Civil Procedure Flashcards
Three Traditional Basis for Personal Jurisdiction?
- Consent
- Domiciled in forum
- Present and served in forum
Modern Basis for Personal Jurisdiction?
Minimum contacts provided there is a long-arm statute that keeps with constitutional requirements.
California Long-Arm is to constitutional limits.
Minimum Contacts Analysis (My Professor Frequently Reminds Everyone From California to Study In Overdrive)?
“My Professors Frequently Remind Everyone From California to Study In Overdrive.”
Minimum contacts:
* Purposeful availment of benefits/protections of the state
* Foreseeability of being hauled into court
* Relatedness between contact and claim
* Essentially at home
Fairness factors:
* Convenience
* State’s interests
* Other interests
Two Bases of Federal Subject Matter Jurisdiction?
- Federal Questions
- Diveristy of Citizenship (complete diversity + exceeds $75,000)
Subject Matter Jurisdiction may be raised at any time, even sua sponte.
Determining Citizenship for Diversity?
Person: Domiciled
Corporation: State of Incorporation and/or Principle Place of Business (nerver center)
Unincorporated Association: Domicile of members
Alienage: Foreign citizen and U.S. Citizen
Three Types of California Subject Matter Jurisdiction?
- Unlimited Case: exceeds $25,000
- Limited Case: $25,000 or less
- Small Claims: $10,000 or less (person) or $5,000 or less (business)
Supplemental Federal Jurisdiction?
- Common nucleus of operative fact
- Same transaction or occurrence
Removal to Federal Court?
- Only Defendant may remove
- Thirty days to one year max
Remand?
Removal of action from federal to state court if removal improper or loss of federal jurisdiction.
Proper Venue Analysis?
- Where claim arose; OR
- Where Defendant reside
If none, then any venue where any D is subject to personal jurisdiction.
Fed = district where any D resides if all in one state
CA = county where any D resides, if any; otherwise any county
Definition of “resides” for Venue Analysis?
Person: Domicile
Corporation (Federal): Where subject to personal jurisdiction
Corporation (California): Principle Place of Business or where contract entered into, performed, or breached.
Transfer of Venue?
If original venue is proper:
* Fed: anywhere action could have been filed or all consent
* Cal: anywhere where interests of justice and convenience of parties served
If original venue is improper:
* Fed: Dismiss or transfer
* Cal: may transfer to proper county
Forum Non Conveniens?
Federal: may dismiss or stay if far more appropriate forum elsewhere
California: may dismiss or stay if another forum better considering interests of justice, public factors (i.e., applicable law), and private factors (i.e., convenience, location of witnesses and evidence).
Proper Notice Requirements?
Service of process by reasonable method with opportunity to be heard.
Three Methods of Service?
- Personal service
- Substituted service
- Constructive service (by mail if waived or by publicaiton in California if all else fails)
Substituted Method of Service?
Federal:
* Defendant’s usual abode with someone of suitable age/discretion;
* Defendant’s authorized agent; or
* any method permitted by state law.
California: only allowed if personal service cannot be accomplished with reasonable diligence. If so, must be left at Defendant’s usual abode with competent member of household who is at least 18 years old and mailed to that address.
Federal Choice of Law Analysis?
Erie Doctrine:
* State substantive law
* Federal procedural law
If unclear, apply outcome determinative test (substantive if substantially affects outcome) and balancing test (federal interest vs. state interest)
California Conflict of Law Analysis?
Tort: Comparative impairment test
Contract: if choice of law clause, fine if reasonable basis and no conflict with CA law; otherwise or if not, comparative impairment test.
Comparative impariment test = impairment to each state’s laws.
Pleading Requirements?
Federal: Notice pleading
California: Fact pleading
Four Complaint Requirements?
- Identify the parties
- Statement of claims and subject matter jurisdiction
- Demand for judgment
- Signature