Character Evidence (Ch. 8) Flashcards
Evidence of past acts to prove that a person acted in a certain way
Character evidence
the potential for a piece of proposed evidence to be misused (usually given too much weight) by the trier of fact
potential prejudice
the degree to which a potential piece of evidence helps prove a proposition; the value or strength of a fact in proving what the party seeks to establish
probative value
Provisions in the Criminal Code that forbid the admission of evidence of a complainant’s sexual history to support an inference that they are more likely to have given consent or are less worthy of belief
Rape shield provisions
Evidence that shows that an accused committed similar offences in the past, which may be admitted provided that it is relevant in establishing an important matter other than the accused’s predisposition to commit that type of offence
Similar fact evidence
When is similar fact evidence admissible?
When the prosecution can prove to the trial judge that the probative value is higher than the potential prejudice
Prejudice that results from the admission of evidence of bad character showing the accused to be a morally bad person and leading the trier of fact to conclude they are guilty
moral prejudice
This type of prejudice applies to evidence that, if admitted, may confuse or distract the trier of fact from the issue it must decide.
reasoning prejudice
When the prosecution asks to stay and can start the case again within one year
prosecutorial stay
s. 579 Criminal Code
pre-trial motion by the judge (when it’s done, it’s done)
judicial stay
s. 37.3 Canada Evidence Act
evidence of an accused person’s psychiatric tendency to act a certain way
propensity or disposition evidence
Why is a bad idea for a person with a criminal record to testify?
- their criminal record likely becomes admissible as evidence
- they can be cross-examined about their criminal record
- for rape cases with previous offenses, it’s too hard for the trier of fact to look past the previous offense, even if it had been 8 years