Con Law Flashcards
What are the 2 main exceptions to the DCC?
1) State is acting as a market participant (including state is choosing to subsidize its own citizens, including state is favoring state entities that perform a traditional government function)
2) Congress authorized the state regulation of commerce
A state that imposes a durational residency requirement for government benefits or voting - what test will this law be reviewed under?
Equal Protection Clause - Strict Scrutiny
A state that imposes a durational residency requirement for government benefits or voting will be valid under the EPC so long as?
The residency requirement is reasonable (30-60 days; not 1 year+)
State law concerning voter registration - What test must that fall under?
Rational basis
State law concerning poll tax - What test must that fall under?
Strict scrutiny
State law concerning disallowing third-party candidacies - What test must that fall under?
Strict scrutiny
State law concerning property ownership requirement for voting - What test must that fall under?
Strict scrutiny
State law concerning imposing blanket/closed primaries - What test must that fall under?
Rational Basis
State law concerning disallowing write-in voting - What test must that fall under?
Rational basis
State law concerning Photo ID for voting - What test must that fall under?
Rational Basis
What kind of immunity do state legislators enjoy?
Absolute immunity from state civil or criminal liability
Absolute immunity for federal civil liability
No immunity for federal criminal liability
What is the Article 4 Comity Clause?
States cannot discriminate against citizens (only individuals, not corporations) of other states, w/r/t civil liberties or commercial activities (employment, practice commercial trade, travel/reside in state)
States may do trivial discrimination for non-commercial, recreational activities like higher fees for state parks
What is the 14th Amendment Privileges and Immunities Clause?
States cannot interfere with their own citizens’ right to national citizenship, right to interstate travel, to assemble peacefully, to vote for national offices. Really only invoked w/r/t EPC and Due Process
What is an advisory opinion?
An opinion issued that does not have the effect of adjudicating a specific legal issue but merely advises on the constitutionality or interpretation of law
Are federal courts allowed to issue advisory opinions?
No because federal courts only render decisions when an actual case or controversy exists
What is a declaratory judgment?
A court order that explains the legal rights and duties of the parties to the suit and resolves legal uncertainty
Are federal courts allowed to issue declaratory judgments?
Yes because they provide legal certainty
When do taxpayers have standing in federal court?
When TP is raising an establishment of religion challenge to a SPECIFIC congressional appropriation of funds
When TP is litigating how much she owes on her tax bill
When do organizations have standing in federal court?
When org is suing on behalf of members and members have standing to sue individually, injury is related to org’s purpose, and the claim does not require participation of individual members
Is the Guaranty Clause (determining what is considered a Republican form of government) considered a non-justiciable PQ?
Yes
Are cases presenting issues related to foreign affairs or military decisions considered a non-justiciable PQ?
Often yes - think, determinations of when war begins/ends, challenges to President’s use of war powers
But it’s not a PQ if it has to do with the validity of a federal statute
Are cases regarding impeachment procedures considered a non-justiciable PQ?
Yes
Are cases involving political gerrymandering considered a non-justiciable PQ?
Yes
When MUST a federal court abstain from hearing a case when a declaratory or injunctive relief is sought?
When there is a pending state proceeding on any matter that involves an important state interest and provides an adequate opportunity to litigate the federal issues. Think - enforcement proceedings akin to a prosecution (termination of parental rights) and proceedings that further a state court’s ability to perform judicial functions (contempt)
Unless the challenged state law is patently unconstitutional
What is the 11th Amendment?
State sovereign immunity
What are Congress’ police power?
Military, Indian reservations, federal land, D.C.
Can Congress provide military trial of U.S. citizens?
No
Can Congress provide military trial of enemy civilians and enemy soldiers and US soldiers?
Yes