Con Law Tricky Flashcards
What are the elements of standing?
- Injury 2. Ripeness 3. Mootness 4. The issue cannot be a political question
What kind of injury is necessary for standing?
- The plaintiff must allege that he has been or imminently will be personally injured. 2. The plaintiff must show causation and redressibility. This means that the plaintiff must show that (a) the defendant caused the harm and (b) a favorable court decision is likely to remedy the injury. 3. A plaintiff cannot assert claims for third parties not before the court unless (a) there is a close relationship between the plaintiff and the injured party, (b) third party standing is allowed if the injured third party is unlikely to be able to assert his rights, and (c) organizations may sue on behalf of their members if (i) the members would have standing to sue, (ii) the interests are germane to the organizations purpose, and (iii) neither the claim nor relief requires participation of individual members. 4. The plaintiff is not suing on the basis of citizenship or as a taxpayer unless plaintiff is a taxpayer suing to challenge a government expenditure pursuant to federal or state or local laws violating the establishment clause.
What do plaintiffs filing for injunctive or declaratory relief have to show?
A likelihood of of future personal harm.
What is mootness?
The plaintiff must allege a live controversy unless (a) the wrong is capable of repetition but is evading review; (b) the defendant voluntarily halted the offending conduct but could take it up again at any time; (c) or it is a class action lawsuit and someone in the class can still sue.
What questions are barred by the political question doctrine?
- The republican form of government clause 2. Challenges to the president’s conduct of foreign policy 3. challenges to the impeachment and removal process 4. challenges to partisan gerrymandering
Over what cases does the Supreme Court sit in appellate jurisdiction?
Over cases decided by three-judge federal district courts.
When does the Supreme Court have original and exclusive jurisdiction?
For suits between states.
Will SCOtUS hear cases when a decision rests on state and federal law and reversing the federal law will not change the cases outcome?
No.
What are the only circumstances under which states can be sued?
- They waive sovereign immunity 2. The suit is brought under Section 5 of the 14th Amendment 3. The plaintiff is the Federal Government 4. The proceedings are bankruptcy proceedings
When can state officials be sued?
As long as it is not the state treasury that will be paying for the damages.
When does the federal Congress have police power?
- Military 2. Indians 3. Territories 4. D.C.
What is the necessary and proper clause?
Art. I Sec. 8: Congress can enact all laws necessary and proper for it to carry out its authority.
When can Congress levy taxes?
Congress can tax and spend on the general welfare.
What can Congress do under its Commerce Power?
- Regulate channels of interstate commerce
- Regulate instrumentalities and persons and things in interstate commerce
- Regulate economic activities that have a substantial effect on interstate commerce. BUT, Congress cannot regulate inactivity.
What is a legislative veto?
Passing a law without going through bicameralism and presentment. This is unconstitutional.
What is a line-item veto?
The president vetoes part of a bill but not the whole thing. This is unconstitutional.
Treaties require _____ in order to be effective.
Senate approval.
Treaties > ____
Conflicting State laws.
If a treaty conflicts with a federal law ______.
The instrument enacted last in time controls.
Does an executive agreement need Senate approval?
No.
What is an executive agreement?
An agreement between the President and the head of another nation.
_____ > Executive Agreement > _____
Federal laws and the constitution > Executive Agreements > State laws
The President’s power to use military abroad is ____.
Broad.
With Senate approval, the President appoints:
- Ambassadors 2. Federal judges 3. Officers of the United States
Who else can make appointments?
Anyone Congress vests with this power BUT Congress may not give this power to itself.
When can the president not make appointments?
During intercession recesses that are less than 10 days.
When can Congress limit the President’s ability to remove appointees?
Where the office is one where independence from the President is desirable.
Can Congress prohibit removal by the President?
No. It can only limit his ability to remove. For instance, to situations where he has good cause to remove.
When is impeachment appropriate?
When a federal officer or the executive has committed “treason, bribery, or high crimes and misdemeanors.”
When are state laws implicitly preempted?
- The laws are mutually exclusive 2. The state law impedes the achievement of a federal objective 3. Congress evidences a clear intent to preempt state law
Can states tax and regulate federal activity?
No. Never.
What is the dormant commerce clause of Art. IV?
It is a prohibition on state activity that “places an undue burden on interstate commerce.”
What is the privileges and immunities clause of Art. IV?
It prevents states from depriving citizens of other states from having the privileges and immunities they accord their citizens. It prevents discrimination.
When does the privileges and immunities clause of the 14th Amendment apply?
Only when the right to interstate travel is implicated.
When is a state’s discriminatory burden on interstate commerce acceptable?
- When it is necessary to achieve an important government purpose
- Congress approves
- The state is acting as a market participant
If a state law discriminates against out-of-staters with regards to their ability to earn a livelihood, it ________.
Violates the privileges and immunities clause of Art. IV, unless it is necessary to achieve an important government purpose.
When can a state tax interstate commerce?
When:
- It is not done to help in state businesses
- There is a substantial nexus between the interstate activity and the state
- The tax is fairly apportioned (for example, only 10% of the market share is in the state, the tax can’t exceed 10%).
When must private conduct comply with constitutional prohibitions on government activity re individual liberties?
- When the private entity is performing a task traditionally exclusively done by the government
- The government has entangled itself with the private activity by affirmatively authorizing, encouraging, or facilitating the unconstitutional activity
When can a numerical set-aside survive strict scrutiny?
Only when there is clear proof of past discrimination.
When can gender classifications be used?
Only when they (i) survive intermediate scrutiny and (ii) there is an exceedingly persuasive justification for the gender classification.