Contract Interpretation Flashcards
Judicial Efficiency
UCC 2-206 Excuse
- Discovery especially difficult
- Failure to discover indicated by the seller
- The buyer reasonably assumed assumed the sellers cure
Advantages of Parol Evidence Rule
- Encourages parties to be look out for themselves when contracting
- Prevents the fraudulent addition of terms not part of the original agreement
- Saves court from having to referee a swearing match of terms
- Prevents sympathetic hindsight contract rewriting
- Aids with summary judgement and judicial efficiency.
Name the 2 forms of Ambiguity
- Patent - Vague or ambiguous on the face of the text
- Latent - Not obvious, need to choose from different possible meanings
Anticipatory Breach
- Repudiation, or
- Obligors own act makes its performance impossible
Buyers Breach - Restitution?
- Buyers acknowledges breach entitled to restitution
- Cannot keep goods
- Earnest money, interest, progress payments
- No restitution in case of LDC
Can a party retract a repudiation?
- If a retraction in time, can erase a repudiation
- If retraction too late, then no
- If the injured party has relied on the repudiation and sought substitution, e.g.
- indicates that repudiation is final
Can you revoke acceptance?
to revoke acceptance and restore my right to reject the goods, a buyer must show serious defect and excuse.
What is the “Certainly Would Have Rule” - UCC
Permits the presumption favoring the inclusion of a non-contradictory supplementary terms unless it is argued that the parties “certainly would have included” such a term.
What is a Complete Integration?
An agreement reduced to its final written form and intended by the parties to be the complete statement of their agreement.
What is Concealment?
Failure to disclose a fact, not a ground per se for rescission/tort claim.
What is a Condition Precedent?
A condition necessary to be satisfied before contract can be formed.
Consequential Damages
Damages which occur as a consequence of the breach, lost profits, personal injury, injury to property, etc.
Constructive Condition - Simultaneous Performance
- Each party must tender performance to fulfill a condition of other’s duty. Mutually dependent conditions.
- Tender is a present willingness and ability to perform
Constructive Condition - Work as Payment
Work taking time is a presumed condition of owners duty to pay.
Express schedule of units of work for units of pay (ratable)
Constructive Condition of Performance
Rest.2d 237 - It is a condition of each party’s remaining duties that there is no uncured material faliure to perform a duty owed by the other party at an earlier time.
- YOU HAVE TO KEEP PERFORMING UNLESS THE OTHER PARTY HAS MATERIALLY BREACHED
Demand for Assurance
- Some new condition which causes a reasonable ground for insecurity
- An obligor’s failure to give assurance is a repudiation
- Unilateral Modification of the Contract
- cannot be excessive
- or unreasonable
- UCC requires a written demand and 30 day waiting period
Discretion
Freedom in the exercise of judgment, the power of free decision-making. One party has freedom, the other party does not with respect to a contract term or condition
Disputed Terms - Material
- If the term is material and in dispute the court can:
- Adopt the best meaning
- Rule no contract - mutual restitution
- Adopt the likely intended meaning
Effort Based Promise
A promise based on the effort of the promisor to fulfill, must make a good faith attempt.
Ejusdem Generis
General word or phrase will be interpretated to include only items of the same class as those listed
What is Equitable Reformation?
In the case of a drafting error the contract can be read as the parties mutually intended (reformed)
Express Warranty
Any description (of performance, features, attributes) that is a basis of the bargain
Expressio Unis Est Exclusio Alterius
Stating one thing might imply exclusion of another
Fit for Intended Purpose
If the sellers knows of the buyers intended purpose and the buyer relies on the sellers recommendation
Fixed Overhead
Costs a party would have incurred irrespective of the formation of the contract (Prop. Taxes, etc.)
Bad Faith
- Predatory or opportunitstic acts shocking the conscience
- Conduct rendering the contract illusory
- Conduct that is destructive of reasonable expectations
Immaterial Terms
Terms which are not central to the deal, like LDC, choice of law, choice of forum, Davy Jones, etc.
Implied in Fact
A contract that the parties presumably intended as their tacit understanding, as inferred from their conduct and other circumstances.
Implied in Law
A remedy that allows the plaintiff to recover a benefit conferred on the defendant.
Implied Warranties
- Merchantability
- Fit for Intended Purpose
What are Incidental Damages
Damages which naturally flow from the breach,
- Costs of halting transaction (recalling, transporting, storing, etc.)
- Costs of searching for and arranging a substitute
Information Sharing Requirements
- No duty to disclose during negotiation
- After K formation, disclosure might be needed to:
- perform
- enjoy the purpose of the K
- Compare claimants need with obligors burden
Installment Contracts
- UCC 2-612 - installment contract involves delivery in separate lots over an extended time.
- time less likely to be critical
- there are opportunites for cure in later installments
- more likely to involve major sunk investments in the contract (irretreviable reliance costs)
Interpretation - Hierarchy
- The words of the contract (express)
- Conduct of the parties during performance (course of performance)
- Conduct of the parties in prior contracts (course of dealing)
- Usage of trade or community for the terms
Interpretation Rules - Within Four Corners
- Avoid an interpretation that would render the contract illegal or in violation of public policy
- Avoid interpretations which would lead to conflict between the provisions of the contract
- Avoid an unreasonable outcome
- Prefer giving meaning and effect to all words on the text.
Is it Impracticable or Impossible?
- Impractibility is normally argued by the seller
- Impossibility is normally argued by the buyer
Limitations of Parol Evidence Rule
- Doesn’t allow evidence when there is a fraudulent denial
- Drafters advantage over non-drafter
- Allows a cure for a “standard form” versus actual intent
- Accounts for difficulties in listing all assumptions nad customs in a contract
- Serves justice by hearing evidence
Material Terms
Terms which are central to the deal, like quantities, price, warranties, etc.
Merchantability
The product will perform as per its ordinary purpose
Modification
A post integration agreement which modifies the contract