Civil Procedure Flashcards
Personal Jurisdiction:
-traditional
D domiciled in the forum; personally served while present in the forum’ express or implied consent to jurisdiction
Personal Jurisdiction:
Long Arm Statute
assume the stature reaches the constitutional limit
Personal Jurisdiction:
constitutional analysis: definition
does the D have such minimum contacts with the forum so that the exercise of jurisdiction doesn’t offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice?
My Parents Frequently Forgot to Read Children’s Stories
-minimum contacts if: purposeful availment + foreseeability
-fairness: relatedness + convenience + state’s interest
Personal Jurisdiction:
relatedness
-specific = D’s specific contact with the forum
-general = D corp must be “at home” in the forum state
Subject Matter Jurisdiction:
-diversity
diversity: complete diversity + amt in controversy > $75k
aggregation
ok to aggregate claims of one P against one D, but not 2 claims by 2 or more Ps against 2 or more Ds
federal question
“arises under” federal law
supplemental jurisdiction
“common nucleus of operative fact”
BUT, P cannot use suppl juris. in a diversity case solely to overcome a lack of diversity
refusal
Fed Q is dismissed early on; state claim is complex; state law issue predominates
removal
-D can remove if case could have been heard in Fed. Court under subj. matter juris.
*all Ds must agree
*no removal by P, if more than 1 year passed since the case was filed, or in a diversity case where any D is a citizen of the forum.
*once D files permissive counterclaim in state court, he can’t remove
Venue:
-local action
anything re: land
transitory
-district in which ALL Ds reside; if same state but diff districts then any district where one resides; OR substantial part of claim arose
*Corp resides anywhere it does business
transfer
-Consider convenience of parties and Ws and interest of justice:
-public factors re: applicable law, what community should bear the burden of jury service
forum nonconveniens
-far more appropriate court exists elsewhere (the Court would then dismiss w/o prejudice or stays the case):
—location of Ws and evidence; undue hardship for D; availability of adequate alternative forums; use of judicial resources; public policy
*applicable when transfer is impossible bc the court is in diff judicial system, but NEVER granted if P is a resident of the forum.
Service:
-summons and complaint; personal service OR
substituted service
-left with someone of suitable age and discretion who resides there
service on agent
Delivering a copy of the summons and complaint to an agent authorized to receive service
waiver my mail
process mailed to D; formal service waived if returned in 30 days. If no return, personal or sub service is required
immunity
if in the state as a W or a party
timing
-must serve the D within 90 days after complaint filed, or Court must dismiss with prejudice unless P shows good cause
Which law governs the dispute?:
-Erie Doctrine
-in diversity and suppl. juris. cases, the Federal Court must apply state substantive law: SoL; choice of law rules; elements of claim/defense; rules on tolling SoL
*BUT the Court uses Federal Procedural Law
process to analyze substantive law
-analyze if outcome determinative (SL); balance of interest; avoid forum shopping (SL)
*if Fed law conflicts, Fed. law prevails
Interlocutory Injunctions:
-preliminary injunction
-preserves status quo pending determination of merits of litigation
*must provide notice to adverse party
*must show: (1) imminent irreparable injury (non-monetary); (2) no adequate legal remedy;
(3) substantial likelihood of success on the merits;
(4) a balance of the hardships;
(5) not adverse to public interest
temporary retraining order
-preserves the status quo of subject matter of litigation, and prevents irreparable harm until PI hearing
*must provide notice UNLESS: (i) immediate and irreparable injury; (ii) effort to give notice; and (iii) provide security in case party wrongfully restrained/enjoined
*must show same elements as PI
*lasts 14 days unless an extension is granted
Proper Pleadings?
-Rule 11
-attorney must sign all pleadings, etc. to certify that: (i) no improper purpose; (ii) legal contentions are warranted by law; (iii) factual contentions and denials have evidentiary support
*can be raised by opposing party w/in 21 day safe harbor OR by court sua sponte
the claim
-must plead FACTS supporting plausible claim enough to put D on notice and prepare reasonable response
*(Iqbal/Twombly standard) + basis of Subj. matter juris + demand for relief
D Response
-must be within 21 days of service: can be motion for more def statement/motion to strike; Motion or Answer.
-waivable: lack of personal juris; improper venue; insufficient service of process
-non-waivable: failure to state a claim, failure to join indispensable party; lack of SMJ
requirements for the Answer
-must respond (admit, deny, lack of info) + raise any affirmative defenses (SoL, SoF, res judicata, self defense)
right to amend
-P once within 21 days after D serves first response
-D once within 21 days after D serves answer
-if no right, seek leave of the court (the court will consider delay, prejudice, futility)
supplemental
-pertains to matters that occur after initial pleading
-permission from the court REQUIRED
Defendant’s Claims:
-counterclaims/Cross complaint against P
-compulsory if arises from the same transaction or occurrence