Civil Courts and other forms of Dispute Resolution Flashcards
Civil Law
• Establish and uphold the rights of the individual
• cover a wide range of matters and arise when an individual or a business believes that there rights have infringed on in same way
- tort, family law, employment law, personal injury claims, contractual disputes
• Case started by claimant (plaintiff)
• County Court
• High Court
• Standard of proof needed
- balance of probabilities
• Decision made by judge
• Decision liable or not liable
• Powers of court
- compensation
- injunction
- court orders
ADR
• alternative dispute resoluton
• must be attempted first
• Negotiation
• Mediation
• Conciliation
• Arbitration
Pre Trial Procedures
• a pre action protocol is aimed at resolving disputes before they need to get to court.
• they explain the steps each party is due to undertake when starting a claim and the conduct that is expected of them
• if a settlerent cannot be reached then issuing a claim would be the next step
- claims are started by the completion of on N1 form
- claims are filed at a County Court office or the High Court (value dependent based on the track system) or onine for a debt claim
- a fee is charged for issung the claim
Civil Courts
Supreme Court
Court of Appeal
Divisional Court
High Court
County Court
claim started in Small Claims Court
Less than £10,000
Up to £1,000 in a personal injury claim
claim started in County Court
Less than £100,000
Between £1,000-£50,000 in a personal injury claim
claim started in either County or High Court
More than £100,000
More than £50,000 in a personal injury claim
Small Claims Track
• Less than £10,000
• Up to £1,000 for personal injury
• The claim will be heard by a District Judge and lawyers are not encouraged
• The hearing should be approx 2-3 hours and each party will be allowed a minimum number of witnesses
- limited number of shared witness
- last half a day
- don’t require legal representation
Fast Track
• £10,000 to £25,000
• A case allocated to this track will have a strict timetable set at a maximum of 30 weeks.
• If parties do not follow the timetable the claim can be thrown out or judgement awarded.
• One day maximum for a hearing in an open court with limited witnesses and heard by a Circuit judge
- more experienced than a district judge
• Each party can be represented by a lawyer
• Should be heard in one day
Multi Track
• £25,000 to £50,000
• Usually allocated to the County Court with a Circuit Judge.
• The case is strictly managed with a timetable.
• There is a set number of witnesses, set guidelines for disclosure of documents and the length of time the case will take
- higher number of witnesses
• If it involves an issue of more than £50,000, complex points of law it is likely to be passed to the High Court.
- complex cases only
- high value
- heavily publicised
County Court Jurisdiction
• Hear cases up to £100,000
• Deals with civil cases which are dealt with by a circuit or district judge
• Most common cases:
- landlord and tenant disputes such as possession (eviction), rent arrears, repairs
- consumer disputes such as faulty goods or services
- personal injury claims (injuries caused by negligence) such as traffic accidents or accidents at work less than £50,000
- discrimination cases
- debt problems such as a creditor seeking payment
- partnership, trusts and inheritance
- small claims, fast track and some multi track cases
High Court Jurisdiction
Family Division
• complex divorce cases
• dissolution of civil partnership
• wardship
• adoption
• all cases related to children
- The Children Act 1989
• domestic violence
• appeal from magistrates
county courts in matrimonial cases
• affairs of people who are mentally i’ll
• simple probate matters
Kings Bench Division
• large/complex compensation claims
• contract and tort cases › £50,000
• admiralty court
• commercial court
- review actions of organisations owned by the state
- acted legally with libel and slander by way of judicial review
Negotiation
• The least binding form of ADR
• Not enforceable by the courts more likely to be in more of a discussion
• Like a neighbourly dispute
Mediation
• Neutral person helps parties reach a compromise solution acting as a facilitator
• Parties have control over the resolution process
• Parties may withdraw at any time
• Mediator does not offer an opinion unless asked
• Parties may choose the method of mediation
• Parties must agree to the compromise
• Formal mediation
- a formal settlement conference is like a mini trial but there are no binding results. Credit examples e.g. Relate
Conciliation
• Neutral person helps parties reach a compromise solution
• Conciliator plays an active role suggesting grounds for compromise or settlement
• Parties have control over the process
• Parties may withdraw at any time
• Parties must agree to the compromise