Christianity, Gender & Sexuality Flashcards
After the reformation (reform protestantism) what happened in regard to biblical criticism?
Translations of the Bible in languages other than Latin become more widespread - allowing greater study and understanding.
What approach would be opposed to biblical criticism?
Literalism - it claims we should just take the words of the Bible literally.
What does Ken Ham argue about the Bible?
It is all or nothing - you cant say some parts are true, and some false, either it’s all true or all false.
For liberal Christians, who believe the Bible is a human record of divine events, what is biblical criticism about?
It’s more about making the words of ancient humans relevant to modern times than figuring out the ‘true meaning’.
What is the problem with liberal views of inspiration?
It is extremely subjective - it opens scripture up to individual interpretation.
How can the Bible hold authority if it derives from human minds?
Feminist biblical criticism is usually a variety of what view of inspiration?
Liberal
What is the concept of ‘biblical patriarchy’?
The Bible is man-made for the purpose of subjugating women.
Post-Christian feminist theologians regard this the patriarchy in the Bible as evidence for what?
The Christian God not existing;
- It’s man-made, as they are given a superior position to womeb.
- God didn’t make men, men made God.
1 Timothy 2:11-13
“A woman should learn in quietness and full submission. I do not permit a woman to teach or assume authority over a man; she must be quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve.”
What is an ordination ritual?
Where someone becomes a church leader - involves laying on of the hands, prayer & the invocation of the Spirit of God
Give 3 examples of women in leadership positions in the early church
Junia, a female apostle (Romans 16:7)
- This was said to be a ‘mistranslation’ and all 12 apostles were men.
Female deacons, (1 Timothy 3:11)
Prophetesses, (Acts 21:9)
Key dates for women in Christianity, 1990-2020
1992 - CoE voted to ordain women.
1993 - voted to allow congregations to opt out of accepting women priests.
March 1994 - 32 women ordained in CoE, over 400 male clergy protested by leaving.
2014 - Pope Francis affirmed the traditions of not ordaining women in the RCC, but showed a willingness to allow female deacons.
2016 - RCC commissioned a study to look into the issue
Key dates for women in Christianity, 1990-2020
1992 - CoE voted to ordain women.
1993 - voted to allow congregations to opt out of accepting women priests.
March 1994 - 32 women ordained in CoE, over 400 male clergy protested by leaving.
2014 - Pope Francis affirmed the traditions of not ordaining women in the RCC, but showed a willingness to allow female deacons.
2016 - RCC commissioned a study to look into the issue
1 Corinthians 14:34
St Paul seems to be against female ordination.
“The women should keep silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be in submission, as the Law also says”
1 Corinthians 11:4-5
This contradicts the previous quote, implying that women DO speak in church.
What does this lead some to think?
“Every women who prays or prophesies with her head uncovered dishonours her head.”
Some are led to think that 14:34 was added later, and not St Paul’s writings.
Why does the Catholic Church argue that there should be no female priests?
Because priests are descended from the ‘line of peter’ - from Jesus’ disciples.
Since Jesus has no female disciples, there should be no female priests.
Quote from Catholic Conservative MP, Anne Widdicome
‘A woman can no more be expected to represent Christ than a man could represent the Virgin Mary’
Karl Rahner on Jesus’ gender & his representation
Jesus’ gender was insignificant when it comes to priestly sacramental representation since it’s Christ’s spiritual qualities that matter - it’s heretical to suggest otherwise.
What does Daphne Hampson argue?
Because Christianity is a historical religion, its commitments are inevitably anchored to a past tradition, which she claims, is patriarchal.
What’s different in other moral areas compared to Christianity?
In other moral areas, we’re free to evolve and change traditional beliefs if there is good cause to.
In Christianity, because its founding principles and traditions are seen as divinely ordained, such freedom doesn’t exist.
What two arguments does Hampson highlight?
1 - the explicit sexism of the depiction of women in biblical stories.
2 - the underlying themes & principles of Christian theology derive from the mind set of men living under patriarchy l.
An underlying theme is Christianity’s ‘bi-polar’ view of reality - a transcendent God is good & humanity is lower and opposite to God.
What is then done which Hampson argued reflects a patriarchal outlook?
This division is then gendered; God described with male language while humanity is conceptualised with feminine language.
E.g. Israel & the Church being the bride of Christ