Chaters 7 - ? Flashcards
What do Supreme Court Justices require of lawyers when presenting their arguments?
Lawyers are expected to make eye contact with each Justice.
What is the function of majority opinions of SCOTUS?
Majority opinions established legal precedents, often referred to as common law, from which future cases are judged.
How do the opposing arguments of lawyers assist Justices?
By identifying and presenting legal issues, lawyers help Justices to understand both sides of the equation, and therefore, assist Justices in synthesizing issues presented before them.
What did Chief Justice Rehnquist say about lawyers who have poor oral presentations?
“…that a poorly presented case is apt to be a poorly decided case…”
What are the two responsibilities of oral advocates?
- Lawyer must put forth the best arguments possible for their clients.
- They must recognize their role and responsibility in helping mold law.
What was the first act of the Courts?
To vet and approve lawyers to practice law.
When were the first three lawyers permitted to practice law before the court?
February 5, 1790
What date did the Supreme Court Justices meet for their initial session?
February 3rd, 1790
How many more lawyers were accepted to practice law in SCOTUS, after the first three lawyers were admitted, by the end of SCOTUS’ first term?
25.
How many lawyers were added to the docket during the SCOTUS’ second term?
29.
How many lawyers were added to the Supreme Court’s docket each year for the first ten years of the court?
5.
At the time O’Connor wrote Out of Order how many lawyers on average were admitted to the Supreme Court each year?
4,300.
What was the Supreme Court’s most controversial case in the first three years of its existence?
Chisholm v. Georgia.
What did Chisholm v. Georgia concern?
Executor Alexander Chisholm accused the state of Georgia of failing to recompense Captain Robert Farquhar for commodities he provided during the Revolutionary War.
Why was Chisholm v. Georgia important?
It questioned whether Georgia, and therefore any other state, was immune to being sued as a sovereign entity. This case helped determine the power of state governments.
Who did Georgia send as counsel?
Nobody.
What Chief Justice was Chisholm v. Georgia argued before?
Justice John Marshall.
What was the SCOTUS’ decision in the Chisholm v. Georgia case?
That private citizens could bring suit against states, and those states did not possess sovereign immunity.
What amendment did Congress pass that overruled the Chisholm v. Georgia ruling?
The 11th amendment.
Who was William Pinkney?
A prominent lawyer who started his legal career in Britain in 1812, prior to the start of the Revolutionary War. He served as the U.S. Attorney General too.
How many cases did William Pinkney argue before the Supreme Court?
84
What was William Pinkney’s specialty?
Maritime law.
What was one of Pinkney’s most important cases?
Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon.
What did the Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon case concern?
An American merchant ship had been seized by France and its rightful owners found the ship Philadelphia.
What was Chief Justice Marshall’s ruling in Schooner Exchange v. McFaddon?
That American courts do not possess authority over a ship seized by a sovereign nation.
How did Pinkney dress and what was his manner?
He was a posh dresser who many perceived as snobbish, but he was in fact humble. He once apologized to a fellow lawyer (Daniel Webster) who accused Pinkney of insulting him. Pinkney seemed surprised but promptly apologized.
Who was Daniel Webster?
Daniel Webster was the only lawyer who may have topped Pinkney’s legal prowess.
Who used “…classical allusions and rhetorical flourishes” and was known for his ability to recall legal precedent and historical evidence at will?
Daniel Webster.