Class Lecture Notes Flashcards
What does Pascal believe on the notion of a God?
- God is so different from us that we are incapable of knowing what/who He is if He exists.
Define the terms evidentialist and non-evidentialist.
Evidentialist - Someone who believes that reasons are necessary for religious belief.
Non-Evidentialist - Someone who believes that reasons are not necessary for religious belief.
Define the terms cognitive and pragmatic in terms of arguments for God’s existence.
Cognitive Arguments - Traditional arguments with a premise and a conclusion.
Pragmatic Arguments - Arguments based on why someone should or should not do something.
What are the three different types of cognitive arguments for God’s existence?
1) Ontological Argument for God’s Existence
2) Teleological Argument for God’s Existence
3) Cosmological Argument for God’s Existence.
What is the only pragmatic argument for God’s Existence?
Pascal’s Wager.
Draw the diagram that represents Pascal’s Wager.
Vertical Axis: 2 Choices - Believe or Don’t Believe
Horizontal Axis: 2 Possibilities - God Exists or He Doesn’t
The Four Squares From Top Right Clockwise: Positive Eternal Benefit, Lost Definable Pleasure, Really Bad Forever, Good That’s Finite and Definable.
What is the argument behind Pascal’s wager?
- That the expected probability of existence is 50/50. Therefore, you should believe and take the wager. If you don’t you stand to lose a lot. If you do, you stand only to lose a little and gain a ton.
Briefly List and Explain the Three Objections to Pascal’s wager?
1) Beliefs are not chosen - Beliefs Seem to happen to us passively. Only exposure to new evidence impacts belief.
2) God would not be pleased with such beliefs.
3) How do we know which God to believe in?
Define doxastic voluntarism.
The notion that people choose their beliefs.
Who is the father of “Modern” Philosophy?
Rene Descartes.
Compare Aristotle and Descartes’ Epistemology.
Aristotle - An empiricist who believed that knowledge started with observation and went further than mere observable facts.
Descartes - Rejects Empiricism. Not a recollections. An existential rationalist that believes reason is supreme above all else.
What is the core of “Modern” Philosophy?
The notion of certainty in foundational knowledge on which all other truths are built. These truths are self-evident and not doubtable.
Describe Descartes’ Metaphysics.
- There’s a dichotomy between mind and body.
- The mind is outside of the physical world.
Define a priori knowledge and postaori knowledge.
A Priori Knowledge - Knowledge that comes before observation.
Postaori Knowledge - Knowledge that comes from observation.
What is Methodological Skepticism?
- Belief/Knowledge, in order to exist, require the possibility of doubt.
- Certainty Must Exist Only In Cases Where Something is Beyond All Possible Doubt. (Doesn’t Have to be Reasonable.
What does Descartes conclude in Mediation I?
- Knowledge cannot be had either a priori or postaori. We could all be dreaming so we can’t trust our sense impressions. Moreover, we cannot find knowledge via reason.
Define phenomenology.
The study of the way something feels.
Do We Have Knowledge according to Descartes?
No.
What does Descartes conclude in Meditation II?
- The only thing that can be known for certain is that something engaged in thought exists.
- This is the origin of the Cogito Ergo Sum: I think; Therefore, I exist.
What does Descartes conclude in Meditation III?
- Argues that God exists. An effect cannot be greater than its cause. Thus, whatever causes the idea cannot be lesser than the idea Himself. We can trust in the existence of a God, to an extent.
Describe the background of Gottfried Leibniz.
- He’s schooled into and holding to Scholasticism
- He’s a philosopher, mathematician, and logician who. invents calculus.
- Very smart, but arrogant.
Describe Leibniz’s Philosophy of Religion.
- God is a perfectly rational being. Everything God does is rational and more rational than our own actions.
- The more rational one is, the more free they are. God is maximally free by extension.
- He’s a determinist with a compatibilistic view of free-will. (Your choice is already determine by your reason, but you still have a choice.
- Believes in a Stoic-like Amor Fati. Love what happens to you because God’s choices are the best that could be.
- Nothing is arbitrary.
Define God’s antecedent will and God’s consequent Will.
God’s Antecedent Will - God’s Will Before considering the Fallen State of the World. Pain or suffering is never in this will.
God’s Consequent Will - Will After considering the Fallen State of the World.
Explain Leibniz’s conception of Necessary Truths.
- If you were trying to imagine other worlds, what truths would you have to transfer?
- These necessary truths include things like Mathematics.
- God cannot change these things since He is rational and to do so would make Him irrational.
Explain Leibniz’s conception of Maximal Creation.
- Creation embodies attributes of complexity and diversity with harmony.
What does Leibniz believe about the world?
- It is the best possible world that could ever exist since God created it.
Define Theodicy.
- The belief that God allows it without causing it.
How does Leibniz view determinism?
- The Future is unknown to us but certain to God.
Define necessary and contingent truth.
Necessary truth - Has to be true in every world.
Contingent Truth - Does not have to be true in every world.
How does Leibniz view Miracles?
- Miracles are laid out ahead of time. They do not break the laws of nature but are a prescribed rule by God. So the monads are doing what they are supposed to do.
What does Leibniz believe is the basis of all substances?
- Monads, a unit of being that is conscious. Awareness is key to being and existence.
What is the chief monad of a human being?
You. The cells are all monads but you are the chief monad.