Childhood (1) Flashcards
What did Wagg (1992) argue about childhood?
Wagg (1992) argues that there is no one universal experience of childhood and as such childhood is not biological but socially constructed; something created and defined by society.
What is childhood?
Childhood is a special time of life and that children are fundamentally different from adults.
What evidence is there that childhood is a social construct?
~Different from childhood in the past = historical comparison.
~Childhood in this country is different from other societies = cross-cultural comparison.
What are children seen as?
~Physically and psychologically immature.
~Not yet competent to run their own lives.
~In need of protection.
~In need of socialisation to learn to become a responsible adult.
In which ways is childhood separate from childhood?
Laws and policies
Products and services
Lifestyle/activities
Innocent and vulnerable
How are laws and policies separate in childhood and adulthood?
There are laws and policies in place regulating what children are and not allowed to do, and controlling their activities:
~Restrictions on alcohol consumption.
~Age of consent for sex and marriage.
~Compulsory education until age 18, keeping children out of the adult work place.
~Laws protecting children and describing them as “vulnerable people”.
How are products and services separate in childhood and adulthood?
Children use different products and services to adults: ~Cloths ~Play areas and nurseries ~Toys ~Books ~TV programmes ~Food
How are lifestyle/activities separate in childhood and adulthood?
Children do different daily activities and have a different lifestyle to adults:
~Pilcher argues childhood is a “golden age” of happiness and innocence where most of children’s time is leisure time.
~Childhood are kept separate from adult activities and the adult world of work.
How are innocent and vulnerable separate in childhood and adulthood?
Because of this happiness and innocence, children are seen as vulnerable and in need of protection:
~Safeguarding and child protection laws.
~Kept separate from adults and the dangers of the adult world.
~Children live their lives largely in the protective bubble of the private sphere of the family.
How did Punch (2001) study into cross cultural differences in childhood?
Punch (2001) studied childhood in rural Bolivia and found children from age of 5 are expected to work both in the home and community.
How did Malinowski (1957) study into cross cultural differences in childhood?
Malinowski (1957) studied children’s sexual behaviour among the Trobriand Islanders in the South Pacific. Found adults took an attitude of ‘tolerance and amused interest’ towards children’s sexual explorations and activities.
What did Pilcher argue about the modern western view of childhood?
Pilcher argues that the modern western view of childhood also sees children as separate from adults, and that childhood is a distinct life stage.
How is laws and policies different for adults children?
There are laws and policies in place regulating what children are and not allowed to do, and controlling their activities:
~Restrictions on alcohol consumption.
~Age of consent for sex and marriage.
~Compulsory education until age 18, keeping children out of the adult work place.
~Laws protecting children and describing them as “vulnerable people”.
How is products and services different for adults children?
Children use different products and services to adults: ~Cloths ~Play areas and nurseries ~Toys ~Books ~TV programmes ~Food
How is lifestyle/activities different for adults children?
Children do different daily activities and have a different lifestyle to adults:
~Pilcher argues childhood is a “golden age” of happiness and innocence where most of children’s time is leisure time.
~Children are kept separate from adult world of work.
How is innocent and vulnerable different for adults children?
Because of this happiness and innocence, children are seen as vulnerable and in need of protection:
~Safeguarding and child protection laws.
~Kept separate from adults and the dangers of the adult world.
~Children live their lives largely in the protective bubble of 5e private sphere of the family.
How is the modern western view childhood evidence that childhood is socially constructed?
The modern western view of childhood is not universal and it hasn’t always been this way.
Other cultures see childhood very differently and don’t see such a big difference between children and adults.
The view of childhood in the West had also significantly changed over time.
How did Punch (2001) study cross cultural differences in childhood?
Punch (2001) studied childhood in rural Bolivia and found children from the age of 5 are expected to work both in the home and community.
How did Malinowski (1957) study cross cultural differences in childhood?
Malinowski (1957) studied children’s sexual behaviour among the Trobriand Islanders in the South Pacific. Found adults took an attitude of ‘tolerance and amused interest’ towards children’s sexual exploitation’s and activities.
What did Aries (1960) argue about historical changes to childhood?
Aries (1960) argued that children in the Middle Ages were like “mini adults”. He conducted research by looking at paintings from the 10th-13th century, determining that in this time period adults and children were not seen as distinct from one another and that childhood was in no way a ‘special’ or ‘separate’ time.
What did Aries (1960) find?
In the 10th-13th century childhood did not exist, but as time went on to the 20th century “the century of the child”, childhood is seen as a very special time.
What are the strengths of Aries (1960)?
+Aries has evidence that childhood is socially constructed. Childhood has changed.
+Shorter (1975) supports the idea that childhood has changed. He argues that when Infant mortality rate was high, parents would place less value on their children as they wouldn’t be likely to live past the age of 1.
What are the weaknesses of Aries (1960)?
- Pollock argues it would me more correct to say that childhood was “different” in the Middle Ages as opposed to non-existent.
- Paintings from the Middle Ages which are likely to depict only middle class people, making his research unrepresentative and class biased. His research is also based purely on his own interpretation of art, not factual photographs.
What are the reasons for changes in childhood in the 19th to 20th century?
~Laws and policies ~Compulsory schooling (1880) ~Children’s rights ~Decline in family size ~Growing interests in child development and health
How has laws and policies changed childhood?
The factories acts in the 1880s gradually removed children from the workplace.
Children went from being an economic asset to being economically dependent on their parents.
Some laws are specific to children such as restrictions on drinking, sex and smoking.
What was laws and policies contributions to modern western childhood?
Children have to go to school so different to work meaning that they get a childhood.
How has compulsory schooling changed childhood?
This further extended children’s dependency on their parents.
Children are no longer an economic asset but but a burden, completely dependent on their parents.
What has compulsory schooling contributed to Morden western childhood?
Prolonged childhood.
More equality not just rich kids going to school.
How has children’s right changed childhood?
Children have more rights than in the past e.g. education, healthcare, protection from abuse.
Parents have a “responsibility” to protect their children rather than “rights” over them.
What has children’s rights contributed to Morden western childhood?
Allows them to be children
They get more freedom
How has decline in family size changed childhood?
Having fewer children means that parents make a greater emotional and financial investment in the children they do have.
More value is placed on then because there are less of them.