CLP 8 Sentencing Flashcards
What must the courts have regard to when considering sentencing?
(a)the punishment of offenders,
(b)the reduction of crime (including its reduction by deterrence),
(c)the reform and rehabilitation of offenders,
(d)the protection of the public, and
(e)the making of reparation by offenders to persons affected by their offences.
When considering what the courts have regard to when considering sentencing, do any factors have more importance?
No they have equal weight, but in particular cases some factors may be more important than others
When considering the seriousness of an offence, what aspects do the courts consider?
Culpability
Harm
Aggregating factors
Can defendants be sentenced in the crown court for summary only offences?
No
Where can a defendant be sentenced for an either way case, if they please guilty in the magistrates court?
They can be sentenced in the magistrates’ court or they could be sent to the Crown Court for sentence
Where can a defendant be sentenced for an either way case, if they plead one way or another in the crown court?
They must be sentenced in the Crown Court, they cannot be sent back to the magistrates’ court for sentence
Where can a defendant be sentenced for an either way case, if they please NOT-guilty in the magistrates court and the case stays in the magistrates court?
They can be sentenced in the magistrates’ court or they could be sent to the Crown Court for sentence
Where will a defendant be sentenced for a indictable only offence?
Crown Court
When are Newton Hearings heard?
When the defendant please guilty but disputes the facts of the offence (i.e. they did less than they are being accused of)
What is the first step towards a Newton Hearing
The defence will draft a ‘basis of plea’ and pass to prosecution for their agreement
What if the prosecution do not agree the defendant’s ‘basis of plea’?
- If the basis of please is not absurd and would affect the sentence, a Newton hearing will be held.
- Otherwise sentence as normal
What if the prosecution agree the defendant’s ‘basis of plea’
the court will have to consider if they are happy with the basis. If not, they will move to a Newton hearing
What happens at a Newton hearing?
The prosecution makes an opening speech and calls evidence in the usual way and their witnesses can be cross-examined by the defence. The defendant is able to give evidence and call witnesses if they so wish. Both parties are entitled to address the Judge by way of a closing speech.
How is a Newton hearing decided?
If the prosecution can’t prove their case beyond reasonable doubt, the defendant is sentenced on their version of the facts.
If the prosecution do prove their case, the defendant loses some credit for the guilty plea (normally halved, possibly more if witnesses are called).
How does sentencing work if there is more than one offence?
The court will consider the totality of the sentence.
If offences are related, they will normally run concurrently
If offences aren’t related they will normally run consecutively.
In what circumstances can a defendant ask for an indication of sentence in the magistrate’s court?
- the offence is either-way and Magistrates have accepted jurisdiction at the allocation stage.
- D can ask for an indication
- Magistrates can only indicate custodial or non-custodial
- Only binding if defendant pleads guilty
When can a defendant ask for an indication of sentence in the Crown Court (Goodyear indication)?
- D can ask at anytime before jury return their verdict
before the indication is given:
- D must accept the prosecution facts or have a written basis of plea agreed by the parties and the court.
- whether to give an indication is discretionary
The court must not pass a custodial sentence unless…
it is of the opinion that—
(a)the offence, or
(b)the combination of the offence and one or more offences associated with it,
was so serious that neither a fine alone nor a community sentence can be justified for the offence’
The court must not make a community order unless…
(a) the offence, or
(b) the combination of the offence and one or more offences associated with it, was serious enough to warrant the making of such an order.
When can a court not follow sentencing guidelines?
the court is satisfied that it would be contrary to the interests of justice to do so
What happens at a sentencing hearing?
Prosecution open facts, make submissions & applications
Then
Defence Mitigate
Then
Judge passes sentence
At what point in proceedings can pre-sentence reports be requested?
Pre sentence reports can be ordered at the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing or even at the time of sending.