Congress Flashcards
What are the concurrent powers of Congress?
- Constitutional amendments - two thirds of both houses must agree to amendment
- Confirming a new VP, if the office becomes vacant through resignation or becoming president they must vote in a new one.
- Passing legislation. All legislation must pass both houses.
What are the exclusive powers of the House?
- Elect a president if the electoral college is deadlocked.
- Initiate money bills, only they can initiate but both vote on it.
- Bring articles of impeachment - Clinton 1998, trump 2020, 2021.
What are the exclusive powers of the Senate?
- Confirm presidential appointments; judicial nominees, cabinet appointments, ambassadors etc.
- Gives advice and consent, allowing the President to ratify treaties (2/3 of senate)
- Try cases of impeachment, 2/3 of senate to remove a president.
- Elect VP if the electoral college is deadlocked.
What are the checks that Congress have on the President? (6)
- Block or amend their proposed legislation
- Override President’s veto
- Power of the purse
- Confirm appointments
- Declare war/ approve military action
- Ratify treaties.
Example of congress having an effect on Obama’s legislation
- Passed ACA 2010 (BUT - Conservative democrats forced Obama’s hand into passing an EO against using federal money for abortions so they would vote for it.)
- Blocked his immigration reform and gun reform (Assault Weapons Ban of 2013)
How did Congress attempt to hold up Trump’s proposals?
- Blocked his demand for money for the wall in budget; tried to block his national emergency by passing a resolution but he vetoed it, they couldn’t get 2/3 to override that.
- However, he would have been a lot more successful if he had had congress’ support.
- Trump failed to pass healthcare reform multiple times, especially his AHCA in 2017 (nicknamed Trumpcare), as Republicans in Congress revolted
When was power of the purse used?
- To try to stop Vietnam, Iraq and the wall.
- Bush pocket vetoed the Iraq defunding, and Trump used a national emergency to fund the wall instead (which Congress failed to stop)
Examples of Congress blocking appointments
- Mitch McConnell wouldn’t hear Merrick Garland’s hearing.
- They blocked John Towers’s appointment for claims of alcohol abuse (Secretary of Defense)
- Democrats blocked Robert Bork for SC because of his very Conservative views (partisan)
Recent controvertial SC nominee
Amy Coney Barret appointed in 2020, just a month before the election - heard and appointed, even though McConnel refused to hold a vote on Garland in the same circumstances in 2016.
Appointment that highlights a loophole and failure of Congress’ oversight, and its signficance
Appointment of Trump loyalist Whitaker as “ACTING” attorney general. Normally, the senate must confirm appointments but under the Federal Vacancies Act (1998), Trump can avoid this by appointing him ‘temporarily’.
It was the day after the midterms where the Dems took control of the house and would have likely scrutinised Trump strongly on Mueller report - Whitaker provided more protection.
It also sets precedent for other Presidents, obstruction of justice - weak congress.
Congressional power to declare war
Last used in 1942, against Hungaria, Bulgaria and Romania
But since the US has been in wars and lots of military activity, this is due to the president’s power as commander in chief.
Treaties that the Senate have/ have not ratified
Disability Rights Treaty 2012 - not ratified but signed by Obama in 09 and negotiated by Bush
Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty with Russia 2010. (NEW START), ratified 71-26
What are the 6 oversight powers of congress?
- Impeachment
- Power of the Purse
- Ratifying treaties
- Ratifying appointments
- Investigation through committees
- Approving military action
Summarise the Russia Investigation and if it was effective oversight
- Trump was being investigated for possible collusion with Russia in the 2016 election, by FBI director James Comey (who Trump fired) and Special Counsel Robert Mueller (appointed by Dep. AG rosenstein)
- Trump tried very hard to obstruct any efforts, offering pardons, trying to convince people at private dinners, using executive privilege and releasing a redacted version of the Mueller report to the public.
- In the end, although Mueller said there was almost definitely Russian interference, he couldn’t prove that the Trump campaign were involved.
- It’s effective oversight because it needed to be brought to light but it was mainly partisan motivated.
Things that affect effective Congressional oversight of the president
- Whether the house, senate and president belong to the same party
- When the next election is (congress may be more focused on pleasing constituents)
- Which branch has the most recent mandate
- The poll and popularity ratings of the president.
- National circumstances and context