ConLaw 1 Final Study Flashcards
Case & Controversy
- Federal courts only hear actual disputes between meaningfully adverse parties for which judicial resolution is possible;
- There must be a definite and live dispute that is not speculative or uncertain;
- Plaintiffs must demonstrate a personal stake in the outcome.
Standing
- Plaintiff must be the proper party for adjudication and have suffered an;
- injury in fact that is concrete and not too speculative or uncertain;
- a causal connection between the injury and defendant’s conduct; and
- redressability through the requested relief.
Third-Party Standing (general rule and 3 exceptions)
- Plaintiff cannot assert claims of third parties unless;
- plaintiff has standing; and
- there is either a special relationship; or the injured party is
- debilitated and cannot assert their own claims; or
- Vague under first amendment.
Associational Standing
Organization can sue for its members if:
A) individual members would have standing to sue;
B) interests are germane to organization’s purpose; and
C) neither the claim nor relief requires individual members (unique money damages).
Taxpayer Standing / Generalized Grievances
- Plaintiff must not be suing solely as a citizen or taxpayer; unless
- a taxpayer is challenging a specific limitation of Congress’s tax and spend power; or
- expenditures violating the Establishment Clause.
Congressional Standing
- Plaintiff may have standing if conferred by statute; if
- within the zone of interests Congress meant to protect; but
- can never eliminate case or controversy requirement.
Ripeness
IPIF
- Plaintiff is not entitled to review of a law before its enforcement; unless
- plaintiff will suffer some harm or IMMEDIATE threat of harm.
- Court will consider:
a. the PROBABILITY of harm;
b. hardship if IMMEDIATE relief is denied; and
c. FITNESS of the record for resolving legal issues.
Mootness
- Plaintiff must have a live controversy at all stages of review;
- If injury already occurred or ceased and no exception exists, it is moot.
- Exceptions are:
a. Voluntary cessation;
b. Capable of repetition yet evading review; and
c. Class actions.
Capable of Repetition Yet Evading Review
- Claims must be justiciable throughout all stages of review.
- Plaintiff must establish:
a. challenged action is too short in duration prior to its cessation; and
b. demonstrated probability that harm will reoccur.
Voluntary Cessation
- Otherwise moot claim justiciable where voluntary cessation.
- Courts consider:
a. likelihood of reoccurrence which defendant bears the burden of disproving; and
b. efforts by defendant to eradicate effects of challenged conduct.
Class Actions
Will not be moot if one class member’s claim is moot.
Political Question (Common Areas)
- Non-justiciable issue constitutionally committed to; or
- leading to disrespect or encroachment upon another branch; or
- inherently incapable of judicial resolution; and
- lacking judicially manageable standards; such as
a. republican form of government,
b. impeachment and removal,
c. partisan gerrymandering, and
d. foreign policy (RIPF)
Adequate and Independent State Grounds
- Adequate if due process is not denied and advances a legitimate state interest applied in a consistent fashion;
- Independent if decision does not interweave federal issues and contains a plain statement that case was decided solely on state grounds.
Supreme Court Review (where cases come from)
Can come from:
1. state’s highest court,
2. US Court of Appeals,
3. US court via certiorari, and
4. cases between states.
Sovereign Immunity
- 11th Amendment bars federal courts from hearing suits by private citizens or foreign governments against states (but not local governments);
- States may be sued if there is express waiver or consent;
- for actions under Section 5 of the 14th Amendment; and
- Suits against state officers are allowed for injunctive relief for officer violation of federal law;
- May sue officers for damages paid by officer personally.
Abstention
- Federal court will not hear a case to enjoin pending state criminal proceedings;
- unless conducted in bad faith; or
- to harass; or
- for unsettled questions of state law until after state settles underlying question.
Necessary and Proper Clause
- Congress may enact all laws necessary and proper to carry out any power;
- granted to any federal branch;
- Can never support federal law independently and must be linked with an enumerated power.
Congressional Authority to Act / Property Clause. What must it be and what is it not? And which areas special powers?
- Must be an enumerated or implied Congressional power;
- No federal police power; but
- Congress does have power over military, Indian reservations, federal land, and the District of Columbia (MILD).