Claims Flashcards
What is a descriptive claim?
Example?
About the way the world is (can be observed/measured)
There are 13 000 students in UBC first year
What is a causal claim?
Example?
Statement with expected/implied relationship between two claims. (Change on one changes the other)
The US has more gun murders per capital than Canada because the US has more strict gun laws
What is a descriptive question?
Example?
What is the world like/what happens/observed
What percentage of wealth do the richest 20% of Canadians own
What is a causal question?
Example?
Asks about the relationship between two variables with a causal implication, they are about the effect one has on another (CAUSE)
Why do Honda civics have more dents on their bumpers?
What is a normative/prescriptive question?
Example?
What should happen? (Needs value on the outcome)
Should taxes on the rich in canada be raised?
What is an empirical question?
Example?
A question that can be answered by an observation of the world
Do I have a fever?
What is a normative/prescriptive claim?
Example?
A claim on the way things should be
Women should have free menstrual products
What is an empirical claim?
Example?
A statement that can only either be true or false
It will rain tomorrow
In a causal claim you change one variable what will happen to the other?
Example?
The other will change too
The floor is sticky because someone spilled pop on it
(If you dont spill pop the floor won’t be sticky)
Why are empirical and perscriptive claims/questions different?
Example?
Perscriptive needs value judgement
What are some examples of causal verbs?
make, cause, allow, help, have, enable, keep, hold, let, force, and require
What is a a counterfactual?
Example?
Every causal statement has an associated counterfactual statement, not necessarily the logical opposite.
The us invasion of Iraq caused isis to form (casual statement)
If the us never invaded Iraq isis would not have formed (counterfactual statement)
Formula: if c had not happened than e would not have happened
Can prescriptive questions be answered only by empirical findings?
No, because it needs a value judgement in addition to empirical
What is a triggering event?
What needs to be in place for a triggering event?
Generates an outcome only in combination with other structural causes
Highly substitutable
If the counterfactual does not satisfy you, what does that make the event?
Example?
Triggering event
The assasination of archduke Ferdinand caused ww1 (not satisfying there must have been more to it aka structural causes)
What is a necessary condition?
Example?
Condition c must happen for outcome e to emerge (but just because c happens does not guarantee e, just that it CAN)
For war to happen between two superpowers there needs to be accidental escalation. (Necessary condition for war)
What is conjunctural causation?
Outcome e only happens with a combination of causes
A+B=C
What is multiple necessary conditions?
Example?
It is conjuntural causation where all the conditions must be met for the outcome to happen.
A plant needs water AND sunlight to grow (just having one will not make the plant grow)
What is a conditional effect?
Example?
Effect of cause c on e depends on on cause d. The thing doesn’t need to be there it just enhances/changes the situation.
1 cm of plant growth when it doesn’t rain, but 2 cm of plant growth when it rains.
What is a sufficient condition?
Example?
Cause that ALWAYS produces effect
Fire always creates heat
What is multiple causes?
Example?
More than one set of causes that produce the same effect. A can cause E and B can cause E.
A spark can cause a flame, a magnifying glass can cause a flame
A=C
B=C
Can multiple and conjugal causation combine?
Example?
Yes, different recipes can make the same outcome. A+B=E, C+D=E
Milk+sugar=caramel
Condensed milk=caramel
What is a deterministic casual claim?
Example?
What must or cannot happen as a result of the particular conditions
Because your gay you can’t have sex with women
What is a probabilistic causal claim?
Example?
Claim that makes an outcome more or less likely to occur
Eating before swimming make sit more likely for a stomach ache.
What is the difference/importance of structural causes vs individual choices, what matters more? What do we (tend to) focus on more? Why?
Structural matters more, we tend to focus on individual choices more. Individual narratives are easier to follow and tend to be more compelling.
Why are most social science claims probabilistic?
Because there’s almost always a counter example or randomness. True extremes are rare.
What is the most common claim (probabilistic or deterministic) in social science? Why? What’s the difference?
Probabilistic. Because of randomness and counter examples. Probablilisic just make a claim more/less likely, deterministic is very cut and dry, what can or cannot happen, no room for shades of grey.