Congress Flashcards
What is the nature of Congress (hint: number of chambers)? What are the respective chambers called?
Bicameral
House of Representatives and the Senate
What are the election cycles in Congress? How does this differ to the UK?
US:
HoR elected every 2 years
Senators serve 6 year terms (1/3 of the Senate is put up for election every 2 years)
UK:
MPs elected every 5 years
HoL not elected
How are Congressmen assigned to represent the public? How does this differ to the UK?
US:
Representatives proportionally represent states based upon population
2 Senators per state
UK:
1 MP per constituency
What are some exclusive powers to the HoR? (3)
- Impeachment - power to accuse any executive or judicial officer (including President) of acting unconstitutionally/beyond their authority
- Power of the purse - HoR can initiate money bills
- Electing the President when no candidate receives an absolute majority and Electoral College is in gridlock (very rare - only used twice in 19th century)
How many times has the HoR used their impeachment powers? Example (2)?
17 times
Impeached Richard Nixon (Watergate scandal) and Bill Clinton (over perjury and obstruction of justice following sexual harassment allegations)
Why does the HoR have the power of the purse?
Chamber that is more immediately representative of the public should have the power over how public money is spent (NO TAXATION WITHOUT REPRESENTATION)
How significant is the HoR’s power of the purse?
Not very significant as many money bills originate in the executive branch + Senate can totally modify the contents of the bill (provided HoR agree to ths differences in a conference)
What are some exclusive powers of the Senate? (3)
- Confirms many Presidential nominations to executive and judicial branch positions by a simple majority
- Confirms the ratification/withdrawal of a treaty by a 2/3 super-majority (some power of foreign policy)
- Runs investigation/trial following HoR impeachment -> if found guilty, accused must resign
How significant is the Senate’s power to confirm treaties? (2)
Check and balance on President’s power over foreign policy
- cannot unilaterally join/withdraw from a treaty
- power can be used as a negotiating tool
What are some concurrent powers between the HoR and the Senate? (4)
- Co-equal powers in legislation - both chambers must agree on the final version of the bill + no chamber can override the other)
- Constitutional amendments must pass with a 2/3 super-majority in both chambers
- 2/3 super-majority required in both chambers to override a President’s veto
- Both chambers must agree with a simple majority to declare war (last used in 1941 - used infrequently)
**How does Congress differ to the UK HoC?
US:
- Both chambers are co-equal in passing legislation
- 2/3 supermajority required to amend constitution
- Senate holds more exclusive powers than HoL
- Senators are elected
- Election cycles
- Individual Senators hold more influence than Lords (1 in 100)
UK:
- HoC can override HoL veto by delaying legislation by 1 year (except for secondary legislation, money bills, and any legislation extending the parliamentary term beyond 5 years)
- Simple majority is required to amend constitution
- HoL weaker chamber compared to HoC
- HoL appointed
- Election cycles
- Lords hold less individual influence than Senators (1 in 800)
**How are Congress and the UK HoC similar?
- Both chambers must agree on the final version of the bill (UK - ‘ping-pong’)
What does the House Speaker do? Significance? (5)
- Presiding officer over the HoR
- Maintains discipline in the House
- Appoints majority of members on the House Rules Committee -> HRC usually is disproportionally made up of Reps from the majority party -> easier for majority party to further own agenda as they select which bills continue onto House floor for second reading
- Appoints chairs of committees
- Leader of the Opposition - if of a different party to the President
How is the House Speaker chosen?
Voted in by a simple majority by the majority party in HoR - so usually from the majority party
What do the majority and minority leaders do? Significance?
- Party chief strategist
- Liaise with Senate leaders/executive -> makes legislative process smoother (eg. able to flag up issues the POTUS has with the bill early on in its passage; able to see if there is enough support to override the President’s veto)
- Chief spokesperson of their party (to the news)
- Day-to-day assistance alongside party whips
What are the roles of a standing committee? (3) Elaborate + example
- Drafting and amending legislation during committee stage - holds hearings to gather research
- Running investigations in their relevant policy area - scrutiny and accountability in the executive (policy failures, crises, etc.)
Eg. House Intelligence Committee investigated into the Trump-Russia issue and concluded that there had been no collusion - (SENATE ONLY) Vets through presidential nominees to relevant policy area -> casts a recommendary vote, which is non-binding, but is usually respected by Senators during the Senate floor vote (due to their expertise)
Eg. Senate Judicial Committee held hearings over sexual allegations during the confirmation process of SC nominee Brett Kavanaugh
Like UK select committees basically
What is the party balance in a standing committee? Significance?
Party balance of chamber is reflected in each standing committee -> easier for majority party to enforce agenda + perhaps less effective scrutiny (eg. Senate Intelligence Committee concluded there HAD BEEN collusion between Trump and Russia whilst House Intelligence Committee concluded NO collusion - Senate tends to be more bipartisan)
How powerful are standing committees?
POWERFUL:
1. Heavily involved in the legislative process (draft and amend the bill prior to its second reading before the floor)
2. Ability to investigate increases scrutiny and holds executive accountable -> can be used to instigate an impeachment process
3. Can block Presidential nominations
Eg. Senate Judicial Committee refused to even hold a hearing on Obama’s SC nominee Merrick Garland + suggestions that Trump’s support was strengthened as conservative voters feared the nomination of a liberal judge
4. Declaration of closed rules may strengthen legislative powers as no amendments can be made
NOT POWERFUL:
- Floor is able to reject/amend the bill
- Bill may not even be allowed to progress onto the floor for a second reading by HRC
- Major investigations may be run by select committees instead
- Recommendary vote on presidential nominees is not technically binding + voting along partisan lines means that respect for their decision is eroding
- Inability for floor to propose amendments under closed rules may doom the bill to failure
- Party balance within standing committee may weaken effective scrutiny
What is the role of the House Rules Committee? Significance?
They vote and select bills to progress onto the floor for a second reading + determine what level of amendments can be made to the bill. Thus able to block legislation by ‘pigeon-holing’ them
What is the party balance in the House Rules Committee? Significance?
Party balance reflected in HRC -> easier for majority party to block legislation that does not fit their agenda
What are the three types of rules assigned to bills by the HRC (in regards to amendments)?
- Open rules - free for any amendment to be made
- Modified rules - limits to what sections/who can propose/how many amendments can be made
- Closed rules - no amendments can be made whatsoever
What is the role of a conference committee?
To reconcile the differences between the finalised versions of a bill after it has passed through the HoR and Senate