Con Law Flashcards
Elements of Standing
1 - injury in fact
2 - Causation
3 - Redressability
Eleventh Amendment limitations
Citizens of one state can’t sue another state. Citizens of own state can’t sue their own state
Exceptions
Consent
Injunctions against state official (not judges or clerks)
Personal suit against state officer, with damages paid by state officer
Congressional enforcement of civil war amendments
structural waivers in Const
Adequate and Independent State Grounds (AISG)
Prevents SCOTUS from hearing case if decided on
adequate - fully resolve matter
Independent - without reference to federal law
If unclear whether it was made without reference to federal law, SCOTUS can review to determine whether such grounds exist.
Standard for power to tax
rationally related to raising revenue
If direct - must be apportioned evenly among states
If indirect - must be uniform in every state
Taxpayer standing
(1) Litigate how much they owe on taxes
(2) challenge expenditures made by Congress’s power to tax and spend that violate Establishment Clause
Impeachment of President
(1) House of Reps votes by majority if “high crimes and misdemeanors”
(2) Senate convicts by super majority (2/3)
Ripeness vs Mootness
Ripe - fully developed, P suffers real injury
Moot - live controversy. Not moot if:
-capable of repetition yet evading review
-D voluntary ceases wrongful action (will only be voluntary if they could easily resume once case dismissed)
Requirements for a valid TPM restriction (public and designated public)
1 - content neutral
2 - narrowly tailored to serve significant state interest
3 - Leave alternate modes of communication open
Speech restrictions on non-public (or limited public) forums (e.g. military bases, prisons, public schools are limited public)
Must be (1) viewpoint neutral, and (2) reasonably related to legitimate government interest. Kind of like rational review
Commerce Clause can regulate which activities
(1) channels
(2) instrumentalities
(3) activities that have a substantial economic impact on interstate commerce (aggregate, presumed if economic in nature)
Cannot aggregate noneconomic things
Anti-Commandeering Doctrine
Federal congress cannot commandeer state legislatures by either forcing them to enact or enforce specific legislation, or prohibit them from enacting new laws.
BUT can use taxing and spending powers to incentivize state legislative action
Advisory Opinions
Court cannot review advisory opinions, must decide an actual case or controversy.
Asking for constitutionality or interpretation of law without an actual case not allowed.
SCOTUS original jurisdiction
(1) ambassadors
(2) public ministers and consuls
(3) case in which state is a party
CANNOT be modified by Congress
When can Congress regulate purely private conduct?
To eliminate badges and incidents of slavery (Thirteenth Amendment)
Expressive Conduct regulation requirements (think flag burning)
(1) - furthers important government interest
(2) - unrelated to suppression of ideas
(3) - burden on speech no greater than necessary
Prohibiting nudity is constitutional
Prohibiting flag burning is not
When can a state discriminate against out of state commerce?
(1) - Necessary to state interest and no other non-discriminatory alternative
(2) - State as Market Participant
(3) - Traditional government function exception (can favor state and local gov entities when performing a traditional gov function)
(4) - Subsidies
(5) - Federal/Congressional approval
Dormant Commerce Clause
Pre-req: Congress has not enacted legislation on particular area of interstate commerce.
THEN, states can regulate it as long as it does not:
1 - discriminate against out of state commerce (subject to strict scrutiny)
2 - facially non-discriminatory, but unduly burden interstate commerce (subject to clearly excessive review)
3 - purposely regulate wholly out of state activity
There are exceptions to discrimination against out of state commerce.
Presidential pardon power
only for federal offenses, not state
Fundamental rights for SDP
Right to travel (residency requirements for government benefits OK if reasonable, but not OK if they deny basic necessities)
Right to Vote
Right to privacy (family reside together, contraceptives, marriage, sexual relations, avoid disclosure of medical info, parental rights to control upbringing and education, obscene material, refuse medical treatment)
Federal Preemption
- Express
-Implied
——Conflict (indirect or direct)- impossible to comply with both state and federal
——-Field - rare, but if congress has occupied field so pervasively that state cannot regulate
State can pass MORE, but not LESS than federal
Pocket Veto
Congress adjourned within 10 day period following presentment. If President has not acted yet, then this is a pocket veto. Cannot be overridden
Are legislative vetos valid?
No, if the legislature reserves a right to disapprove of future execute actions, not allowed.
Suspect Classes for EQP
Race
Ethnicity
National origin
If state law, then Non-Citizens
Presidential immunity
Immune for civil liability for acts performed as part of official responsibilities.
NOT immune for acts committed before president or completely unrelated to carrying out the job
Intermediate Scrutiny - EQP
Gender - exceedingly persuasive justification. If separate facilities provided for men and women, then the facilities must be substantially equivalent.
Illegitimacy - almost always invalid though
Deprivation of Property as Job rules
If employee could only be fired for cause or terms of contract show they were entitled to more, then losing job can be a deprivation of property for PDP to kick in.
Even if at will, cannot be fired for unconstitutional reasons
When can Gov restrict speech on basis of content?
Obscenity
Incitement
Fighting words
Defamation
Commercial Speech