Clinical Flashcards
Outline what is meant by mental illness using the 4 D’s
Give examples of the 4 D’s in terms of dysfunction etc.
Deviance –is the behaviour rare? Deviate from the norm eg Shouting randomly is not normal
Dysfunction – does behaviour interfere with everyday life? May not be instantly obvious eg unable to work in a workplace
Distress – does the behaviour cause upset. This is treated in isolation as people may appear to cope or be able to function in some areas. Subjective opinion eg behaviour is followed by crying or complaining
Danger – danger to self and others, seen on a scale, and classed as risky eg seeing hallucinations can be dangerous as they may lead you to being distracted and run into a road
Duration- many behaviours may address the above but be short term. Eg Only occurs for a day
Evaluate and explain the limitations and strengths of the 4’Ds as a form of
diagnosis
- Gives clinicians power, to remove rights under Mental Health Act, serious issues with labelling and life changes. Ethics
- Subjectivitybyclinicianininterpretingclient/patients experience for example, DEVIANCE – can be very subjective as it ignores culture and time. What may be the norm in one culture may not in another. Definitions of deviance change over time. Reliability
- Reliability–the4Dsarenotstandardisedinreallife, clinicians may focus on some or every factor
- Basedoninterviews,structured/unstructured,issueswith
self report, e.g. honesty, socially desirable answers, shame etc. Validity
Describe the DSM5 as a diagnostic tool
Has 3 sections:
- Introductions and instructions on how to use it.
- Classification of main mental health disorders and their symptoms. Like the ICD it groups mental disorders into families e.g. Mood disorders (unipolar depression, bipolar ect).
- Other assessment measures such as cultural formulation interviews to help diagnose those from other cultures.
- The multi axis system describes the 5 axis needed to diagnose someone e.g. 5 is the ability to cope with normal life.
- Patients needs to show 5 symptoms or more to be diagnosed with a mental disorder.
Evaluate the DSM 5, in terms of reliability. Focus on at least two forms of reliability
1) Goldstein (1988)** – found that the DSM III was reliable as she tested two experts, using a single blind technique, to diagnose a patients and found high levels of inter rater reliability.
2) Brown et al (2001)*- 362 American patients were interviewed by 2 different experts using the anxiety disorders interview schedule for DSM IV. Brown et al found high levels of inter rater reliability
- Burnham et al found that American Mexicans were more likely to be diagnosed with auditory hallucination as opposed to non-Mexican Americans. This how’s that the DSM is not reliable as it cannot account for cultural differences.
Evaluate the DSM5 in terms of validity, focus on at least two forms of validity
+ Hoffmann – Found that the diagnosis of alcohol abuse had no differences using the DSM or computer interview. The symptoms from the interview matched the DSM so it has concurrent validity.
- Kirk and Kutchins – argued that there had been insufficient training and supervision of interviews. The studies took place in a specialised research setting so its lacks ecological validity and cannot be generalised to real life setting.
Outline what is meant by schizophrenia
It is a long term disorder involving a breakdown in the relationships between thought, emotion and behaviour. It can lead to faults in perception and inappropriate actions and feelings. It is often referred to as a type of psychosis, which means the person may withdraw from reality and from relationships.
Describe the symptoms of schizophrenia, including positive and negative
Positive Symptoms (Type 1) – symptoms that change behaviour or thought, effectively adds to normal behaviour, e.g. Hallucinations, delusions.
Negative Symptoms (Type 2) – symptoms that cause a withdrawal or lack of function, effectively takes away from normal behaviour, e.g. Social withdrawal, mutism, avolition.
Describe the features of schizophrenia
25% of sufferers only experience one episode.
- 25% of sufferers will have symptoms continuously without any breaks.
- 50% of sufferers experience periods of symptoms and periods of recovery.
- With treatment 60 % of patients manage a relatively normal life.
- 1% of the population are diagnosed with schizophrenia.
Evaluate the diagnosis of schizophrenia, in terms of validity and reliability giving examples
According to the DSM V
1. Hallucinations (us. auditory or somatic) 2. Delusions (oft. linked to hallucinations) 3. Disorganised speech
4. Disorganised or catatonic behaviour
5. Negative symptoms
PLUS
Social & occupational dysfunction Duration of at least one month
Which is reliable as this is for all individuals but lacks reliability as can be subjective
However lacks validity as on occasions people with schizophrenia don’t count as having as doesn’t fit criteria for example may only have a duration of 1 week
Describe the neurochemical explanation of schizophrenia
The dopamine hypothesis’ which is a biochemical theory which suggests that schizophrenia is caused by excessive activity at synapses that use dopamine as their primary neurotransmitter. Dopamine is a neurotransmitter that helps control the brain’s reward and pleasure centres as well as being associated with regulating movement and emotional responses. Research suggests that the presence of an excess number of dopamine D2 receptors at the synapse is the main contributing factor to the mental disorder. According to this hypothesis, the increased number of D2 receptors means that there is a faster rate of D2 receptor dopamine complexes formed per unit of time. This therefore causes abnormal functioning of dopamine dependent brain systems by increasing or decreasing brain activity, resulting in schizophrenic positive and/ or negative symptoms. It is possible that an increase in dopamine activity in the mesolimbic pathway contributes to positive symptoms including auditory hallucinations and delusions associated with psychosis. Likewise, it is also possible that dysfunction with dopamine functioning in the mesocortical pathway contributes to the negative symptoms like social withdrawal and alogia. Using evidence from post mortem studies, It is suggested that sensitivity to dopamine can arise from brain lesioning or prefrontal cortex damage. This may lead to lack of dopamine inhibition in the striatum which is an area associated with multiple aspects of cognition including; decision making motivation, reinforcement and reward perception.
Evaluate the neurochemical explanation of schizophrenia using PACEE
P. The dopamine hypothesis has lead to the development of antipsychotics such as haloperidol which work by blocking the D2 receptors that bind with dopamine. This has allowed many to carry on with their lives as productive members of society.
Individual Differences may not work for all
A. Cognitive explanations states that the cause of schizophrenia is due to dysfunctions cognitive processes leading to the development of schizophrenia.
However this can’t be empirically tested like with biological by measuring dopamine levels
C. Is a creditable theory as it has been empirically testedand the theory is supported by measurable concepts such as drug trials making the theory more credible.
The brains of schizophrenics are only ever studied after a diagnosis has been made, we cannot look at the brain before diagnosis
This means that we do not know if the dopamine is the cause of sz or whether developing the illness changes the brain chemistry.
E. - Seeman – found high numbers of D2 receptors in the brain post-mortem. These have a higher chance of bonding with dopamine, leading to higher dopamine activity.
Gottseman and Shield – 48% concordance rate in MZ twins whereas strangers only 1%
EV. - Seeman – there is a problem with direction of causality as it is not clear if higher number of D2 receptors cause schizophrenia or if schizophrenia caused a higher number of D2 receptors.
- Gottesman and Shield did not find a concordance rate of 100% showing that there are other causes of Schizophrenia such as the effects of environment.
Describe one other biological explanation of schizophrenia for example
genetic explanation or diathesis-stress explanation.
Argues there is a gene for the disorder which is inherited and therefore is innate.
- Individuals have a predisposition for developing schizophrenia but can be triggered by environmental factors.
- The risk of developing schizophrenia in a lifetime is 1% however this increases to 2-6% if you have a second degree relative with schizophrenia. This shows there is a genetic factor to schizophrenia.
- The genetic basis is largely corroborated by the twin study carried out by Gottesman and Shield. Study conducted on 62 patients found concordance rates of 48% for MZ twins and 17% for DZ twins. This suggests that there is a genetic factor to schizophrenia.
Evaluate the genetic explanation of schizophrenia using PACEE
P
Can predict if a baby may have sz by looking at family history and can help from a young age
A
C
Single gene has not been identified or isolated as a cause of schizophrenia suggesting that there are other factors contributing to schizophrenia.
Twin studies are difficult to use as its hard to separatenature and nurture, as families share the same environment and MZ twins are reared (brought up similarly).
E.
Gottseman and Shield – 48% concordance rate in MZ twins whereas strangers only 1%
F. Seeman – found high numbers of D2 receptors in the brain post-mortem. These have a higher chance of bonding with dopamine, leading to higher dopamine activity.
Ev
Gottesman and Shield did not find a concordance rate of 100% showing that there are other causes of Schizophrenia such as the effects of environment.
Seeman – there is a problem with direction of causality as it is not clear if higher number of D2 receptors cause schizophrenia or if schizophrenia caused a higher number of D2 receptors.
Describe the cognitive explanation, of schizophrenia using key terminology
Frith’s Model:
- Model distinguishes between conscious and preconsciousprocessing:
➢ Conscious processing: where highest level of cognitive functions takes place, we are aware of this level. Has a limited capacity and carries out one task at a time.
➢ Preconscious processing: takes place without our awareness; its an automatic process and carries out a number of tasks at once.
- Delusional Thinking is a result of the attention filter breaking down allowing unimportant information to get into the conscious level, leading to it being interpreted as something important that needs to be acted upon.
- Auditory Hallucinations are a result of the conscious/preconscious filter breaking down allowing all sounds to enter the conscious level, this results in non-speech sounds being interpreted as speech and experienced as voices.
Hemsley’s Model:
- Schizophrenics are unable to give meaning to new sensory input as they cannot activate or access their schemas.
- This leads to an overload of sensory information that they do not know what to attend to or how to attend it.
- All information they receive is interpreted as a completely new experience to them, external stimuli such as drilling may be interpreted as danger as they have no corresponding schema to the noise.
- Internal speech and thoughts are recognised as external voices causing auditory hallucinations.
Evaluate the cognitive explanation of schizophrenia using PACEE
P. The cognitive explanation of schizophrenia has lead to the development of cognitive behavioural therapy and coping therapy. These treatments have helped schizophrenics to cope with positive symptoms of schizophrenia e.g. Hallucinations.
A. The dopamine hypothesis (biological explanation) would argue that the cause of schizophrenia is due to overactivity of dopamine at the synapses.
C. Is a creditable theory as it has been empirically tested however concepts are theoretical therefore are not falsifiable meaning the theory is not scientific and therefore less credible.
E. Bentall et al found that schizophrenics with hallucinations performed worse compared to normal people and schizophrenics with no hallucinations, as they found cognitive tasks demanding due to limited capacity at the conscious level. They are unable to filter out important information.
EV. The experiment was conducted in a laboratory environment meaning that it has high internal validity however has low ecological validity.