Conscience Flashcards
What are the 4 functions our conscience can have?
1.A sense of moral obligation or duty
2.A sense of guilt
3.An awareness of the difference between right and wrong
4.A guide
Who believes that the conscience is “reason making right decisions”?
•Aquinas
What 3 things does Aquinas believe the conscience consists of?
1.Synderesis
2.Ratio
3.Conscienta
What is synderesis?
•It is our natural inclination to do good and avoid evil
- It is an innate level of practical reason we all share
What is ratio?
•It is what tells us what is good or evil (use Bible, Church teachings and past experiences to help)
- It leads us to the principles of Natural Law
- It allows us to share in God’s nature due to reason ultimately coming from God
What is conscienta?
•It is the final stage where we apply the principles to a situation
- It guides us but also judges us by producing guilt
What does Aquinas believe the conscience is “not”?
•He believes the conscience is “not a power but an act”
- This means it is not an ability we have but something that we do
What does Aquinas believe about the conscience?
•He believes it is “knowledge applied to an individual case”
What do the 3 stages of the conscience do?
1.Acts as a witness
2.Judges our actions
3.Judges whether we have done the rights thing
- Aquinas believes these are all actions
What does Aquinas’ theory of the conscience uphold?
•It upholds absolute laws that apply to everyone
What are the 2 main implications of Aquinas’ theory of the conscience?
1.The conscience cannot be used to justify breaking any moral absolutes
- This is because correct reason would tell us it’s evil and synderesis would prevent us from acting
2.The conscience can make mistakes as reason can cause us to see a mistaken goal if wrong
- This is “mistaken reason”
What is an example of “mistaken reason”?
•An example is of a man that commits adultery because he followed a lesser good (lust) rather than God
What is vincibile ignorance?
•It is ignorance that could have been overcome
- This causes us to be morally blameworthy
What is invincible ignorance?
•It is when we are in situations where we could not have known what we were doing was wrong
- This means we are not morally blameworthy
What does Aquinas believe the conscience is equivalent to?
•He believes it is equivalent to God’s Law
What quote illustrates Aquinas’ belief that the conscience is equivalent to God’s Law?
•He states “when a reason which is in error proposes something as a command of God, then to dismiss the dictate of reason is just the same dismissing the command of God”
What supports Aquinas’ view that the conscience is linked with God?
•The Catechism of the Catholic Church
- It states that the conscience encourages people “to do good and avoid evil” while also acting as a “judgement of reason”
Who argues the conscience is more directly linked with God?
•Augustine
- He argues that we cannot know right and wrong through our own reason due to our reason being changeable and fallible while morality is unchangeable
What is the conscience for Augustine?
•It is God’s truth impressed on our hearts like a ring impressed on wax
Who argues that are natural inclinations are actually driven by our sexual desires?
•Freud
Strengths of Aquinas’ theory of the conscience:
1.Important for Christians to have our morality linked with God
2.Displays how we are involved in the development of our conscience and how it is not just the voice of God within us
3.Vincible and Invincible Ignorance frees us from unnecessary guilt
Weaknesses of Aquinas’ theory of the conscience:
1.Conscience is more directly linked with God
2.Outdated - established before psychology and behavioural sciences
3.Overly positive view of human nature