Con Law: 1st Amendment Flashcards
Establishment Clause:
prohibits gov from establishing a religion, preferring a particular religion, or preferring religion over non-religion.
A government action that has the effect of benefitting a religion is valid if (Lemon test) ∑:
(a) PURPOSE – it has a secular purpose,
(b) EFFECT – its primary effect neither advances nor inhibits religion;
(c) ENTANGLEMENT – it does not result in excessive government entanglement with religion
Financial aid to religious institutions is valid if
if the
(a) aid is used only for secular purposes,
(b) secular in nature, and is
(c) distributed according to religiously neutral criteria
Constitutionality of government holiday displays
permitted unless a reasonable observer would conclude that the display is a religious endorsement.
Standard for laws that intentionally target religious conduct
strict scrutiny
Standard for neutral regulation of conduct that impact religion:
rational basis
Ministers exception to freedom of religion
religious organization are free to select its ministers without governmental interference.
Test for regulation of expressive conduct ∑ 3
is valid if ∑ 3:
(a) INTEREST – it furthers an important interest;
(b) INTEREST – interest is unrelated to suppression of expression and
(c) BURDEN – burden on expression is no greater than necessary
Speech regulation is impermissibly overbroad if
if it regulates substantially more speech than necessary to protect a compelling interest
Speech regulation is void for vagueness if
if it fails to provide a person of ordinary intelligence with fair notice of what’s prohibited.
Prior restraints on speech:
- standard of review
- presumption
Subject to strict scrutiny
Presumption: presumed to be unconstitutional unless procedural safeguards are in place.
Prior restraints on speech–burden of proof
government bears the burden to prove that the material is not protected speech, even when national security is at issue.
Media’s right to publish
standard of review
prohibits gov from unduly restricting the right to publish (a) lawfully obtained and (b) truthful info about (c) matters of public significance
strict scrutiny for matters of public concern.
Media restrictions on media–Illegally obtained info
Media can publish if
(a) info was obtained by third party unknown to the media / media didn’t unlawfully obtain it; and
(b) the info involves matter of public concern.
Media restrictions on media–lawfully obtained private fact
Media can publish if the matter involves matter of public concern (e.g., the identity of a rape victim)
Standard for content-based regulation
Strict scrutiny.
5 Exceptions to content-based regulation:
Commercial speech, Obscenity/Child porn, incitement to violence, fighting words, defamation
Is commercial speech protected under 1st Amendment?
Commercial speech is protected unless false, misleading, or unlawful.