Civ. Pro. Flashcards
What does a sufficient claim for relief need?
FRCP 8(a) - Jurisdiction, demand for relief
(1) short plain statement of a claim; (2) name, blame, claim; (3) legal sufficiency; (4) factual sufficiency
Legal Sufficiency
name ALL elements of the claim within the pleading
Factual Sufficiency
(1) ignore unsupported legal conclusions, recitals of cause of action; (2) assume all factual allegations are true; (3) determine if plausible (Twiqbal)
Can a pl. make alternative claims?
FRCP 8(d) - yes, but at least one of the claims must be sufficient
Formation guidelines for pleadings
FRCP 10
Can def. make alternative defenses?
only if the def. is genuinely in doubt about what happened
Can def. challenge the sufficiency of the pl. complaint?
Yes, through FRCP 12 motion
What is needed for a pl. to plead fraud or mistake?
FRCP 9 - (1) state w/ particularity the circumstances; (2) make general allegation of def. conduct; (3) factual contentions must be able to be proved by future evidence (11(b)(3))
Elements of a Preliminary Injunction
(1) establish the likelihood of success on the merits; (2) pl. must prove likely to suffer from irreparable harm in absence of prelim. injunction; (3) the equities balance in the favor of the pl.; (4) prelim. injunction is in the best interest of the public
Voluntary dismissal
FRCP 41(a) - (1) filed by the pl.; (2) notice of dismissal prior to def. ans. or MSJ; OR (3) stipulation of dismissal (signed by both parties); OR motion filed with the court requesting court to dismiss the claims
Involuntary Dismissal
FRCP 41(b) - (1) filed by the def.; (2) pl. failed to comply with the FRCP
Def. options in responding to a complaint
FRCP 8(b) & 12(b) motions - if def. needs additional information outside of the complaint to dispute the claim, do nothing (mo. in the future)
Default
when def. does not appear at all for the case
Entry of Default
request to the clerk to enter default on the docket for def. failure to show up
Entry of Default Judgment
From the clerk 55(b)(1) - (1) relief sum is certain, can be shown with affidavit; (2) def. did not appear EVER
From Judge (all other cases outside of above) 55(b)(2) - (1) apply to the court for default judgment; (2) pl. must send written notice at least 7 days prior to the hearing
Amending Pleadings Before Trial
FRCP 15(a)(1) - once as a matter of right; no later than 21 days after serving it; if pleading that req. response (complaint/12(b) mo.) 21 days after service of resp. pleading or motion, whichever is EARLIER
FRCP 15(a)(2) - all other cases: ONLY w/ opposing party consent OR courts leave
Amending Pleadings During & After Trial
15(b)(1) during trial - if party obj. evidence is not within issues raised in pleadings, court may grant leave to amend; should freely permit when (1) it will aid in presenting the merits; AND (2) obj. party fails to show the court that amending will prejudice their action/defense on the merits
15(b)(2) after trial - party may move to amend pleadings after trial to conform with evidence
Relation Back of Amendments
15(c) - amendment to pleading relates back when (1) law that provides the statute of limitations allows it; (2) amendment asserts claim/defense arising from that set out or attempted to set out in original complaint; (3) change party or name of party (a) received notice of action; and (b) knew or should have known of action
Supplementing Pleadings
15(d) - w/ motion AND reasonable notice; transaction or occurrence that happened AFTER the date of the original pleading
What information is needed from an attorney to avoid sanctions?
FRCP 11 - name, address, email, phone #
What if an atty does not follow guidelines for pleading requirements?
opposing party MUST notify party of issue w/ pleading, give chance for party to fix issue, if not fixed, court is to strike the pleading
What other ways can an atty get sanctioned for?
11(b) - (1) paper presented for improper purpose; (2) legal contentions are NOT warranted by existing law; (3) factual contentions DO NOT have evidentiary support; (4) denials of factual contentions are NOT warranted on evidence or based on reasonable belief or lack of info
28 U.S.C. 1927 - atty. multiplied proceedings unreasonably or vexatiously