Comparative Health Systems Study Guide Flashcards
Health System
all activities whose primary purpose is to promote, restore, or maintain health and disease prevention, enviornmental safety.
What does a health system include?
health services, traditional healers, home care, all use of medication, health promotion and disease prevention, environmental safety.
Is education part of the health system?
No! It supports its purpose, but is not part of it
Americans consider the health system as
hospitals and clinics
What do other countries consider the health system as?
Health process in the entire country.
Health CARE system
The provision of and investment in health services.
Can be preventive, curative, or palliative
Proximate health factors
health system, healht behavior, psycosocial factors
Intermediate health factors
educaiton, occupation, income, ethnicity, environment, food, working conditions
Structural health factors
socioeconomic and political context
What is the #1 thing you can do to improve maternal and child health?
focus on female education… 50% of decline in U5MR is due to female education
Wealth and its connection to health
wealthier countries on average have individuals with longer life expectancy
income and survival are strongly correlated
It helps to a certain point w/ regards to increased life expectancy, but isnt everything
What is NOT captured in life expectancy numbers?
Quality of Life
What led to an improvement in health before modern medicine, and to what degree?
sanitation, germ theory, handwashing, birth spacing, housing improvements
IMR dropped from high 190s/1000 live births in 1900 to 30s/1000 prior to penecillian, all without drugs
What are the 3 goals of any health system?
1) Improve the health of the population and its distribution
2) Respond to people’s non-health expectations (customer service)
3) provide financial protection against the costs of ill health
What other goals should a health system encompass?
- Equitable provision of services
- Efficient provision of services
- should function as social institutions that communicate government’s committments to their citizens.
Why does health care need government intervention
Capital markets need perfect competition and information to function freely - health care has market failures that prevent optimal function without oversight
What are the marekt failures of health systems that create imperfect competition?
- Externalities
- Adverse Selection
- Moral Hazard
- Agency/Information Assymertry
- Monopolies
What is the government’s role in healthcare ?
AS health is a basic right of most countries’ citizenship, governments must ensure access to essential health care and quality of care, given that the market ISNT perfect
Government’s roles range by region and level of income
What is the role of government in the health system in SSA?
the government is often the payor and provider of health care… there isnt health insurance.
What % of all health spending runs through the government in the US?
45%
What is the role of the government in Canada, the UK, and France?
they are the main payor of health care and are sometimes the employer of physicians
What are the WHO building blocks of health?
She Helps Inmate Manage Fine Lines
Service Delivery Health workforce Information Medical products, vaccines, technologies Financing Leadership/Governmance
What are the goals relative to the WHO building blocks?
and IRIS
Improved Health (level and equity)
Responsiveness
Social and Financial Risk Protection
Improved Efficiency
Service Delivery
Offer safe, effective, quality personal and non-personal health interventions to those who need them, who and where needed, with a minimum waste of resources
Health Workforsce
works in ways that are responsive, fair, and efficient to achieve the best health outcomes possible, given available resources and circumstances.
Must be sufficient in numbers and mix of staff, and be fairly distributed; should be competent, responsive and productive.
Information
HIS must ensure the production, analysis, dissemination, and use of reliable and timely info on health determinants, health systems performance, and health status.
Medical Products, Vaccines, and Techonoliges
Must have equitable access to these. Must be of assured quality, safety, efficacy, and cost effectiveness, and should be scientifically sound and cost-effective in use.
Financing
system must raise adequate funds for health, in ways that ensure people can use needed services, and are protectd from financial catastrophe or impoverishment assoiciated with having to pay for them
Leadership/Governance
must ensure strategic policy frameworks exist and are combined with effective oversight, coalition building, the provision of appropriate regulation and incentives, have attention to system design, and have accountability.
How much we spend and how we spend it determines…
improved health
social and financial risk protection
improved efficiency
Total Expenditures on Health
all the $ spent in a country in 1 yr
Total expenditures as a % of GDP
how big a piece of the economic pie is healthcare?
Government expenditures on health as a % of total government expenditures
what % does the government spend on health as a % of all its spending
Per capita expenditure on health
total health expenditures divided by the population
What is the us spend per capita on health per year?
8,000
Where do global preventable deaths take place?
in the places with the lowest per capita spending
What are the sources of US spending on health?
Social health insurance (payroll taxes and private health insurance)
Direct expenditures (VA system)
Taxes
how are OOPP good?
discourages overuse of services
how are OOPP bad?
prevents the poor from getting essential care
Where are OOPP lowest?
IN high income countries…. ironically oopp drop as countries get wealthier, but the poor are the ones who need more help.
What is the range of OOPP as a % of total health spending?
70% down to 15%
What is the goal for OOPP?
to limit financial hardship, should be <20% of total health expenditures
what is NOT included in OOPP?
health insurance premiums.
What is the r^2 of weath and per capita expenditures?
95% - very highly correlated.
When did health services begin to be organized?
19th century
What were hospitals like in the 19th century?
they were places of last resort, where people went to die, or were refuges for the crippled/insane.
see same thing in africa today….go to the hospital, get Ebola.
Health care spending per capita for low-income countries
$24
Health care spending per capita for lower-middle income countries
$91
health care spending per capita for upper-middle income countries
$342
Health care spending per capita for high income countries
$3810
What did Germany do to start their HS?
in 1883, enacted a law requiring worker premium contributions to ensure health coverage (pool $ and provide HC in a systematic way)
What were the next 3 countries post Germany to work on creating a health care system?
Belgium, Norway, Britain
What was Russia’s basic health care system?
They created a tax-funded network of clinics and hospitals where treatment was free in the late 1800s.
By 1911, free crae was mandatory (were looking to improve the health of the farmers)
Bismark System
Social security system where employers and workers contriubte to health funds; generally progressive (although can me mildly regressive if there are ceilings on income contributions).
More you make the more you give.
Large pool of money from many workers.
Government kicks in money for unemployed
Nations that follow the bismark system:
Japan, Germany, US for employer sponsored HC
Participation in bismark system
mandatory, but wealthy can have option to opt out at times (Germany, Netherlands)
Who are the payers in the Bismark System?
The social insurance funds (multi-payer).
can be geographic, political, or religiously based
are not-for profit
are regulated by the state and require same comprehensive benefits for all members
can negotiate directly with providers and pharma
What is the choice option in Bismark systems?
have choice of providers and sometimes of sickness funds
Beveridge Model
Tax based insurance (income, sales, etc.)
Is progressive as long as the taxes are progressive
is portable since not tied to a job
directly pays the providers
Who participates in beveridge model
everyone, is mandatory
risk and contribution are spread over a large base
Promotes equity (as contributions are not based on health need) and solidarity
Payers in beveridge
single payer model
country examples of beveridge
canada, UK, US for veterans
What is the impact of the beveridge model on costs?
tends to have low cost per capita due to purchasing power and economies of scale
Semashko
tax funded, centralized planning, with universal coverage, free service, salaried workers, little or no private sector participation
What countries use semashko?
cuba, formerly eastern europe
Mixed model
USA
majority of health systems belong in this category
combination of tax based, social insurance and out of pocket funding for health care
Risk Rated premiums
Little risk transfer/pooling
Community Rated premiums
risk transfer between sick and healthy