Code III Flashcards
Chapter 9 of Title 10, Louisiana Revised Statutes, deals with relationships between which of the following groups:
A. Between debtors and creditors
B. Between creditors and creditors.
C. Between debtors and debtors.
D. Both A and B.
D
Is the same version of UCC Article 9 found in every state?
A. No, because some states have not yet enacted the Revised Article 9.
B. No, because state legislatures have made changes to the uniform version when they enacted the statute. (But ALL have adopted it)
C. Yes, because as federal law, it is uniform throughout the states.
D. Yes, because each state has enacted the uniform version
B
Which of the following choice is an accurate statement about Article 9?
A. Every transaction within Article 9 involves at least one creditor, a debtor, and collateral.
B. Under Article 9, in order to perfect a security interest, you must have a valid security interest.
C. Article 9 priority rules determine which creditor of the debtor gets paid first.
D. All of the above
D
Which of the following choice is NOT an accurate statement about a lien?
A. A lien is an interest in debtor’s property created by law to protect a creditor’s interest.
B. A lien can be created by statute.
C. A lien can attach only to the debtor’s personal property.
D. A lien can be created by contract.
C
CarMax sells a car to Bob for $25,000. Bob puts down $5,000 as a down payment. Bob agrees to pay the rest in installments of $1,000 by signing a promissory note (a formal promise to pay). Bob defaults in payments. On these facts, what can CarMax choose to do?
• A. CarMax can repossess the car because Bob promised to pay.
• B. CarMax can sue Bob for damages for breach of contract and get a judgment
against Bob.
• C. CarMax can repossess the car because CarMax has a security interest in the car.
• D. Both A and C
B
Article 9 applies to all transactions, regardless of their form, that create a security interest in personal property or fixtures by contract.
- A. True
- B. False
A
Security interest” means an interest in all property or fixtures which secures payment or performance of an obligation.
- A. True
- B. False
B (PERSONAL property – lien is on real property)
UCC Article 9 applies to all consignments of personal property.
- A. True
- B. False
B– excludes some consignments!
Chapter 9 applies to all consignments of movable property.
A. True
B. False
B
Chapter 9 of Title 10, Louisiana Revised Statutes, covers the following topic:
A. A consensual lien in immovable property.
B. Certain consensual liens in movable property.
C. All consensual liens in movable property.
D. All involuntary liens in movable property.
B
Which one of the following statements is a correct statement regarding the scope of UCC Article 9?
A. UCC Article 9 covers all liens on personal property.
B. UCC Article 9 covers all consensual liens on personal property.
C. UCC Article 9 covers all (some?) consensual liens on personal property and fixtures.*
D. UCC Article 9 covers all liens on personal property, judicial liens and statutory liens such as mechanics liens.
C
Pursuant to a state statute permitting it to do so, an auto repair shop retains possession of David’s car when David fails to pay for the repairs. This is not an Article 9 secured transaction because:
A. The repair shop is not extending credit.
B. The credit is not secured.
C. The transaction does not involve personal property
D. The right to retain the car by the auto repair shop is not given consensually.
D
Mary collects antiques and sends them to Antique Mall, well known in the area for selling antiques on consignment. Mary delivered $3,000 worth of antiques to Antique Mall a few months ago. Mary did not comply with any Article 9 filing requirements. Antique Mall is now in financial trouble. One of its secured creditors has seized Mary’s antiques. Can Mary get her antiques back?
• A. Yes, because Mary delivered the antiques to Antique Mall for sale but did not sell
them to Antique Mall.
• B. Yes, because Mary’s consignment is not included within Article 9.
• C. No, because Mary failed to comply with Article 9’s requirements.
• D. No, because Antique Mall’s creditors may not know that it is generally engaged in
selling the goods of others.
B
David signed an agreement titled “automobile lease” with CarMax whereby David was obligated to make payments of $300 per month for three years and had an option to buy the car at the end of the three year period for $10. This transaction could be included within Article 9.
- A. True
- B. False
A
Federal statutes may affect security interests in ships, aircrafts, railroad equipment, and some interstate commercial vehicles.
- A. True
- B. False
A
UCC Article 9 includes all sales of accounts, chattel paper, promisory notes and payment intangibles.
- A. True
- B. False
B
How does a court determine whether a transaction is a lease or a secured transaction within Article 9?
A. A court will examine factors such as the length of the lease and the rights under the agreement. (Don’t look at intent → this isn’t contract law!)
B. A court will try to determine the parties’ intent.
C. A court will pay attention to how the parties themselves have treated the transaction.
D. Both A and B.
A
Bob wants to buy a new dishwasher from Sears. The dishwasher costs $300 but Bob only has $100 available. Sears agrees to sell the dishwasher to Bob. Bob signs an agreement in which Bob agrees that, if he defaults, Sears has the right to take possession of the dishwasher. In the transaction between Bob and Sears, what is the security interest?
A. Sears’ right with respect to the dishwasher.
B. Buyer’s ownership of the dishwasher.
C. The contract between Bob and Sears.
D. Buyer’s debt to Sears.
A
Penda Machinery, Inc. leased a $2 million manufacturing equipment to Electronics Manufacturing, Inc. (EMI) for 20 years, a period equal to the useful life of the goods. EMI has the right to terminate the lease at any time. EMI also has the option to buy the goods at the end of the lease period for their appraised fair market value. Which of the following additional facts is most likely to turn the lease into an Chapter 9 transaction?
A. EMI must insure the goods and keep them in good repair.
B. The goods were manufactured specially for EMI and not readily suitable for sale to anyone else.
C. The goods have to be integrated into EMI’s manufacturing line and the cost of removing them would exceed the total amount remaining due under the lease.
D. EMI paid $400,000 upon entering into the lease and is obligated to pay $12,000 per month for the 20 year term of the lease (an amount totaling $2,880,000).
C
Muses Gallery is in the business of buying and selling expensive paintings and art pieces. Those art works typically take a long time to sell because of the price tag. Recently, Muses Gallery decided to experiment with a new business model to reduce its inventory cost and to increase foot traffic. It agreed to allow some local artists to exhibit their own art for sale in Muses Gallery. Under the terms of each arrangement, the owner sets the price and Muses Gallery keeps 20 percent of the sale proceeds after a sale. Which of the owners, if any, must comply with Chapter 9?
A. Mary who delivered a recently inherited oil painting to Muses Gallery to be sold for $15,000.
B. John who sells his painting for income delivered a recently completed water color to Muses Gallery for sale for $5,000.
C. Carol who makes pottery pieces and sells them for income delivered three newly completed pottery pieces to be sold for $250 each.
D. David who specializes in special artistic glass vases delivered two pieces of glass vases to be sold for $400 each.
B
Carla took her broken television to Honest John’s Repair Shop to be repaired. Honest John quoted a repair price of $100. They did not sign any written contract and there was no verbal agreement that the television could be retained to secure payment of the repair bill. When the television was repaired, Carla refused to pay. Which of the following statements is most accurate?
A. Honest John has a right under Chapter 9 to retain the television pending payment.
B. Any right that Honest John has to retain the television arises outside of Chapter 9.
C. Honest John does not have any right to retain the television because there is no written agreement.
D. A lien granted by any state statute to Honest John falls within the definition of an Chapter 9 security interest.
B
Home Depot sells electronic appliances to contractors on credit under a standard agreement calling for the contractors to pay within 60 days of receipt for any goods delivered. Once a shipment is sent out, Home Depot records the amount due as an account receivable. Home Depot then sells all of its accounts receivable outright to Financing Unlimited to obtain financing to pay for ongoing business expenses. Which of the following statements is accurate?
A. In both transactions, Home Depot is a secured creditor. The contractors and Financing Unlimited are debtors.
B. Home Depot is a secured creditor in the first transaction, but a debtor in the second transaction.
C. Home Depot is a creditor in the first transaction, but a debtor in the second transaction.
D. Home Depot is a creditor in the first transaction and Financing Unlimited is a debtor in the second transaction.
C
David buys a new leather sofa from Thomas Walker Furniture for $5000, paying $100 down and signing a promissory note for the remaining amount. Thomas Walker Furniture sells the promissory note to Argo Financing as part of its usual business practice. Which one of the following statement is true?
A. Neither transaction is included within the scope of Chapter 9.
B. The first transaction is within Chapter 9.
C. The second transaction is within Chapter 9.
D. Both transactions are within Chapter 9.
C
David’s Machine Shop (“DMS”) has applied for a loan from your client, Octopus National Bank (“ONB”). DMS has signed an agreement and granted ONB a security interest in its intellectual property rights. The intellectual property rights include DMS’ copyright, patents and trademarks. ONB’s in house counsel has asked you what ONB should do to protect its security interest.
A. No need to do anything, because DMS has signed an agreement and granted ONB security interests in some valuable collateral. B. ONB can best protect its interests by filing in the appropriate office under the state’s UCC Article 9. C. ONB can best protect its security interest by filing in the relevant federal offices. D. Both B and C.
D
Acme Corp. manufactures various household appliances. It sells its products to major retailers under a standard agreement calling for the buyer to pay within 60 days of receipt for any goods delivered. Once a shipment is sent out, Acme records the amount due as an account receivable. Acme needs some money to buy raw materials for the appliances. Acme sold its accounts receivable outright to a firm called Financing Unlimited. Which of the following statement is a correct description of the transaction?
A. This transaction involves an outright sale of accounts receivable and is therefore outside the scope
of Article 9.
B. This transaction involves a sale of accounts receivable for purpose of commercial financing
and is therefore within the scope of Article 9. (But all account receivables are not included!)
C. This transaction involves accounts receivable and is therefore included within the scope of Article
9.
D. This transaction involves a sale of accounts receivable in the ordinary course of business and is
therefore excluded from the scope of Article 9.
B
Which of the following statement is not true with regard to the classification of collateral under Chapter 9?
A. Classification of the collateral is to be determined based on the intended use of the collateral as of the time of the creation of the security interest.
B. Courts examine the principal use of the property in the debtor’s hands in order to ascertain whether goods are inventory, equipment, or consumer goods.
C. Courts will look at the use of the collateral by all of the parties involved in order to determine its classification.
D. Classification of collateral under Chapter 9 allows a creditor to reasonably identify the property subject to the security interest.
C
Classification of the collateral is critical under Article 9 because many provisions of Article 9 make legal distinctions based on the type of collateral.
- A. True
- B. False
A
According to Article 9-109, Article 9 applies to “a transaction, regardless of its form, that creates a security interest in personal property or fixtures by contract.” Which of the following transactions does Article 9 NOT apply to?
- A. Real estate mortgages.
- B. A consignment.
- C. Sale of accounts, chattel paper, payment intangibles, and promissory notes.
- D. Agricultural liens.
A
David signed an agreement titled “automobile lease” with CarMax. Under the lease agreement, David was obligated to make payments of $300 per month for three years and had an option to buy the car at the end of the three year period for $1. The agreement also provided that, on default, CarMax had the right to terminate the lease and take back the car. CarMax did not comply with Article 9 filing requirements. David defaulted on his payments. Which advice would you give CarMax?
A. The car belongs to CarMax, so it can take back the car because David breached the lease.
B. The car belongs to David, but CarMax can repossess the car because it has a security
interest.
C. The car belongs to CarMax, but it must sue for a money judgment.
D. The car belongs to David, but CarMax cannot repossess the car because CarMax did not comply with Article 9 filing requirements.
B
Remedy for the creditor for a disguised lease is to take back the car or repossess whatever is at issue
o filing requirements only have to do with perfection – only when you are dealing with creditor and creditor. When debtor and creditor, creditor can use remedy provided for in the agreement →so here the filing requirements are irrelevant
o if it had been a true lease, CarMax would not have given up the title.
“Collateral” under UCC Article 9 means the property subject to a security interest or agricultural lien.
A. True
B. False
A
“Collateral” under UCC Article 9 is divided into many different categories. They are generally organized in three broad groups: Goods, quasi-tangible property and intangible property.
- A. True
- B. False
A
Sears sells household appliances. The Club House buys some household appliances from Sears to furnish its club house for use by its members. Many customers of Sears however buy the appliances for their own houses. National Bank intends to make a loan to The Club House and wants to take a security interest in the appliances that The Club House buys from Sears. How should the security agreement describe the appliances using the code classification?
A. Inventory.
B. Equipment.
C. Inventory and equipment.
D. Inventory, equipment and consumer goods.
B
4) Farmer McDonalds stored 50,000 bushels of wheat in the Farmer’s Co-Op grain elevator and received a receipt for the wheat. National Bank then loaned McDonalds $10,000 and took a security interest in the receipt. How would you describe the collateral?
A. Goods.
B. Documents.
C. Farm products.
D. General intangible.
B
(creditor is bank, debtor is farmer, what is collateral? It’s the property given –
here it is the receipt)
Autos Express sells automobiles. National Bank intends to make a loan to Autos Express and wants to take a security interest in the automobiles. What is the collateral for the loan?
A. Consumer goods.
B. Equipment.
C. Inventory.
D. Goods
C
Classification of collateral is to be determined based on the intended use of the collateral as of the time of the creation of the security interest.
A. True
B. False
A
Courts examine the principal use of the property in order to ascertain whether goods are inventory or equipment.
- A. True
- B. False
A
David bought a new computer on credit from Best Buy. Best Buy asked him to sign a “Conditional Sales Contract” by which David agreed that title to the computer would remain with the store until he had fully paid for his computer. David signed the contract. The contract described the computer in detail by its serial number. Which of the following statement is correct under Chapter 9?
A. The transaction is a secured transaction within Chapter 9.
B. Best Buy is not a secured creditor because David only promised to pay for the computer and did not grant a security interest to Best Buy.
C. Best Buy is not a secured creditor because David failed to authenticate any security agreement.
D. Best Buy does not need any security interest because it successfully reserved title to the computer.
A
9) Sears sells electronic appliances. Its customers include both companies that will buy the appliances for business purpose and individuals who will buy the appliances for their personal use. National Bank intends to make a loan to Sears and wants to take a security interest in the electronic appliances. How should you describe the electronic appliances using Article 9 classification?
A. Inventory and consumer goods.
B. Inventory and equipment.
C. Inventory.
D. Inventory, equipment and consumer goods.
C
Collateral = electronic appliances. Look at what the debtor is using the collateral for! Here, they are holding it for sale, so its inventory
Auto Zone is a car dealer. It buys a van from Ford on credit and grants Ford a security interest in the van. Auto Zone plans to use the van as a “courtesy car” to shuttle customers from their homes or offices to the dealer repair shop while their cars are being serviced. What Article 9 classification best describes the collateral?
A. Inventory.
B. Equipment.
C. Consumer Goods.
D. Courtesy car.
B
Under Article 9, a professional pianist’s piano, chickens from a chicken farmer’s farm, the tractor that the chicken farmer uses to transport the chickens, and ink used by a newspaper to print newspapers are respectively classified as the following when used as collateral (in the order mentioned):
A. Instrument, farm products, equipment, and inventory. • B. Equipment, consumer goods, tractor, and inventory. • C. Equipment, farm products, equipment, and inventory. • D. Consumer goods, farm products, equipment and instrument.
C
Which of the following statement is not true regarding the creation of a valid security interest?
- A. The creditor must have given value to the debtor.
- B. The debtor must have rights in the collateral.
- C. There has to be a written security agreement.
- D. A financing statement does not have to be filed
C
need valid secured interest for creation of SI but don’t need financing statement – only for perfected SI
Bob bought a flat screen television for $600 on credit from Best Buy. Bob signed a contract that describes the television and states that Best Buy will keep the title to the television until Bob pays all amounts due. Best Buy did not file any financing statement related to the transaction under UCC Article 9. If Bob fails to pay under the contract, can Best Buy repossess the television?
A. Yes, because Best Buy has a valid security interest in the television. OR
B. Yes, because contract law allows a seller the remedy of possession when a buyer does not
pay.
C. No, because Bob did not grant Best Buy a security interest in the television.
D. No, because Best Buy may not take a security interest in household goods.
A. Yes, because the retention of title by a seller creates a security interest.
Creditor must have given value (Best buy sold goods on credit), debtor must have rights in collateral (Bob has rights because he bought it); and 1 of the 3 requirements (Bob signed a contract – authentication)
David and Sally were having lunch and discussing the sale of Sally’s car, a 1963 MGB, to David. Sally wanted $10,000 for the car, but David did not have that much money. Sally said: “I’ll let you pay $1,000.00 each month. If you miss any payment, I can take the car back.” David agreed. Sally wrote these notes on a napkin: 1963 MGB, $10,000 total, $1,000 per month, take back if no pay. David initialed the napkin and they shook hands on the deal. David has missed a monthly payment. Can Sally take the car back?
A. Yes, because the oral agreement is enforceable.
B. Yes, because Sally has a security interest in the car.
C. No, because Sally did not actually sign any agreement.
D. It depends on whether parol evidence of the security agreement is admissible to supplement the writing.
B Agreement doesn’t have to be signed – sally wrote on napkin and David initialed – this is authentication – doesn’t have to be a full signature – can be any symbol that person consented
Only the debtor has to authenticate agreement – doesn’t matter whether creditor signs or not
Joe desperately needed some cash. He asked Mary if he could borrow $5,000.00 from her. He promised to repay the amount with interest within a year and offered a valuable diamond ring that he owned as collateral. Mary agreed. She wrote him a check for $5,000. 00 and in exchange, Joe handed over the diamond ring to Mary. Mary and Joe did not sign any agreement. Which choice below correctly describes the transaction?
A. This transaction did not create a security interest because Mary and Joe did not sign any security agreement.
B. This transaction created a security interest because Mary lent Joe $5,000.
C. This transaction did not create any security interest because Mary did not authenticate a security agreement.
D. This transaction created a security interest in Mary’s favor because Mary had the collateral in her possession pursuant to their oral agreement.
D. Need value and rights, the other are collaterals – authenticate, possession or control
here we have value and rights, and creditor has possession of collateral, so its a valid security interest
Which of the following statement is NOT true regarding a financing statement?
• A. A financing statement is commonly used to perfect a creditor’s security interest in the
collateral.
• B. A financing statement needs to be signed by a creditor.
• C. A financing statement is generally filed by a creditor.
• D. To be effective, a financing statement needs to identify the parties and indicate what collateral is covered.
B
Financing statement does not need to be signed by anyone. The other one needs to be signed by the debtor, but this doesn’t need to be signed by anyone
Al Bundy owns and operates a women’s shoe store. In addition to shoes, the store sells belts and purses. Citibank has agreed to loan Bundy necessary funds for operating expenses. Bundy has signed a security agreement granting Citibank a security interest in all of the shoes, belts and purses. To be effective, Citibank’s “financing statement” (“Security Agreement” = A) can describe the collateral as:
A. All of the debtor’s inventory
B. All of the debtor’s assets.
C. All of the debtor’s personal property
D. Any of the above.
D
Joe’s Auto, a car dealer, went to National Bank to obtain a $10,000 loan on June 10. On that day, Joe’s signed an application for a loan with National Bank and authorized National Bank to file a financing statement. On June 17, National Bank told Joe’s that its application was approved. On that day Joe’s signed a security agreement which granted the bank a security interest in all of his inventory. National Bank gave Joe’s a cashier’s check for $10,000. On that day, Joe’s had an inventory of 500 cars. On June 20, National Bank filed a financing statement covering Joe’s inventory. On which date was a security interest created in favor of National Bank?
A. June 10
B. June 17.
C. June 20
D. June 10 or June 20.
B.
financing statement not relevant in creation of SI between debtor and creditor. Has to be be really real or politically correct
o application for a loan doesn’t make security agreement
o the fact that bank can file financing statement doesn’t help
o filing of financing statement is not relevant in SI between debtor and creditor
A security agreement can reasonably identify a debtor’s collateral by specifically listing the collateral, describing the collateral by category or describing the collateral as all of the debtor’s assets or personal property.
A. True B. False
B
cant be super generic description – stricter for a security agreement)
Tom lent Della $3,000 pursuant to an oral agreement. A couple of months later, Tom needed to borrow some money from National Bank. He signed a security agreement with National Bank, granting the bank a security interest in his right to payment under the oral agreement with Della. What category best describes Tom’s right under the oral agreement using Chapter 9 classification?
A. An account.
B. General intangible.
C. A contract right.
D. Payment intangible
D
Only requirement is that she pay him back)
A properly filed financing statement remains effective to perfect a security interest in the collateral that the debtor has at the time of the perfection even if the debtor changes its name after the filing.
A. True
B. False
A
On April 1, John Kerry signed a security agreement with the Bank, granting the Bank a security interest in all of his presently existing and after-acquired equipment. The Bank committed itself to lending Kerry $10,000. On that day, John Kerry owned various pieces of equipment. On April 2, Bank filed a properly completed financing statement in the proper place, properly naming the debtor as John Kerry. The collateral was described in the financing statement as “debtor’s presently-owned and after-acquired equipment.” On June 1, John Kerry legally changed his name to John Kennedy, in honor of the former president. It is now December 1. As to the equipment acquired by Kerry/Kennedy on November 15:
A. Bank has no security interest.
B. Bank has a security interest, which has been unperfected since it attached on November 15.
C. Bank has a security interest, which became unperfected on Dec.1.
D. Bank has a perfected security interest at this time.
B
Only good for 4 months after a name change!!! (different question where it is within 4 months) all of the above is answer of that question
Johnnie Cochran borrowed money from Citibank to expand his law practice. To secure the loan, he granted Citibank a security interest in all of his equipment and agreed in writing that Citibank could take the equipment if he defaulted. Citibank failed to comply with the filing requirements under Article 9. Cochran defaulted on his loan. Can Citibank repossess the collateral from Cochran?
A. No, because the security interest is not effective due to Citibank’s failure to comply with the
filing requirements of Article 9.
B. Yes, because Citibank has a valid security interest in the collateral.
C. Yes, because as between creditor and debtor, the creditor only needed to make a good faith effort
to perfect.
D. No, because without filing, third parties lack notice of Citibank’s security interest.
B
The security agreement signed by the debtor stated that the collateral was “all of the debtor’s machinery, equipment, furniture, and fixtures.” The financing statement filed by the creditor described the collateral as “all of the debtor’s machinery, equipment, fixtures, accounts receivable, and inventory.” Assuming that the creditor has given value and that the debtor has rights in the collateral, which of the following statements correctly describes the creditor’s security interest under Article 9?
A. The creditor has a perfected security interest in all of the debtor’s machinery, equipment, furniture, fixtures, accounts receivable and inventory. B. The creditor has a perfected security interest in all of the debtor’s machinery, equipment, furniture, and fixtures. C. The creditor has a valid security interest in all of the debtor’s machinery, equipment, furniture and fixtures. D. The creditor has a valid security interest in the debtor’s machinery, equipment, furniture, fixture, accounts receivable and inventory.
C
Which of the following is not correct under Article 9?
A. A creditor must have a valid security interest before it can perfect it.
B. To create a security interest, the debtor must authenticate the security agreement, or
the debtor must have possession or control of the collateral pursuant to an oral
agreement.
C. To create a security interest, the debtor must have rights in the collateral.
D. To create a security interest, the creditor must have given value.
B
Toys R’Us (“Toys”) wanted to borrow $10,000 from National Bank for business financing. On May 3, Toys and National Bank signed a security agreement that granted National Bank a security interest in Toys’ presently existing and after-acquired inventory. On that day, National Bank also committed to lend Toys $10,000. On May 3, Toys owned an inventory of various toys. On May 10, National Bank filed a financing statement covering Toys’ inventory. On June 20, Toys received another shipment of toys for sale including the latest wii games for sale. On which date was a security interest first created in favor of National Bank?
- A. May 3.
- B. May 10.
- C. June 20.
- D. May 3 and June 20.
C.
When did national bank’s security interest attach to the wii games?
Ace Company owes considerable amount of money to National Bank. Recently, Ace closed certain business transactions in the bank’s office and obtained some valuable promissory notes as a result of those transactions. The bank collected the promissory notes and put them in its own vault for safekeeping. Which of the following statement is correct?
A. The bank’s security interest attaches to the notes because the bank has physical possession of
those notes.
B. The bank’s security interest does not attach to the notes because the bank’s possession of
the promissory notes is not pursuant to any security agreement with Ace Company.
C. The bank does not have any security interest in the notes because the bank has not given any
value.
D. The bank does not have any security interest in the notes because the parties did not sign any
written security agreement.
B
David Ink signed a security agreement granting a security interest in all of his assets to secure the loan from Chase Bank. Chase Bank filed a proper financing statement in the proper filing office. Both the security agreement and the financing statement described the collateral as “all of David’s assets.” David owned, among other things, a collection of Harry Potter books autographed by J.K. Rowling. Does Chase Bank have a security interest in the Harry Potter books?
A. Yes, because David Ink granted Citibank a security interest in all of David Ink’s assets.
B. No, because the security agreement and the financing statement failed to reasonably identify the collateral.
C. Yes, because Chase Bank filed a proper financing statement in the proper filing office.
D. No, because the security agreement failed to reasonably identify the collateral.
D
Dave sent an email to Carl, asking if he could borrow $5,000 for one year at 10 percent, with the obligation secured by Dave’s football-card collection. Carl said that he had to see the football-card collection first. Dave and Carl got together at Dave’s house. After looking at the collection, Carl said: “It is a deal. You can hold onto the collection subject to my security interest.” Carl gave Dave a check for $5,000. Dave failed to pay the loan. Carl sought to exercise his Article 9 rights to the football-card collection. Did a security interest attach to the football-card collection?
A. Yes, because the email from Dave satisfies the requirement of an authenticated security agreement.
B. Yes, because the transaction was a financing transaction within Article 9.
C. No, because Dave never authenticated a security agreement.
D. No, because Carl did not file a financing statement covering the collateral.
C