conflict of law Flashcards
Vested Rights
Traditional theory. Court applies the law of place where the cause of action occurred
Effects of Domicile
- Liable to the jursidiciton of the courts
2.matters relating to status such as marriage, legitimacy and adoption usually falls on under laws of domicile - transfer of property following death and wills often follow laws of domicile
4, considered an important contact - likely liable for state taxes.
changing domicile
physical presence in state and intent to remain there without a fixed time or purpose until returning to abode
Incapacity and domicile
- Minors attached to parents
- Insane individuals can choose domicile if competent enough
- Guardians can change domicile
corporations and domicile
Corps are domiciled in place of incorporation
Choice of law, state statute
If a state has a statute applying its law in a situation forum court applies this
Choice of law Characterizing the suit
State law of forum state. Ie forum court determines if it is a contracts, tort, family case
Choice of Law procedural
Court applies forum state procedure
Substantive Vs. Procedural
Court determines whether an issue is substantative or procedural based on forum state law
Most significant relationship approach to choice of law
Applies the most significant relationship to each issue. Thus a forum court may be exercising law from multiple jurisdictions. Ie its own, and where the occurrence occurred.
depecage
The process of applying law from different states. Generally the courts will only apply state law unless a litigant timely invokes the law of a foreign state and states that state law should apply.
Federal Courts in diversity action applying substantive law.
Follow the state laws of forum state for determining choice of law.
Factors in determining depecage
- the needs of the interstate and international systems(Choice of Law rules should further harmony between states and encourage commerce.
- relevant policies of forum
- the relevant policies of other interested states
- protection of justified expectations
- the basic policies underlying a particular field of law. ie validating contracts, or tort remedies
- predictability and uniform results
- ease of determination and application of law
Characterizing law in specific area’s
Be reasonable
Choice of Law in tort law
Place of injury.
many states follow the choice of law of the state where the occurence occurred, Nevada does too, unless a party presents evidence that another state has more significant relationship with the tort.
Choice of lawWrongful Death
Typically the rule is to follow place of injury unless another state has a more significant relationship to the party and the occurrence.
Choice of law Dram shop act
Usually applies in state where patron was served even if they caused injury in another state. Nevada has no Dram shop act.
Choice of law Workers compensation
Any state that has a legitimate interest in an injury and its consequences
Choice of Law workers comp factors
- injury occurred
- the employment is principally located
- Where the employer supervised the employee from
- State with most significant relationship to contract
- Contract has choice of law provision
- state has reasonable relationship to parties and occurrence
Successive awards in Workers comp cases
- an employee may file a workers comp claim in
Choice of Law Contracts
3 catogories
- contracts that specify governing law
- contracts that specify no choice of law
- UCC contracts