Competence and consent in a minor Flashcards
Define: Consent
(code of practice definition)
Voluntary and continuing permission of a patient to receive a particular treatment based of adequate knowledge of the purpose, nature, likely effects and risks of that treatment, including likelihood of success and any alternatives.
What criteria needs to be met for informed consent?
- competence to understand and to decide
- voluntary decision making
- disclosure of material information
- recommendation of a plan
- comprehension of 3 and 4
- decision in favour of plan
- authorisation of plan
in summary - competence to understand, have the ability to decide, agree and go through with a recommended plan
What is informed refusal?
Person reject plan whilst meeting all other aspects of informed consent
Capacity vs Consent?
Capacity is the ability and comes in degrees
Competence is a personal possession and is allow nothing - a legal term
Definitions
Capacity vs Consent?
capacity - the degree one is able to understand…
consent - being able to understand…
…information relevant to treatment decision and to appreciate the reasonably foreseeable consequences of a decision or lack of a decision
When can competence be presumed?
When over 16
can be presumed in law to be competent to give consent for medical treatment and to release information in England, Scotland and Wales.
Can someone under 16 be competent?
yes, should be assessed case-by-case
What year did Mrs Gillick go to court?
and why?
1982
stop doctors contraceptive advice or treatment to under 16 year olds without parental consent
What year did the courts dismiss Mrs Gillick’s claim?
And what did the house of lords rule?
1985
upheld that doctors could give contraceptive advice and treatment to a young person under 16 based of Fraser Guidelines
What are Gillick competency and Fraser guidelines?
A child giving consent depends on:
- maturity
- understanding
- nature of consent
a child must be capable of making a reasonable assessment of the advantages and disadvantages of the treatment proposed
Difference between Gillick competence and Fraser guidelines?
GC = determining a childs capacity to consent FG = decide if a child can consent to contraceptive or sexual health advice and treatment
How are Fraser Guidelines applied?
A doctor can give advice and treatment if he is satisfied with the following criteria:
- girl will understand advice
- can’t persuade her to tell parents or allow him to tell parents she is seeking contraceptive advice
- very likely to continue having sex with or without contraception
- without contraceptive advice her mental and physical health will suffer
- her best interest requires she is given contraceptive advice, treatment both with or without parental consent
When did Fraser Guidelines coverage change and what does it now apply to?
Originally related to contraceptive advice and treatment
in 2006 it changed and now applies to decisions about treatment for STI’s and terminations of pregnancy
When are there grounds to break confidentiality?
if the conditions aren’t all met
reason to believe the child is under pressure to give consent or is being exploited
How to assess competence?
- understand there are choices and choices have consequences
- can weigh information and arrive at decision
- willingness to make choice
- understand nature and purpose of intervention
- understand proposed risks and side effects of intervention
- understand alternative interventions and risks
- freedom of undue pressure