Conformity Flashcards
Compliance
When someone changes their public behaviour but not private beliefs in order to be liked (fit in and avoid social rejection) - temporary, non-ambiguous and NSI
Identification
When an individual changes their public behaviour and private beliefs in the presence of a group in order to be liked - temporary, non-ambiguous and NSI
Internalisation
When an individual changed their public behaviour and private beliefs because they think the belief is right - ambiguous, permanent and ISI
Normative social influence
When a person conforms in order to be liked and fit in with a group
-based on a need to be liked
-short term
-leads to identification and compliance
-non-ambiguous situation
Informational social influence
When a person conforms because they want to gain knowledge ornthey believe someone is right
-based on the need to be right
-long term
-leads to internalisation
-ambigous
Evaluation of the types of conformity
Strengths:
Empirical evidence supports that people conform to be right and liked
Limitations:
Deutsch and Gerard: two process model as an explanation for conformity may not be a complete explanation for why people conform
Evaluation of Asch
Strengths:
-Lab study so highly controlled and standardised procedure carried out
-supportive evidence from Lucas et al (2006)
Limitations:
-Lacks temporal validity (Perrins and Spencer 1980) done during cold war
-demand characteristics
-lacks population validity
-artificial there was no reason not to conform
Variables affecting conformity
- group size
- unanimity
- task difficulty
Group size - results
- 1 confederate: 3% conformed
- 2 confederates: 12.8% conformed
- 3 confederates: 32% conformed
Didn’t change after 3 confederates were added
Unanimity - results
When a dissenter was added conformity dropped to 5.5% regardless if they were right or wrong
Task difficulty - results
Conformity increased when the comparison lines became closer in length - ppts looked to others for guidance
Social roles
A pattern of behaviour expected of a person in a given setting or group
Zimbardo (1973)
Conducted an extremely controversial study on conformity to social roles - Stanford prison experiment
Explanations for obedience
Agentic state & legitimacy of authority
Agentic state
A state of mind where the individual believes they don’t have responsibility for their behaviour as they are an agent of authority
Legitimacy of authority
Learnt through socialisation and is usually shown through uniform or setting
Situational variables affecting obedience
Proximity, location and the power of uniform
Obedience
A direct response to an order from another person
Proximity
Teacher and learner in the same room: 40% obedience
Teacher instructs learner over phone: 20.5% obedience