Congestion charge Flashcards
why is congestion a problem
externalities
externalities d
one person’s actions affect another person’s well-being and the relevant costs and benefits are not reflected in market prices
what are the externalities of driving
local air pollution, global pollutants, congestion, accidents, noise, road damage
why is congestion bad
as traffic volumes increase in a given road space, the average speed of all vehicles slows down, and time costs are thus imposed on other road users
how is the MPC (marginal private cost) affected by congestion externalities
it rises because journey time increases with number of drivers
look at diagrams for congestion
in folder in designated area
what is the marginal external cost
marginal social cost - marginal private cost
how do you show marginal external cost on a diagram
first page of written notes
where is the initial equilibrium for the externalities diagram
where MPC = P(q) (demand)
where is the socially optimal point for externalities
where MSC = P(q) (demand)
what are the two ways to get from the initial point to the socially optimal point q* for congestion externalities
quantity rationing (typically based on number plates only let certain drive at certain times), price rationing (increase price until get to point)
example of where they used quantity rationing for congestion charge
athens drivers with even numbered plates on even days of the month and odd on days of the month with odd numbers
what is a pigovian tax (also spelled pigouvian)
a tax on any market activity that generates negative externalities
what is a pigouvian tax (pigovian) intended to do
correct an inefficient market outcome by being set equal to the social cost of the negative externalities
what does the pigouvian tax need to be set equal too
the social cost of the negative externalities
what are the problems with road pricing in practice
uncertainty about estimating msc and mpc etc, technology and administration costs, public opinion (people might not like so vote against etc)
what are the things you need to consider when thinking about quantity versus price rationing *
effectiveness (what is going to achieve q* with more certainty),
efficiency (which delivers lowest social cost/biggest social benefit),
equity (which is fairer)
what does equity mean for congestion charge
which is fairer
what does effectiveness mean in terms of the policies for congestion charge
which is going to achieve q* with more certainty
what does efficiency mean in terms of the policies for congestion charge
which delivers the lowest social cost/biggest social benefit
what is the effectiveness of quantity rationing
effective in the short run, in the long run households may adapt (multiple cars/license plates)
what is the efficiency of quantity rationing
does not account for demand for driving, some may be more affected than others, buying second car more costly than congestion charge
what is the equity of quantity rationing
in the short-run all treated the same, cost of rationing may be increasing with income
what is the effectiveness of price rationing
need to know marginal external cost (hard to calculate) may be easier to calculate in the long run,
also need to know elasticity of demand for driving which may vary between short and long run
what is the efficiency of price rationing
assuming effective, this would be socially efficient
progressive tax
proportion of tax you pay increases as your income goes up
is a congestion charge a progressive or regressive tax
as a flat rate it is regressive because the lower income you have the higher that is as a percentage of your income
talk about whether price rationing is equitable
horizontal - yes because all individuals are treated the same,
vertical - higher income individuals do not pay a higher percentage of income but also depends on who benefits from the proceeds from the congestion charge