Civil Law: Law of Obligations Flashcards
What are the two main parts of the 2nd Book of the Civil Code (BGB) structure?
- General Part: Applies to all types of obligations.
- Specific Part:
Contains special rules for:
-Contractual obligations: e.g., purchase contracts, lease agreements, service contracts.
-Obligations imposed by law: e.g., torts (delictual acts).
What types of contractual obligations are included in the Specific Part of the BGB?
- Purchase contracts (Kaufvertrag)
- Lease agreements (Mietvertrag)
- Service contracts (Dienstvertrag)
What Additional Legal Sources does the Law of Obligations include?
-
Product Liability Act (Produkthaftungsgesetz):
- Covers liability of manufacturers/importers for defective products.
-
Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch):
- Contains special rules for merchants (Kaufleute).
What is the Law of Obligations, and what does it govern?
The Law of Obligations governs the relationship between a debtor (Schuldner) and a creditor (Gläubiger), where one party is entitled to demand performance (§ 241 I BGB).
What is meant by “Freedom of Content” in the Law of Obligations?
Provisions are optional (dispositiv) and apply only if the parties don’t agree otherwise.
What are the two types of obligations under the “Beginning of Obligations,” and how are they created?
- Contractually Based Obligations (Vertragliche Schuldverhältnisse): Created through an agreement between parties.
- Statutory Obligations (Gesetzliche Schuldverhältnisse):Arise by fulfilling legal requirements
What are examples of statutory obligations, and what do they involve?
- Delictual acts/Torts (§ 823 BGB): Liability for harm caused.
- Unjustified enrichment (§ 812 BGB): Obligation to return gains obtained without legal basis.
- Unauthorized management of affairs (§§ 677 BGB):Acting without authority for another’s benefit.
What are the different types of duties in obligations according to § 241 BGB, and what do they entail?
- Primary Duties (§ 241 I BGB): Main performance obligations, e.g., paying the purchase price or delivering goods (§ 433 BGB).
- Secondary Duties (Nebenleistungspflichten): Support proper fulfillment of primary duties; arise from agreements, statutes (§ 448 II BGB), or good faith (§ 242 BGB).
- Ancillary Duties (§ 241 II BGB): Protect rights like property and health; include duties to inform about risks or past accidents (linked to § 242 BGB).
What are the performance modalities for obligations under BGB?
- Place of Performance (§ 269 BGB):
Default: Debtor performs at their location (Holschuld).
May involve delivery (Bringschuld) or shipping (Schickschuld). - Time of Performance (§ 271 BGB): If unspecified, performance is due immediately.
- Right to Refuse (§ 273 BGB): Debtor can refuse performance if they have a valid counterclaim from the same legal relationship.
What are the obligations regarding ascertained and unascertained goods in a contract?
- Stückschuld (Ascertained Goods): A specific, identified item is owed (e.g., a painting). Obligation ends if the item is destroyed or lost.
- Gattungsschuld (Unascertained Goods): Goods belonging to a class (e.g., apples).
* Vorratsschuld: Supplied from debtor’s stock.
* Konkretisierung: Obligation shifts to specific items upon designation. - If unascertained goods are destroyed before designation, the debtor may need to provide substitutes.
How can third persons fulfill obligations on behalf of the debtor?
- § 267 BGB: A debtor may use third parties to render performance.
- Erfüllungsgehilfe (Vicarious Agent): A person acting with the debtor’s knowledge and intent within their duties, e.g., employees or subcontractors
How are third parties included in contracts under BGB?
- Contracts for the Benefit of a Third Party (§ 328 BGB): Creditor demands performance for a third party, who gains a direct claim against the debtor.
- Contracts with Protective Effect for Third Parties: Protect related third parties (e.g., a parent-child relationship). They cannot demand performance but can claim compensation if harmed.
What are the types of contract breaches under BGB and their general conditions?
- General Damages (§ 280 I BGB): Breach of duty causing damages, exempt if no fault.
- Damages for Delay (§ 286 BGB): Debtor default required (e.g., missed deadlines).
- Damages Instead of Performance (§§ 281, 282, 283 BGB): Conditions include failure after request (§ 281), unreasonable performance (§ 282), or impossibility (§ 283).
- Pre-Contractual Breach (§§ 311 II, 241 II BGB): Breaches during pre-contractual negotiations, e.g., false information, unjustified negotiation end.
What are the prerequisites for damages under § 280 I BGB?
- Contractual Obligation (Schuldverhältnis): A valid relationship exists.
- Breach of Duty (Pflichtverletzung): Obligations violated.
- Responsibility (Verschulden): Fault of obligor (§ 276 BGB).
- Causal Damages (Kausaler Schaden): Damages result from breach (§§ 249 et seq. BGB).
Legal Consequence: Obligor compensates the obligee for damages.
What is the principle of compensation under § 249 I BGB?
The liable party must restore the injured party to the position they would have been in if the damage had not occurred.