Constitutional Law Flashcards
What article of the Constitution covers the federal judicial power?
Article III
Federal judicial power extends to cases involving:
(1) Interpretation of the Constitution, federal law, treaties, and admiralty and maritime laws; and
(2) Disputes between states, states and foreign citizens, and citizens of diverse citizenship
What part of the Constitution allows the SCOTUS to review state acts?
Supremacy Clause
Under Article III, federal courts have power over ______ and _______
Cases, Controversy
True or False, federal judges have lifetime tenure?
True
What is the only type of case in which the SCOTUS has exclusive original jurisdiction?
controversies between states
What two ways can cases come to the SCOTUS?
(1) writ of certiorari; and
(2) appeals from three-judge panels of the federal district court
SCOTUS has ________ discretion to hear cases that come to it by certiorari.
complete
When is it appropriate for the SCOTUS to grant cert on a case coming from state courts?
(1) the constitutionality of a federal statute, treaty, or state statute is at issue;
(2) a state statute allegedly violates a federal law
True or false: the constitution bars the federal courts from issuing advisory opinions?
True, there must be specific present harm or threat of specific future harm.
What must a plaintiff show to satisfy a court that it would not be issuing an advisory opinion in a certain case?
That they have engaged in (or wish to engage in) specific conduct and that the challenged action poses a real and immediate danger to their interests.
What factors will courts consider to determine whether a case is ripe for review?
(1) fitness of the issues for judicial decision;
(2) the hardship to the parties of withholding court consideration
When will an issue not be fit for judicial decision under the ripeness doctrine?
When it relies on uncertain or contingent future events that may not occur as anticipated.
What is the consequence if an issue has already been resolved before a judicial determination can be made on a matter?
The case will be dismissed as moot.
What are the exceptions to the mootness doctrine?
(1) when the controversy is capable of repetition, but evading review; OR
(2) when a defendant who contrarily stops the offending practice but is free to resume
(3) a class representative may continue to pursue a class action after the representative’s controversy has become moot if claims of other class members are still viable
What are the requirements a plaintiff must show to establish standing?
(1) injury in fact
(2) causation
(3) redressability
What is required to have injury in fact?
(1) a particularized injury (one that affects the plaintiff in a personal way)
(2) a concrete injury
Must a plaintiff have an economic injury in order to have standing?
No.
Define redressability.
Exists when a decision in the litigant’s favor must be capable of eliminating her grievance
May congress expressly grant standing to someone not having an “injury in fact”?
No, but congress can create new interests, injury to which may confer standing
When does a plaintiff have standing to enforce a federal statute?
if she is within the “zone of interests” Congress meant to protect.
True or false: generally, a plaintiff has standing to assert the claims of others to obtain standing
False
When does a plaintiff have standing to assert the rights of others?
(1) if it is difficult for the third party to assert her own rights; OR
(2) a special relationship exists between the claimant and the third party (doctor/patient)
When may an organization sue on behalf of its members?
(1) there is an injury in fact to members
(2) the injury is related to the organizations purpose; AND
(3) individual member participation in the lawsuit is not required
May a person claim standing because there are a citizen claiming that the government action violates federal law or constitution?
No, but a person may have standing to allege that federal action violates the tenth amendment, as long as the person has a redressable injury in fact.
True or false: a taxpayer has standing to litigate her own tax bill?
True
Does a tax payer have standing to challenge government expenditures? What are the exceptions to this rule?
No. A tax payer has standing to challenge congressional spending measures on First Amendment Establishment Clause grounds
What is the doctrine of independent and adequate State Grounds?
It states that the SCOTUS will not exercise jurisdiction if the state court judgment is based upon independent and adequate state law grounds, even if federal issues are involved.
True or false: the SCOTUS will temporarily abstain from resolving constitutional claim when the disposition rests on an unsettled question of state law.
True
Will a federal court enjoin pending state criminal proceedings?
No, except in cases of proved harassment or prosecution taken in bad faith
What types of claims are barred by the political question doctrine?
issues that are:
(1) constitutionally committed to another branch of government;
(2) inherently incapable of judicial resolution
What are common types of questions that federal courts will decline to hear under the political question doctrine?
(1) republican for of government” clause of Article IV
(2) challenges to congressional procedures for ratifying constitutional amendments;
(3) presidents conduct of foreign policy;
(4) partisan legislative apportionment (gerrymandering)
What does the Eleventh Amendment do?
prohibits federal courts from hearing a private party’s or foreign governments claims against a state government.
What types of cases does the Eleventh Amendment apply to?
Cases in which state is named as a party or in which the state will pay retroactive damages (regardless of how the damages are categorized)
The Supreme Court has held that the doctrine of _______ ________ bars suits against a state government in state court, even on federal claims, unless the defendant state consents.
Sovereign Immunity
Are actions against local governments barred by the Eleventh Amendment?
No
Are actions against a state by the US or other states barred by the Eleventh Amendment?
No.
Are bankruptcy proceedings against a state barred by the Eleventh Amendment?
No.
When are actions against state officials allowed under the Eleventh Amendment?
(1) actions to enjoin an officer from future conduct that violates the Constitution or federal law;
(2) actions for damages against an officer personally
For what actions may Congress remove 11th Amendment immunity for the states?
actions created under the Fourteenth Amendment, where it is unmistakably clear that Congress intended to remove the immunity
What powers can Congress validly exercise under the Constitution?
those powers enumerated in the Constitution plus all auxiliary powers necessary and proper to carry out all powers vested in the federal government
Can the necessary and proper Clause, standing alone, support a federal law?
No.
What test will be used to judge the constitutionality of a tax?
(1) the tax must bear some reasonable relationship to revenue production, or
(2) have the power to regulate the activity taxed.
For what purpose may Congress use its spending power?
To provide for the common defense and general welfare. Congress may spend for any public purpose
What can Congress regulate under the Commerce Clause?
(1) channels of interstate commerce
(2) the instrumentalities of interstate commerce and person and things moving in interstate commerce
(3) activities that have a substantial effect on interstate commerce
When Congress attempts to regulate intrastate activity under the commerce clause, what standard must it meet in order to be constitutional?
(1) economic or commercial activity: the Court must be able to conceive of a rational basis on which Congress could conclude the activity in aggregate substantially affects interstate commerce.
(2) noneconomic activity: Congress must be able to show a direct substantial economic effect on interstate commerce.
True or False: Congress can compel activity under the Commerce Clause.
False
Who has the power to declare war?
Congress
Does Congress have a general police power?
No.
True or False: Congress has plenary powers over aliens?
True
Are resident aliens entitled to notice and hearing before being deported?
Yes
May the Legislature delegate legislative power to the other breaches of government?
Yes, as long as intelligible standards are set and the power is not uniquely confined to Congress. (however, no law has been struck down under this standard since 1936)
What is a legislative veto? are they constitutional?
It is an attempt by congress to overturn an executive agency action without bicameralism (house and senate approval) or presentment (to the president).
No, it is not constitutional
When may Congress vest the appointment power in someone other than the President?
when it is for the appointment of an inferior office
Can the President’s pardon power be limited by congress?
No.
What portion of the house and senate must vote to overturn a presidential veto?
2/3
What is a line item veto? Is it constitutional?
A line item veto is an attempt by the president to veto discrete sections of a bill and approve others.
No, it is not constitutional
When are the president’s powers at their highest and likely to be valid?
When she is acting with the express authority of Congress
When are the president’s powers at their lowest and likely to be invalid?
When she is acting against the express will of Congress
What is the authority of the president when he acts where congress has been silent?
his action will be upheld unless it users the power of another govnmental branch or prevents another branch or prevents another branch from carrying out its tasks
Does the president have the power to declare war?
No
Are state laws that conflict with valid treaties are invalid?
Yes
Which prevails when a treaty conflicts with federal law?
The one enacted last in time
Which prevails when a treaty conflicts with the Constitution?
The Constitution
Do executive agreements need the consent of the Senate to be valid?
No
What prevails between a conflicting state law and executive agreement?
executive agreement
What prevails between a conflicting federal law and executive agreement?
the federal law
When does the executive privilege apply?
applies to keep certain communications secret. National Security is given the greater deference
When does the exception to the executive privilege apply?
Applies in criminal cases where presidential communications will be available to the prosecution where a need for such info is demonstrated.
What is executive immunity?
Absolute immunity from suit for any actions arising DURING presidency
Who is subject to impeachment?
All civil officers of the US
What is the process for impeachment?
(1) 1/2 vote of impeachment in the house
(2) 2/3 vote of conviction in the senate
Because of the ________ Clause, a federal law may supersede or preempt local laws
Supremacy
What are the two general types of preemption?
express and implied
What are the three types of implied preemptions?
(1) conflict/impossibility
(2) obstacle
(3) field
True or false: in all preemption cases, the courts will start with the presumption that the historic police powers of the state are not preempted unless it was the clear and manifest purpose of Congress
True
May the US sue a state without its consent?
Yes
May states sue the US without its consent?
No, Unless the US has waived its immunity for the particular suit.
May a state sue another state without its consent?
Yes
When may Congress regulate the conduct of a state?
(1) congress may restrict state activities that violate civil liberties
(2) congress may regulate the states through its spending power (ice, conditions imposed on receipt of federal funds)
When may congress regulate the states through its spending power?
(1) when the conditions are clearly stated
(2) the conditions relate the purpose of the program; AND
(3) are not unduly coercive
May a state tax the federal government?
No, not without the US’s consent
What does the Article IV Privileges and Immunities Clause prohibit?
discrimination by a state against nonresidents regarding fundamental rights
Are corporations protected by the Article IV Privileges and Immunities Clause?
No
What fundamental rights are protected by the Article IV Privileges and Immunities Clause?
rights relating to important commercial activities (pursuit of livelihood) or civil liberties.
When will a state law discriminating against nonresidents be valid under the Article IV Privileges and Immunities Clause? What must the state prove under this standard?
when there is substantial justification for the different treatment.
The state must show that the nonresidents are the cause or part of the problem the state is attempting to solve and there are no less restrictive means of achieving the state’s goal