Competing models of depression Flashcards
Which psychological model of depression dominated in the later Middle Ages?
Scheme of temperaments
- phlegmatic
- > sluggishness and inactivity
- melancholic (i.e. black bile)
- > depressed, apprehensive, resentful, shy
What did Claudius Galen of Pergamon propose in his work “On the nature of man” (2nd century AD)?
4 humours contribute to the formation of character
- blood
- phlegm
- black bile
- yellow bile
What was the Hierarchy of Spirits (vapours) in Galen’s Physiological System (131-201 AD)?
- Animal spirits: Brain (soul)
- Vital spirits: Heart
- Natural spirits: Liver
What was the Hierarchy of Souls in Renaissance Philosophical Psychology (Reisch, 1517)?
“static hierarchy of notability”
- Intellective soul: Brain
- Sensitive soul: Heart
- Vegetative soul: Liver
What did the work of art Melencolia I of Albrecht Dūrer express (1500s)?
Melencolia (depression) = Positive character
- temperament style
- basis for intellectual/imaginative accomplishments
- popular view during
What was the popular view of depression (melancholia) during the Renaissance?
Melancholia = positive character
- something to strive for
What was the view of depression (melancholia) from the minority of artists during the Renaissance?
- Negative connotation
- Associated with impairment
=> debate on the value of melancholia
What was the Kraepilin’s account of depression (1900s)?
Part of manic-depressive illnesses
- occurring in spectrum of conditions (today’s bipolar disorder)
- 3 core symptoms of depression
- independent temporal dynamics of symptoms
=> co-existence of manic and depressive symptoms in mixed state
What were Kraepelin’s core symptoms of depression (1900s)?
- Thought disturbance (inhibition)
- Mood disturbance (empty)
- Will disturbance (inability to decide)
What was Kraepelin’s concept of independent temporal dynamics of the symptoms in depression?
Affective states continuum
- core symptoms vary independently
- different combinations of the symptoms at different time points
=> mixed states
- co-existence of manic and depressive symptoms
How did Sigmund Freud conceptualise depression (1917)?
“Mourning and Melancholia”
> Self-blame
-> depression or adaptive sadness
> Ambivalence in relations with deceased people
-> unconscious anger -> self-directed anger
What was John Bowlby’s model of depression, as presented in his work “The making and Breaking of Affectional Bonds” (1977)?
Depression in Attachment Theory:
- problem in detaching from people
- AND with processing loss
- > Making and breaking of affectional bonds
- > Understanding of depression
What does the revised Learned Helplessness model of depression (Abramson, Seligman, Teasdale, 1978) consist of?
> Attribution theories of motivation
- importance of perceived agency
- > modern cognitive theories
> Depression = negative attribution style
-> cycle of decreased self-worth and vulnerability to depression
What did the modern cognitive theories of motivation supersede?
They superseded the simplistic motivation theories
- Freud: one drive (libido) leads all human striving
What was the limit of the revised learned helplessness model (Abramson, Selgiman, Teasdale, 1978)?
Studies using attributional style questionnaire
- normal scores in remitted depression
- yet, the model suggests person’s attributional style should persist even when depression symptoms have subsided (vulnerability factor outside of depression)
What did Aaron Beck propose as a theory of depression, in “Thinking and Depression” (1963)?
> Idiosyncratic content and Cognitive distorsions
- dominating schemas
> Depression as affective disorder
-> impairment of thought processes (failure to demonstrate evidence)
> Abnormalities in the responses to standard battery of psychological tests
- arbitrary inference
- selective attention
- over-generalisation
- magnification and minimization
> Reciprocal interaction between cognition and affect
What is Beck’s Cognitive Triad (1976)?
Self-critical interpretations
- Negative view of self
- Negative interpretations of current experiences
- Negative view of own future