possession of the goods
B Promptly deliver the goods to the buyer’s place of business or residence
C Put and hold conforming goods at the buyer’s disposition at an agreed upon destination
A
A noncarrier case is a sale in which it appears that the parties did not intend that the goods be moved by carrier. In a proper tender of delivery, the seller must put and hold conforming goods at the buyer’s disposition for a time sufficient for the buyer to take possession. The seller must give the buyer notice reasonably necessary to enable her to take possession of the goods. Absent a contrary agreement, a seller is not required to actually deliver the goods to the buyer. The seller need only tender (offer) the goods to the buyer at the seller’s place of business or residence. In a destination contract, the seller has agreed to tender at a particular destination. In that case, the seller must put and hold conforming goods at the buyer’s disposition at the agreed upon destination. He must also give the buyer any notice of tender that is reasonably necessary and provide her with any documents of title necessary to obtain delivery. QUESTION ID: K0073B Additional Learning
Under a U.C.C. Article 2 shipment contract, the seller need not ___________ but must ___________.
A See that the goods reach the buyer; promptly notify the buyer of the shipment
B Notify the buyer of the shipment; put the goods into the hands of a reasonable carrier for shipment
C Notify the buyer of the shipment; see that the goods reach the buyer
D See that the goods reach the buyer; bear the risk of loss until the goods reach the destination
A
Under a U.C.C. Article 2 shipment contract, a seller need NOT see that the goods reach the buyer, but must: put the goods into the hands of a reasonable carrier and make a reasonable contract for their transportation to the buyer; obtain and tender any documents required to enable the buyer to take possession; and promptly notify the buyer of the shipment. In a shipment contract, the seller bears the risk of loss only until the seller delivers the goods to the carrier. QUESTION ID: K0074A Additional Learning
Under Article 2 of the U.C.C., a buyer cannot reject a shipment of nonconforming goods if:
A The nonconforming shipment causes no monetary damage to the buyer
B The defect can be cured within the time for performance
C The nonconforming shipment is part of an installment contract
D The nonconforming shipment is part of an installment contract and the defect can be cured
D
Article 2 follows the Perfect Tender Rule. If the goods fail to conform to the contract in any way, the buyer generally may reject tender. An exception to this rule is that a defective shipment in an installment contract cannot be rejected if the defect can be cured. In a single delivery contract, the buyer can always reject the goods because of defects under the perfect tender rule. Note, however, that the seller may, within the time originally provided for performance, “cure” by giving reasonable notice of her intention to do so and making a new tender of conforming goods, which the buyer must then accept. It is not enough that the defective shipment be part of an installment contract; the defect must be capable of being cured. For example, if the defects are in the particular goods themselves and thus cannot be cured, the buyer can reject them. The seller retains the right to cure within the time for performance by making a tender of conforming goods within the time for performance. Under the perfect tender rule, a buyer can choose to reject nonconforming goods even if they cause no monetary damage to the buyer. For example, a buyer could rightly reject nearly identical goods in a different color than those ordered even if the monetary value of the goods is the same. QUESTION ID: K0107B Additional Learning
Under the UCC, in a single delivery contract, a seller may always cure a shipment that the buyer has rejected because of defects by delivering conforming goods within:
A The time originally provided for performance
B Ten days after the notice of rejection is received
C A reasonable time beyond the original contract time
D Ten days after the notice of rejection is sent
A
If the buyer has rejected goods because of defects, the seller may, within the time originally provided for performance, “cure” by giving reasonable notice of her intention to do so and making a new tender of conforming goods which the buyer must then accept. Ordinarily, the seller has no right to cure beyond the original contract time. However, in cases where the buyer rejects a tender of nonconforming goods that the seller reasonably believed would be acceptable “with or without money allowance,” the seller, on reasonable notification to the buyer, has a further reasonable time beyond the original contract time within which to make a conforming tender. A seller will probably be found to have had reasonable cause to believe that the tender would be acceptable if the seller can show that trade practices or prior dealings with the buyer led the seller to believe that the goods would be acceptable, or the seller could not have known of the defect despite proper business conduct. There is no set time period, such as 10 days after the notice of rejection is sent or received, in which the seller always has a right to cure. As stated above, the length of time to cure depends on the specifics of the contract and the circumstances surrounding the defective delivery. QUESTION ID: K0105A Additional Learning
Under Article 2, a buyer’s right to reject is cut off by __________.
A Failure to return the goods within a reasonable time
B Delivery of goods in substantial conformity with the contract
C Receipt of the goods followed by a submission of the goods to inspection
D Acceptance of the goods, even if the goods are nonconforming
D
A buyer’s right to reject under the perfect tender doctrine generally is cut off by acceptance of the goods by the buyer, even though they are nonconforming. Under Article 2, a buyer accepts when, after a reasonable opportunity to inspect the goods, she indicates to the seller that they conform to requirements or that she will keep them even though they are nonconforming; or she fails to reject within a reasonable time after tender or delivery of the goods or fails to seasonably notify the seller of her rejection; or she does any act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership. When a buyer receives goods and submits them to an inspection, she has not yet accepted the goods. A buyer must be given a reasonable opportunity to inspect the goods before acceptance; thus, merely receiving the goods and submitting them to an inspection is not yet an acceptance and the buyer’s right to reject has not yet been cut off. Delivery of goods in substantial conformity with the contract would not cut off a buyer’s right to reject. Article 2 generally does not follow the common law substantial performance doctrine. Instead, it follows the perfect tender rule—if goods or their delivery fail to conform to the contract in any way, the buyer generally may reject all, accept all, or accept any commercial units and reject the rest. The buyer is not obligated to return the goods within a reasonable time; she only needs to notify the seller of her rejection. After rejecting the goods, the buyer has an obligation to hold them with reasonable care at the seller’s disposition for a time sufficient to permit the seller to remove them. If the seller has no agent or place of business within the market area where the goods are rejected, a merchant buyer has an obligation to obey any reasonable instructions as to the rejected goods. If a seller gives no instructions within a reasonable time after notification of rejection, the buyer may reship the goods to the seller, store them for the seller’s account, or resell them for the seller’s account. The buyer has a security interest in rejected goods in her possession for any part of the price already paid and for expenses reasonably incurred in connection with handling them after rejection. QUESTION ID: K0102A Additional Learning
A buyer orders 600 widgets to be delivered on the 10th of each month in lots of 100. The second month’s shipment arrived on the 8th of the month and contains only 95 widgets.
The buyer ____________________.
A May not reject the shipment
B May cancel the contract
C May reject all, accept all, or accept any commercial units and reject the rest in the shipment
A
The buyer may not reject the shipment. Under a single delivery sale of goods contract, a five-widget shortfall could be the basis for rejection under the perfect tender rule. However, this is an installment contract, and the buyer cannot reject the installment unless he can show that the shortfall substantially impairs the value of the installment and cannot be cured. A deficiency in quantity can always be cured, and there are still two days before performance is due. Under the perfect tender rule, if goods or their delivery fail to conform to the contract in any way, the buyer may reject all, accept all, or accept any commercial units and reject the rest. However, in an installment contract, the right to reject an installment is limited to nonconformities that substantially impair the value of the installment and cannot be cured. In an installment contract, a buyer may cancel the entire contract due to breach only if the buyer can show that the nonconformity substantially impairs the value of the entire contract. The five-widget deficiency is easily cured and is unlikely in any event to be found to impair the value of the entire 600-widget contract. QUESTION ID: K0104B Additional Learning
If a seller gives no instructions within a reasonable time after notification of rejection, the buyer may _________________ the goods.
A Reship, store, or resell
B Store, resell, or destroy
C Reship, resell, or destroy
D Reship, store, or destroy
A
If a seller gives no instructions within a reasonable time after notification of rejection, the buyer may reship the goods to the seller, store them for the seller’s account, or resell them for the seller’s account. A buyer may not destroy rejected goods. QUESTION ID: K0103B Additional Learning
A destination contract __________.
A requires the seller to tender the goods to the buyer at a particular destination
B requires the seller to put the goods into the hands of a carrier for shipment to a particular destination
C requires the buyer to arrange for shipment of the goods to a particular destination
D requires the buyer to take possession of the goods at the seller’s place of business
A
A destination contract is one in which the seller is required to tender delivery of the goods at a particular destination. At the destination, the seller must give the buyer notice of the tender, put and hold conforming goods at the buyer’s disposition, and provide the buyer with documents of title. The requirement that the seller put the goods into the hands of a carrier for shipment is a requirement of a shipment, rather than a destination, contract. Requirements that the buyer take possession of the goods at the seller’s place of business and arrange for shipment of the goods describe a noncarrier case, not a destination contract. A noncarrier case is a sale in which the parties did not intend that the goods be moved by carrier. QUESTION ID: K00147 Additional Learning
Under U.C.C. Article 2, unless the contract provides otherwise, any expenses for inspection of the goods sold will be borne by:
A The seller in all cases
B The buyer in all cases
C orrect
C The buyer, but may be recovered from the seller if the goods do not conform and are rejected
D Both the buyer and the seller in equal shares
C
Under Article 2, unless the contract provides otherwise, the buyer has a right to inspect the goods before paying. Expenses of inspection must be borne by the buyer, but may be recovered from the seller if the goods do not conform and are rejected. A buyer may inspect at any reasonable time and in any reasonable manner. If the contract between the parties provides for payment C.O.D. or otherwise indicates that the buyer has promised to pay without inspecting the goods, there is no right of inspection prior to payment. If payment is due before inspection, the fact that the goods are defective does not excuse nonpayment unless the defect appears without inspection or there is fraud in the transaction. Thus, generally the seller will not share in the cost of inspections, but may have to pay the costs if the goods do not conform and are rejected, as noted above. QUESTION ID: K0076A Additional Learning
Which of the following statements regarding shipment and destination contracts is accurate?
A In a shipment contract, the cost of the buyer’s inspection of the goods is borne by the seller, and in a destination contract, the cost of the buyer’s inspection of the goods is borne by the buyer.
B In both a shipment contract and in a destination contract, the price must be paid in legal tender unless the agreement permits payment by check.
C In both a shipment contract and in a destination contract, the price is due when the goods reach the named destination.
D In a shipment contract, the price is due when the goods are put in the hands of the carrier, and in a destination contract, the price is due when the goods reach the named destination.
D
The correct statement is that in a shipment contract, the price is due when the goods are put in the hands of the carrier, and in a destination contract, the price is due when the goods reach the named destination. In both a shipment and destination contract, the cost of the buyer’s inspection of the goods is borne by the buyer. The buyer may recover inspection costs from the seller if the goods are nonconforming and the buyer rejects them. In both a shipment and destination contract, tender of payment by check is sufficient unless the seller demands legal tender. QUESTION ID: K0075 Additional Learning
Which of the following is a true statement regarding a minor breach of contract under the common law?
A The aggrieved party will gain the substantial benefit of her bargain, and thus is not entitled to a remedy for the minor breach.
B The aggrieved party will not gain the entire benefit of her bargain, and therefore any duty of counterperformance owed by the aggrieved party is discharged.
C The aggrieved party will not gain the entire benefit of her bargain, and therefore is entitled to a remedy for breach of the entire contract.
D The aggrieved party will gain the substantial benefit of her bargain, but is still entitled to a remedy for the minor breach.
D
When a breach of contract is minor, the obligee still gains the substantial benefit of her bargain despite the obligor’s defective performance. The aggrieved party is entitled to a remedy for the minor breach. Although a minor breach may prevent the aggrieved party from gaining the entire benefit of her bargain, she still gains the substantial benefit of her bargain. Thus, the minor breach will not discharge any duty of counterperformance owed by the aggrieved party, nor entitle her to a remedy for breach of the entire contract. QUESTION ID: K0100 Additional Learning
Which of the following does not constitute an acceptance of goods under Article 2?
A The buyer does any act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership.
B The buyer fails to reject the goods within a reasonable time after tender or delivery.
C The buyer indicates to the seller that she will keep the goods even though they fail to conform to the contract requirements.
D The buyer receives the goods and submits them to an inspection.
D
When a buyer receives goods and submits them to an inspection, he has not yet accepted the goods. A buyer must be given a reasonable opportunity to inspect the goods before acceptance, thus merely receiving the goods and submitting them to an inspection is not yet an acceptance. After inspection, the buyer may then accept the goods if they conform. In addition, it is also an acceptance, if the buyer indicates to the seller that she will keep the goods even though they fail to conform to the contract requirements. Failure to reject the goods within a reasonable time after tender or delivery and any act inconsistent with the seller’s ownership are also considered an acceptance under Article 2. QUESTION ID: K0102 Additional Learning
After a reasonable time has passed since the notification of rejection, if the seller has given the buyer no instructions as to the disposal of the defective goods, the buyer may do any of the following, except:
A store the goods
B return the goods
C destroy the goods
D resell the goods
C
After rejecting goods in her physical possession, a buyer has an obligation to hold them with reasonable care at the seller’s disposition for a time sufficient to permit the seller to remove them; thus, the buyer should not destroy the goods. If the seller gives no instructions to the buyer within a reasonable time after notification of rejection, the buyer may return the goods to the seller by shipment, store the goods for the seller’s account, or resell the goods for the seller’s account. QUESTION ID: K0103 Additional Learning