ConLaw Flashcards
Article III section II limits jurisdiction of federal court
Law-Based JDX
-Constitution
-Admiralty and Maritime
Party-Based JDX
-Where US is party
-2 or more states
-state and citizens of other states
-ambassadors and counsel
-diversity jdx
11th amendment
private individauls cannot sue states for money damages in any court
Exceptions;
-federal suits brought by one state against another
-suits brought by the federal government against state
-subdivisions of states do not have this imunity
-private citizen may sue state requesting injunction
-state may consent to suit in federal court if it clearly waives immunity
-congress can authorized individual citizen private suits involving moneytary damage for violations of 13, 14 ,15 amendments
11th amendment
private individuals cannot sue states for money damages in any court
Exceptions;
-federal suits brought by one state against another
-suits brought by the federal government against state
-subdivisions of states do not have this immunity
-private citizen may sue state requesting injunction
-state may consent to suit in federal court if it clearly waives immunity
-congress can authorized individual citizen private suits involving monetary damage for violations of 13, 14 ,15 amendments
To address getting into federal courts; RAMPS
RAMPS
S; Standing; must show a direct and impending injury in fact
R; Ripeness
A; Abstentions
M; Mootness (Exception is if the injury is capable of repetition)
Political Question
Legislative Power
Congress has the power given by the CONST, including pass laws
Congress gets power to legislate from 3 sources (PEN);
P; Power and money (collecting taxes)
E: Enabling clauses of 13, 14, 15 Amendments
N; Necessary and Proper Clause
Commerce Power
Congress can regulate interstate commerce, instrumentalities of interstate commerce, Activities (that substantially affect interstate commerce)
Commerce Power; Substantial Effect
Congress is meant to regulate any economic activity, so long as it effects interstate commerce
Commerce Powers; Cumulative Effect doctrine
multiple activities, related, effecting interstate commerce
Taxing Power
Congress has the power to impose and collect taxes so long as its;
for raising revenue
regulate activity
NOT ALLOWED TO BE PENALTY
Executive Powers
VAPER
Veto
Appointment
Pardon
Enforcement
Removal
Dormant Commerce Clause
States cannot discriminate out-of-state economic actors.
If state law discriminates, the STATE must show;
regulation serves a COMPELLING interest
regulation is necessary
Due Process Clause
5th and 14th Amendment;
Procedural Due Process
Substantive Due Process
Procedural Due Process
Protects against deprivation of life, liberty, or property without due process
Liberty (Broad) things like restraint and punishment
Property (Narrow) things like public education, public employment (if a K exists) welfare, driver’s license
Substantive Due Process
Rational Basis Review v. Strict Scrutiny
- Substantive due process requires legislation be rationally related to LEGITIMATE government Purpose
Economic regulations
Substantive due process challenge directed at economic regulation is subject to rational basis review
-Burden is on plaintiff to show (1) government interest is not legit, (2) if it is legit, it is not rationally related to promoting it.
Fundamental Rights
Strict Scrutiny applied; (1) government interest being served is COMPELLING (2) legislation is NARROWLY TAILORED
Four kinds of takings
Regulatory; government imposes regulation that causes owner to suffer some permanent physical invasion
Direct government appropriation; actually taking the property
Temporary restrictions
Conditional permits; permissible if (1) logical nexus b/w condition and gov’t purpose and (2) rough proportionality b/w impact and gov’t objectives
Rational Basis
Plaintiff must prove no rational relation to any legitimate governmental interest
Applies to;
Age
Alienage
Disability
Sexual Orientation
Aliens
Wealth
All Else
Intermediate scrutiny
Government must show that the measure being challenged is SUBSTANTIALLY related to an IMPORTANT government interest
Applied to;
Gender
Child Legitimacy
Strict Scrutiny
Government must prove that the measure being challenged serves a COMPELLING government interest and it is NECESSARY to further that interest
Applies to;
Alienage (state)
Domestic Travel
National Origin
Race
Voting
Privileges and Immunities under Article IV, Section 2
Comity Clause provides citizens of each states are privileged to all rights of citizens of other states
The Contracts Clause
State legislation changes a contract obligation, the court shall look at the Severity of the Impairment and the importance of the public interest served
Ex Post Facto
Legislatures cannot criminalize behavior or increase punishment after the fact
Bills of Attainder
Legislatures may not inflict punishment on an individual or easily ascertainable group for past conduct without trial