Competing Claims Flashcards
When two property claims compete, lawyers win! Learn the priority of property claims and the procedures needed to safeguard a claim.
Define
adverse possession
Method of acquiring title to another’s land by hostile continuous possession for a period of time.
Elements of adverse possession
Trespasser’s possession must be:
- Continuous for duration of statutory period (depends on jurisdiction);
- Hostile;
- Actual,
- Open & notorious;
- Exclusive
What is the default statutory period for adverse possession?
20 years
What is “continuous” possession?
Uninterrupted use of the property throughout the statutory period.
Does seasonal or infrequent use count as continuous possession?
Yes as long as it is consistent with the ordinary use of the property (ex. if property is a ski cabin or summer beach house).
Define
tacking
When a trespasser “tacks on” (adds on) a prior adverse possession period to meet the statutory requirement.
⚠️ Note: Privity between trespassers is required. The new trespasser must take by non-hostile means without gaps in possession.
When is tacking not allowed?
If the new trespasser has taken control of the property through hostile means (called “ouster”).
Does the SOL run if the rightful owner was disabled when the adverse possession started?
No, SOL will toll (pause) if rightful owner was disabled (minor, incarcerated, mentally incompetent, etc) when the adverse possession started.
What is “actual” possession?
Actual, physical possession of the property.
What is “open and notorious” possession?
Obvious and not hidden; the owner would know of it with reasonable inspection.
What does it mean for possession to be hostile?
Without the owner’s permission. Trespasser does not need to intend to adversely possess the property.
Can a trespasser adversely possess the land with the owner’s permission?
No, defeats hostility requirement
If a renter overstays their lease, is this considered “hostile” possession?
No, tenancy at sufferance exists, not adverse possession
Will a mistaken encroachment satisfy the intent needed for adverse possession?
Majority: Yes, mistake is sufficient
Minority: No, possessor must show they would have intentionally encroached even if they had known of their hostile use
Define
color of title
Title that appears valid, but actually isn’t because of some flaw in the deed (i.e. deed doesn’t contain all required elements)
What is the effect of adversely possessing the property under color of title?
If adverse possessor occupies a significant portion of the land in the deed, the possessor is entitled to the entire property
Can you adversely possess government land?
No
Can a co-tenant acquire title to the whole property through adverse possession?
Yes, but only if the co-tenant clearly and unequivocably ousts the others from the land for the statutory period
When will a restrictive covenant run with land acquired by adverse possession?
Only if adverse possessor’s use was consistent with the covenant
What are the 3 steps in a land transaction?
- Land contract;
- Closing;
- Deed transfer
Requirements for a land sale contract to satisfy the SOF
- In writing;
- Signed by the parties to be bound;
- Contain essential terms of the deal (description of the land, consideration to be paid, etc)
When does a land sale contract not need to satisfy the SOF?
If buyer does 2 of the following:
- Takes possession of the land;
- Makes physical improvements; and/or
- Pays significant part of the purchase price
Define
implied covenant of marketable title
title is free from defects and unreasonable risk of litigation
What defects render a title unmarketable?
-
Encumberances;
- Covenants
- Easements
- Mortgages
- Liens
- Title acquired by adverse possession;
- Zoning violations;
- Incurable physical defects; and
- Future interests that have not consented to transfer
Can the buyer waive defects that render a title unmarketable?
Yes
Define
duty to disclose
- Seller has duty to disclose all material latent defects; and
- Seller cannot misrepresent or fraudulently conceal
Do disclaimers limit the seller’s liability for misrepresentation or fraudulent concealment? (e.g. “property sold as is”)
No, disclaimers do not limit liability for misrepresentation or fraud
Deadline for seller to deliver marketable title
By the date of closing
What happens if the title is unmarketable at the time of closing?
Can make arrangements on the date of closing to earmark part of the purchase price to remedy the defect and make the title marketable
What can the buyer do if they discover the title is unmarketable?
Notify the seller before the closing date and give them a reasonable time to cure defects
If seller doesn’t cure, buyer can seek specific performance, damages, and an action to quiet title
⚠️ If buyer doesn’t notify seller beforehand, deed controls b/c of the merger doctrine and seller is not liable
What is the implied warranty of quality in construction/good workmanship?
For new property, implied promise that structures will be constructed in a “good and workmanlike” mannner
What’s the doctrine of merger and its effect?
Once the deed is transferred/conveyed to the buyer, the contract merges with the deed and the deed controls, not the contract.
⭐️ This means that whatever obligations the seller had under the contract are not enforceable unless they are also contained in the deed.
What is the doctrine of equitable conversion?
Doctrine that helps determine who bears the risk of loss. Once the buyer signs K to purchase land at a later date, but before closing:
- Buyer has equitable title; and
- Seller has legal title