Constitutional law Flashcards
Individual ministerial responsibility is a …
constitutional convention
How can Parliament can override or displace an existing prerogative power?
Through statute
Can the government introduce a bill in Parliament that would breach a recognised constitutional convention?
Yes
- Parliament is sovereign and legally can pass any legislation it pleases.
- The courts will recognise the convention’s existence, but this will not stop them applying the legislation.
Are constitutional conventions enforceable?
No
can a monarch withold Royal Assent to a Bill that parliament wants to pass
- constitutional convention finds that the Monarch should not refuse asssent
- if Parliament votes in favour of the Bill, the Monarch should give Royal Assent to it.
- constitutional conventions aren’t enforceable so the monarch ‘should’ rather than ‘must’ give consent
Describe the UK’s constitution
- unwritten
- monarchical
- rigid
- informal separation of powers.
- unitary
Can a MP crititcise an indidviual memeber on the judiciary?
No
- the convention wont allow this
- MP’s must resign if they want to criticise a member publicly
If the royal prerogative and statute come into conflict, which will prevail?
statute. (Miller v Secretary of state)
If the government is considering introducing a compensation scheme for victims of some recent extreme weather events, but there is no statutory scheme in place what can they do?
- adopt a non-statutory scheme pursuant to its prerogative power
- subject to Parliament voting the necessary funds. ( government cannot use the prerogative to authorise expenditure)
If the government loses an important case in the Supreme Court which affects its ability to carry out a manifesto commitment, what can they do?
- government can introduce legislation into Parliament
- which retrospectively changes the law
- and effectively overrides the judgment.
Breaches of conventions (such as collective cabinet responsibility) may result in…
political sanctions, but not legal sanctions.
what is the sub judice rule?
its a rule that
- prevents MPs or Lords
- from discussing matters
- which are currently or imminently being considered by the Courts.
what is the basis of the sub judice rule as a source of the UK constitution?
Law and custom of Parliament
- NOT constituional convention
what happens if a minister makes a grave error which has resulted in significant harm to UK citizens?
principle of individual ministerial responsibility
- constitutional convention = Resignation although, this is not legally enforceable
what does parliamentary privilege protect?
- MP’s freedom to represent their constituents and freely express their views
- Parliament’s internal affairs from interference by the courts.
- civil arrest whilst parliament is in session
- exclusive cognisance