Considerations of counselling people from minorities Flashcards
What is a minority therapy a concern?
Over 50% of the state of California is composed of
minority groups.
The worldviews of a culturally diverse population are likely to be quite different from that of the helping professional. Need to be aware in order to aid positive self-development.
Anagram of 5 consideration
DAPUC
Deconstructing the therapist’s self
name
Understanding and being open with clients differences of thinking, experiencing as a result of socialisation can only take place when we have undergone our own personal exploration and learning.
Hicks and Milton (2010) - important all therapists have critically considered how their identity will affect their practise with their client.
How they see you. Need to explore what it means by the client to be perceived as the same or different.
Critique of deconstructing the therapist’s self
A client can sense how cultural information is asked and why. Do not assume the client is thinking what you have self discovered.
Attend to ‘pre-transference’
name
Don’t idealise the clients culture, resist the need to help the social exclusion of the client.
Important to understand the impact of culture in the client’s lives, as well as meaning of culture in our own lives.
Milton (2016) - phenomenological rule of epoche, being aware of your own views and making sure they don’t impact the session to avoid judgement.
Challenge one’s own ethnocentrism and stereotypes about the other culture.
Critique of attending to pre-transference
Issues of colour blindness technique, actually a form a racism (Terwilliger et al 2013), excuse to remain ignorant to cultures and customs of their minority. Need to address trauma if it is apparent.
Understanding the client
name
Examine conscious and unconscious relationship to culture. Be open to how they present their culture rather than your image.
Understand their journey into the new culture.
Hicks and Milton (2010) - avoid assumptions: identity and totality of being should not be assumed, minority aspects interacts with multiple other factors, religion, culture which may moderate the influencing effects
Avoid excusing dysfunctional behaviour as culturally normative
Intersectionality
Clear awareness and challenge own ethnocentrism and any stereotypes evoked when coming into contact with other cultural groups.
Critique of understanding the client / challenging stereotypes
name
Eleftheriadou (2012)
Avoid othering and difference, whilst it can be reassuring to the client attempting to understand his minority issues, it can come across negatively.
Cross-culture clients can feel overwhelmed by the task of ‘educating’ their counsellor, before they even bring their issue.
Avoid us and them - making them bare responsibility of representing their people, focus on the issues
Avoid Microaggressions / building relationship
Name 2
Be aware of subtle racism “regular person” - devalues exchange simply because he belongs to a minority group.
Being attentive and knowledgeable about other cultures can provide significant connection.
Spinelli (1989) notes the paradoxical nature of bracketing biases and recognising they exist, - suggests the mere acknowledgement lessens the impact upon our immediate experience
Sue (2007) Unconsciously delivered, most difficult to combat as unaware
Who ran the study to do with microaggressions what did it entail and what did they find?
Constantine (2007) - examined microaggressions effect on relationship with client
Undertook a focus group with self-identified minority counselling clients to create themes and then underwent a literature review investigating these themes.
Greater perceived racial microaggressions were predictive of a weaker therapeutic alliance
which, in turn, predicted lower ratings of general and multicultural counseling competence.
Clinical modifications / non-verbal
name
Nonverbal communication. Attend to the sensitivity of non-verbal language, and interpersonal distance. Make sure the client is speaking the way they feel most comfortable.
In certain parts of the Middle East, thumbs-up is definitely a highly offensive thumbs-down.
Paralanguage, kinesics and proxemics - part of everyday communication provide stronger messages than the verbal.
Non-verbal behaviour more unconscious – more primitive so can be more revealing.
Use of interpreters - emotional difficulty, complicate dynamic, superiority.
Eleftheriadou (2012)
Critique of clinical modifications
Be wary not to close off body language in fear of offence as this could also send the wrong message
Avoid them and us labels as can be unwanted pity and segregation
According to Landridge what is Gay Affirmative therapy?
Work to lessen shame and guilt. Use your authority to affirm LGB identities.
Address cultural bereavement
Issues with Gay Affirmative therapy?
Ethical therapy is enough to treat them as an equal.
Assumptions could lead to negative impact on the relationship.
5 considerations of affirmative practise?
Deconstruction of the therapist's self Pre-transference Avoid Microaggressions Understanding the client Clinical Modifications