Con Law Flashcards
Case and Controversy
There must be an actual case or controvery in dispute. No political questions.
Standing
- To bring a claim, a person must have standing. Standing requires
- injury,
- causation, and
- redressibility.
- Third-party standing
-
Organizational standing requires that the
- individual members have standing
- that the interest asserted are related to the organization’s purpose and
- that individual members are not required to participate
Ripeness
A case eill not be heard if there is not yet a live controversy or immediate threat of harm (future harm)
**discuss when declaratory judgement AND encacted law not yet enforced**
Mootness
A case will not be heard of a live controversy exsisted at the time the complaint was filed but has since been eliminated
11th Amendment
The Eleventh Amendmen provides immunity to the states from any federal suit against any one of the states by citizens of another state or a foreign state
- cannot sue state
- Bars actions for damages
- Cities and counties OK
State Action
- There must be government action for an action to violate the constitution.
- The actions of a private actor can bw state action if
- performs function that are traditionally and exclusively public functions, OR
- state is heavy entangled
State Power: 10th Amendment
Under the 10th Amendment, powers not delegated to the federal government are reserved for the states
Federal Powers: Congress
- Can regulate commerce
- interstate
- channels
- instrumentalities
- persons and things moving
- activities with substantial effect on commerce
- intrastate
- economic
- rational belief
- substantial economic effect
- direct and substancial effect
- interstate
- Tax and Spending
- War
- Naturalization
- Necessary and propery - if rationally related
Federal Powers: Judiciary
- Cases under constitution
- Admiralty/ 2 states / citizens of different states
- not if independent and adequate state grounds
Federal Powers: Executive
- Carry out laws
- executive orders
- treaties
- appointments
- foreign affairs
- pardon federal offenses
- Veto bills - but no line items
- Executive privilege qualified: weigh government interest
Limitations on State Power: Supremacy/Preemption
Federal laws take priority and preempt over state laws that conflict
Limitations on State Power: Dormate Commerce Clause
The Domant Commerce Clause restricts the states ad local governments from regulating activity that affects interstate commerce if the reulation is discriminatory or unduly burdens commerce.
(per se violaion) A regulation that is facially discriminatory against out-of-towners will be permitted only if it is
- necessary to
- important noneconomic government interest
- with no reasonable alternatives
A regulation that unduly burdens interestate commerce will be permitted if it is
- rationally related to a
- legitimate government interest and the
- burden imposed on interestate commerce must be outweighed by the benefits to the state
EXCEPTIONS
- Market participant: when the state is not acting as a regulator, but rather owns or operates a business, it may favor local interest over nonlocal interest.
- Congressional consent to regulation
Limitations on State Power: Privileges and Immunities Clause
- State cannot discriminate against noncitizens
- Unless substanctially reated and less discriminatory alternatives
- rights fundamental to national unity
- corporations and aliens are not citizens
Limitations on State Power: Contracts Clause
The contracts clause prevents state governments from passing laws that retrocatively and substantially impair existing contracts
- if the state is substantially impairing private contracts, the law must be reasonable and appropriate to serve a significant and legitimate public purpose
- Similar to the test above but the court will interpret it more strictly, focusing on the law being necessary to serve an important public purpose
Limitations on Federal Power: 10th Amendment
The tenth amendment reserves all powers not delegated to the federal government to states