Common Law and UCC Art. 2 Flashcards
Common law
General case law, everything except sale of goods
Personal service, employment, real estate
UCC
Sale of goods, anything movable
Watch, widget, laptop, car
Mutual Assent
Both parties, usually through an offer and acceptance, communicate a present commitment.
Lucy v. Zehmer
Claimed it was a joke, the court viewed it objectively from what a reasonable person would think that an offer/acceptance/contract was formed. Court held that it didn’t matter if it was a joke a reasonable person would see it as an offer.
Offer
Q: quantity T: time for performance P: parties of the contract P: price P: place for performance S: subject matter
Special Offer Rules
Advertisements are not legally binding
- unless clear, definite, explicit, and leaves no room for negotiation
- unless it’s a reward directed with specific language of commitment or some invitation to take action
- letter of intent is not a contract
- general contractors request for bids is an invitation for offer, subcontractors’ bids are considered offers
Termination of Offer
- Death
- Lapse of time
- specified time, reasonable time
- Revocation
- offeror changes mind, indirect from a reliable third-party (see Dickinson v. Dodds)
- Rejection
- saying no, counter-offer, conditional acceptance (I accept but), additional terms
Acceptance
Offeree’s manifestation of agreement in the manner invited and in the time required
Are advertisements binding
No
Is a letter of intent a contract
No
Are subcontractors bids considered offers
Yes
Mirror image rule
Acceptance must mirror the terms of the offer exactly
Unilateral
Promise for performance
Offeror is making promise
Offeree must perform
Bilateral
Promise for promise
Option contract
Option to hold so the buyer has more time to decide
Is an option contract irrevocable
Yes
Under the UCC, If when the first reply is not an acceptance, the offeror turns away in silence, is the offer still open for acceptance
No
Is Lapse of time a termination of offer
If specified or a reasonable amount of time has passed
Is a counter-offer acceptance or rejection?
Rejection of the original offer
Mailbox Rule
The moment of acceptance is upon sent not when received
If a buyer sends both rejection and acceptance in the mail, and the rejection arrives first, is there a contract
No
If a buyer sends both rejection and acceptance in the mail, and the acceptance arrives first, is there a contract
Yes
Does the mailbox rule apply to any options contract?
No, it must actually be received
If you specify you want it sent by FedEx but it is sent by UPS, does the mailbox rule apply?
No, only accepted upon receipt